Click here for PDF format of this essay
THE ULTIMATE CATASTROPHE
the dangers of emotional extremism
A Study in Thought
sa047
by
Marius Heuff
Chapter 1
Content
A small vignette.
The figure-skater.
Tears of relief and gratitude.
The sensations of beauty and happiness.
The value of long-term goals.
The fusion between goal and achievement.
No trace of a cheap triumph.
A sense of indebtedness to the people
Emotional resonance.
True achievement does not have to lead to an egocentric victory.
Sentimentality; an emotional over-reaction.
The need to understand our own behaviour.
1 Ladies and gentlemen, we will
begin our discussion about the depressive aspects of the extremes in human
behaviour, by recalling a small vignette that happened just recently, and is
still vividly etched in my mind. Just the other night, my wife and I watched
the finish of the women's Olympic figure-skating competition. The East European
girl had won and was standing on the platform, ready to accept the gold medal.
2 What does it matter what her
name was, or, which country she represented, because she became, at least, for
me, at that moment, a superb symbol of human achievement, and, the tears, that
were streaming down her cheeks as she looked with a steady gaze at the
unfolding flag of her country, moved me more than anything had moved me in
years.
3 I was not quite sure, why her
tears and her smile moved me so much, because I am not particularly interested
in figure-skating, and I hardly remembered having seen her before. But, I
realised, suddenly, that the emotions of this young, attractive and athletic
girl, standing there on this Olympic platform, after a long and tense
competition in a strange country, represented the feelings of gratitude and
quiet happiness; after a struggle of many years to achieve something
worthwhile.
4 Of course, she had worked hard
for this, for many years, and yet, in stead of a victorious and self-conscious
smile of pride and glory, this girl was crying and smiling at the same time,
trying to hold back her tears. Certainly, I do not know, why she was crying,
and the exact reasons are not that important. What was important to me, was the
realisation, that these simple tears and her half-smiling, staring gaze were
more moving and genuine than most of the dramas, comedies, family-shows and
other vehicles for entertainment, which fill the television screens in our
times. In our society, these emotions are often portrayed in somewhat dubious
forms of art, because most art-forms are heavily tainted with commercial
considerations and a variety of "hard-sell" advertising techniques.
5 Certainly, here and there, we
see a glimpse of genuine and moving artistry, but, so many of the contemporary
programs on television, or in the movie-theaters, are blatant attempts to
arouse our emotions for the sake of making us shell-out some of our earnings.
As always, the efforts of producers and editors are geared towards the
question; will it sell? Will we be able to make a profit? Will our sponsors
like it, and pay the high fees for their advertisements?
6 I am sick and disgusted with
the rape of our communications media. Sometimes, I would like to throw the
radio and television out the door and isolate myself completely from this
commercial bias, but, then, I realise, that I am part of my society, and, that
I would not contribute anything, if I would just shut myself off from my
environment.
7 And, last night, I was happy
that I watched for a moment, when this young girl from a far-away country cried
silently. I think, that the cameraman also felt a twinge of emotion, because
the camera dwelled nearly all the time on her face. "Here", I
thought, " you, commercial enterprises, you all can go to hell, because,
regardless, how much money you spend trying to get a few people emotionally
aroused and make them pay for your products, you will never be able to match
the simple beauty of this girl with her tears streaming over her cheeks as she
listened to a national anthem I had never heard before".
8 The music was unimportant, and,
even, her thoughts at that moment were unimportant, but, what was important, to
me, was the realisation, that a completely non-staged situation, (a girl who
probably never even thought, for one moment, about acting or communicating
emotions to other people), could convey, so powerfully, an emotion of beauty
and hope for the future. I was glad to have witnessed this fleeting moment as a
matter of chance.
9 Let us scrap all the
commercially oriented stage-productions of drama and situation-comedies, and,
let us look again at the people around us and see the immense variety of human
behaviour. Certainly, a lot of it is mediocre, uninspired, timid, average and
boring. Some of it is outright disgusting and infuriating, but, some of it is
beautiful and powerful, in particular, when we see a human being achieve a
lofty goal after enormously hard work and persistent dedication. It is
beautiful to see an artist, or an athlete, realise, that it is a glorious
moment, but, also, a moment of quiet gratitude for the fact, that it is
"all over", and, that those, who have been counting so much on his or
her succes, have not been let-down.
10 I think I know, roughly, what
went through the mind of this East European girl, and, I hope, that the
sensation of beauty was felt by millions of other people, who must have seen
those tears trickling down her cheeks. I hope, that, they too, felt moved and
uplifted by the experience, in spite of the fact, that very few people will
have understood the meaning of this experience in the same conceptual terms as
I have outlined here. Most of us will have forgotten her within a few days,
but, let us not forget the experience we felt, and, let us think about the
meaning and sensation of this experience of "beauty".
11 Let us recall some of the ideas
we have sketched before about the sensation of beauty and happiness, and, we
will see, why genuine art has to be close to life and has to be based on a
genuine experience of beauty. Unless an artist is true to his own emotions, he
or she will be unable to portray, convincingly, any human emotion in his art,
and, if an artist only thinks about the question, whether or not people will
like what he or she is doing, one might as well retire from the field of art
and become a business-entrepreneur.
12 We have elaborated, elsewhere,
the idea, that, the sensations of beauty and happiness arise, whenever there is
a fusion between the situation "as is" and "as we would like it
to be". Logically, if we achieve, finally, a long-range objective, after a
good deal of hard work, we will experience a sensation that we have
"arrived". We "consummate" our goal, and, in this final
moment of fusion between goal and accomplishment, (when we realise, that we have
finally achieved the dream for which we have worked so hard, for so many
years), we experience a great emotional surge. This emotional surge is the
direct physiological cause for the secretion of tears.
13 The longer and harder we have worked to achieve a particular objective, the higher our emotional investment has become, and, the stronger the emotional surge will be, whenever we experience a clearly defined fusion between objective and achievement. Often, an achievement is not nearly as concrete or precisely delineated as receiving an Olympic gold-medal, and the fusion may, then, not be as clear-cut or well-defined, either.
14 On the other hand, many of us
will experience a clear-cut fusion between goal and achievement, somewhere, in
the privacy of our own lives, and, we may experience a strong emotional surge
without the publicity of television cameras and an audience in the hundreds of
millions of people. The emotion may be just as strong, even, if the
significance for other people may be limited, whenever we celebrate, quietly, a
private but hard-won goal.
15 While the strength of the
emotional surge depends, entirely, on the degree of fusion between our goal and
our achievement, as well as on the effort we have put into it, the
persuasiveness of such an emotional surge for others depends, to a large
extent, upon the recognition of the importance of the goal. If someone has a
powerful emotional surge, because one has finally learned to ride a bicycle,
this emotional surge will not make news-headlines, nor, will it be witnessed by
many other people, since the goal is not recognised as an outstanding
achievement under ordinary circumstances.
16 However, if a young girl is
finally crowned in full public view as the best figure-skater in the world, the
achievement, as well as the goal, are, not only, recognised by millions of
people as completely valid, but a great deal of admiration for the skill and
grace of good figure-skating results in an emotional identification with the
person, who finally obtains this highest honour and achievement.
17 Yet, this is not sufficient to
explain, why the tears of this East European girl had such a profoundly moving
influence upon me. In the few short moments I watched her skate her final
program, I must have liked the way she skated, as well as the way she looked,
and, I must have identified subconsciously with her. I must have come to the
conclusion that she deserved to win. In addition, I must have realised, how
much hard work had gone into her skating performance, even, before she had been
declared the winner, and, when I saw her standing there, without a trace of
cheap triumph, I must have realised, how much this whole venture must have
meant, not only to her, but her coach, her friends and family, her team-mates,
her club, as well as the city and country she came from.
18 At the time she stood there, on
this platform, her whole country must have felt proud, that one of its own
youngsters had captured a gold-medal in figure-skating. She was not only a
symbol for me, but she was a symbol of achievement, dedication and hard work
for millions of other people who had watched her over the years and had
supported her unceasing efforts. Yet, she seemed to convey, as young as she
was, a deep sense of indebtedness to the people of her country, and, I am sure
that part of her emotional surge was due to a feeling of happiness that she had
been able to bring a gold-medal home to her people.
19 In part, the power of the
emotional persuasiveness, or resonance, of her appearance, was due to the fact,
that the meaning of individual achievement had been transformed into an
achievement of the peoples of an entire nation, but, as I mentioned before, the
main reason for feeling a sense of beauty on my part, was her soft sense of
gratitude, in stead of a strident, egocentric sense of personal victory.
20 This, however, brings us to the
point, that the interpretation of the onlooker, who happens to witness a
particular event, becomes all-important in the decision, whether or not a
certain experience is moving. While there are numerous specific circumstances
that determine or influence the interpretation of a specific experience, we may
also look for many common denominators. If we know a little better, what
arouses us, either to a sensation of beauty or happiness, or a feeling of
disgust and anger, or, perhaps, a quiet sense of pride and curiosity, we may be
able to understand the reactions of ourselves, and others, much better.
21 Sure, any spectator who knows
figure-skating well and had identified with her long before I ever saw her,
will probably share the emotions of this girl who had just received a
gold-medal, but, even those, who, like myself, just caught a glimpse of the
whole event, and, who were not particularly familiar with the skaters, could
get involved in a very short period of time. This indicates the powerful
persuasiveness of her skating and her personality, but, it also indicates a
peculiar sensitivity on my part at the time I watched this event.
22 This brings us to the question
of emotional resonance. While we have some ideas, now, why this girl was crying
at the time of her gold-medal presentation, we still have to understand the
reasons, why, witnessing those tears stream down her cheeks, made such an
impression upon me, that I decided to use it as an introduction to this essay.
Perhaps, in part, the explanation can be found in the very rapid process of
identification that took place during the few minutes I watched her skate.
Perhaps, there was an intuitive appreciation for the freshness and
attractiveness of her face, which lacked any obvious traces of make-up.
Perhaps, it was a reaction against the artificial and misleading emotionality
of so many programs on television with their ever-present commercial
over-tones.
23 Perhaps, it reminded me about my
own European country of birth, which was not the same as the country she came
from. Perhaps, it was an intuitive reaction against the nationalistic bias of
so many reporters and fans, but, I am well aware of the fact, that chauvinistic
nationalism is just as widespread and intense in other countries.
24 But, the main reason was,
perhaps, my surprise to see those tears, because, only then, did I realise,
suddenly, that she was not basking in a well-deserved triumph. She became,
then, all of a sudden a symbol for something I strongly believe in; nl, that
true achievement does not have to lead to a display of egocentric victory, but,
that it can lead to a deep understanding and a sense of humility and awareness
of the fact, that, all, or, at least, most of our finest achievements are only
possible, if we all cooperate and dedicate our efforts, wholeheartedly and
unconditionally, to a common goal.
25 Yet, this last consideration may
well be a very personal reason that is not shared, at least, not consciously,
by many other people, and, it may well be, that most people would not verbalise
their reasons in the same way as I have done. On the other hand, it is
possible, that many people will feel the same way, after they read an analysis
of my reactions and emotions.
26 Often, we are not aware, with
any degree of precision, of the many awarenesses and psychological mechanisms
that take place within us, but, after we read someone else's analysis or description,
we may suddenly recognise, that it put something into words which we vaguely
felt or experienced before.
27 But, there is another factor. We
all fluctuate, to some extent, in the sensitivity to emotional stimuli. If we
are emotionally unstable or labile, we may experience strong emotional currents
or surges, and, even rather trivial experiences or stimuli may bring tears to
our eyes. This instability is often called "sentimentality", but, we
have to distinguish between people who go through an emotionally unsettling
period and may, then, experience frequently emotional surges that bring tears
to their eyes, and, those people, who live in a rather narrow, egocentric and
emotionally unrestrained atmosphere, who cry at the drop of a hat as a result of
somewhat trivial stimuli, but, who would remain completely cold and
incomprehending, if they saw a tragedy take place beyond the rather narrow
horizon of their emotional and intellectual sphere of concerns.
28 I certainly do not consider
myself emotionally labile, and, many years go by in which I do not recall
having experienced a tearful episode. Even, when I watched this East European
girl cry on the Olympic platform, I did not have a sufficiently strong
emotional surge to bring tears to my eyes. However, over the next few days, I
noticed, that the imagery remained vivid in my mind, and, I found myself
frequently thinking about this episode, and, slowly, the many reasons and
mechanisms became clear to me.
29 These are the reasons, why I
decided to incorporate this vignette as an introduction to an essay that will
deal, primarily, with the opposite site of the spectrum of human emotions and
experiences. We will concentrate upon the far more significant experiences,
(significant, in terms of social chaos and disaster), which are associated with
the psychological mechanisms of depression, despair and the tendency to commit
suicide.
30 Let us review, briefly, the
overall spectrum of the human personality, with its range of emotions and the
super-imposed faculty of rationality. Only, if we are able to see, clearly, how
the experiences of beauty and depression relate to each other, will we be able
to discuss them intelligently. After all, the purpose of this excercise in
thinking is to help us understand ourselves, and each other, a little better.
.......
Chapter 2
Content
The free-floating cell.
The basic discrimination between benefit and harm.
Aggression; "moving towards"; "ad-grado".
Negative and positive stimuli.
The sense of vision.
The search for a possibility to exist.
The short-cut of animal existence.
The inevitability of death in the end.
Human behaviour-patterns.
The closer we behave to an emotional extreme, the less our behaviour is under
the control of rational evaluations.
Behavioural flexibility, and the ability to finely tune our responses.
The functions of the "free will".
A fusion of contemporary sense impressions with the memories of the past, as
well as the expectations for the immediate future.
Evolution; a second shock for Christianity, after the discovery, that the earth
was not the center of the Universe.
1 The concepts about the
structure and function of the human personality go back to those earliest
developments in the evolution of life, where we see, how the single, free
floating cell developed, already, the capability to distinguish between a
harmful and a beneficial stimulus. With the development of the capabilities of
locomotion, or propulsion, the ability to distinguish between a harmful or
potentially harmful stimulus, and, a stimulus that provides food, energy or
some other beneficial feature, became even more important, because, now, the
organism could actively seek-out a set of favourable circumstances, and, it
could avoid, or, at least, try to avoid, those areas of its environment, where
the conditions were not so favourable.
2 The surrounding area or
"space" of the natural environment in which an organism lived, became
"sensed", or interpreted, in terms of harmful or beneficial,
"evil" or "good", and, this basic classification of stimuli
arising from the environment go back to the physiological capabilities of the
single cell. The same basic classification still plays a role in such a complex
piece of behavioural machinery as the human being. One of the most fundamental,
most intuitive, and, often, poorly verbalised distinctions we make in the
contacts with our environment, is a classification of incoming sense
impressions into the broad categories of being potentially beneficial or
potentially harmful.
3 Naturally, we will try to
prolong contact with factors or conditions that are potentially rewarding to
us, and, we have a tendency to move towards such a set of circumstances. A
"movement towards" reads, literally, translated into Latin, as "ad-grado",
and, we still use the anglicized term of this Latin word as
"aggression" or aggressiveness.
4 True, in our contemporary use
of the word aggression, we do not use this word in all forms of behaviour,
where we move towards a beneficial stimulus. If we hear someone sing a
beautiful song, we may stop, listen and come a little closer in order to hear
better, but no-one would call this a form of "aggression". Yet, it is
helpful to keep in mind the original meaning of the word. The meaning of a word
often clarifies, how people have perceived reality over a prolonged period of
time, especially, if we have some idea, how a word came into being, and, how it
slowly changed its meaning as it went through a series of cultural developments
in successive generations.
5 When dealing with a set of
adverse circumstances, we can react in two completely different ways. If we
have a choice, we certainly would avoid, or flee, from circumstances that
appear to be harmful, and, the intensity of this avoidance response is directly
proportional to our interpretation of the sense impressions we are receiving.
Yet, we may not be able to avoid contact with, or flee from, an unpleasant or
harmful situation, and, we can, then, only resist the harmful conditions as
best as we can. This is the defensive or resistive stance, and, we have
discussed, on many occasions, how our response to a challenge is a smooth blend
between a reaction of resistance, or defensiveness, and a behaviour of
yielding, or avoidance.
6 Similarly, the response to stimuli
that are interpreted as potentially beneficial, or rewarding, range from an
all-out hunt to kill a prey, to an attack upon a competitor or enemy; from a
movement towards a group of people we hope to plunder, to a mild curiosity or
cautious exploratory attitude, whenever the signs of potential benefit are weak
or mixed with contradictory signals.
7 When we look at the overall
range of human behaviour, we see, that it is very useful to categorise
behavioural responses according to the degree of perceived significance of
these environmental stimuli or circumstances. Let us make it clear, that the
word "environment" is not used, here, in its narrow ecological sense,
but, it refers, literally, to the area or space that surrounds a living organism,
and, it includes, therefore, all the stimuli that arise in the space
surrounding an organism. Other living organisms and their signals, behavioural
actions, attitudes or intentions form then a part of this
"environment".
8 If the stimuli are threatening
or harmful, we may call them, somewhat arbitrarily, "negative", and,
if they are beneficial or promising, we call them "positive". We see,
indeed, how a living organism seems to focus its attention, (not so much by an
act of the voluntary will, but, through the functions of its physiological
mechanisms and anatomical design), almost exclusively upon stimuli with some
meaning for the existence of this organism. Existentially significant stimuli
are sensed, evaluated and classified, and, to some extent, recorded for future
reference, while stimuli that are not significant go largely unnoticed.
9 We may go one step further,
and, we note, that, the way an organism is "built", including its
general and special sense-organs, shows, how these specialised sensing mechanisms
are geared towards the detection of stimuli that are meaningful, or, may become
meaningful. For example, the sense of vision has selected a narrow range of the
electro-magnetic spectrum to which it has become sensitive. This allows us to
locate the presence of objects or the occurrence of events at some distance
away, as a result of the ability to register the discrete patterns of
electro-magnetic wave-fronts arising from these objects and events.
10 To be sensitive to a much larger
spectrum of electro-magnetic radiation would be confusing, because it would
blur a picture that has become a remarkably sharp and detailed portrait of
whatever is present in the environment of a living organism. If we would be
sensitive to electro-magnetic wave-fronts with a much larger wave-length, we
notice, that, indeed, the sharpness and clarity of our visual picture would
suffer. At the same time, a sensitivity to much shorter electro-magnetic
wave-fronts would lead to a loss of definition of many objects because of the
fact, that these short wave-length forms of electro-magnetic radiation are able
to penetrate many particles or objects.
11 In addition, there may be
physiological reasons, why the design of visual sensitivity has been limited to
a narrow spectrum of electro-magnetic radiation during the evolutionary search
for special sensory capabilities. Perhaps, the mechanisms of chemical
break-down and photo-sensitivity of the sensory rods and cones in the retina
dictated the range of sensitivities we now have, but, I am under the
impression, that the most important factor shaping the functional range of
visual perception, is related to the clarity of the physical imagery. This
clarity of the physical imagery is obtained by limiting the sense of vision to
a narrow band of electro-magnetic wave-lengths.
12 Let us come back to our main
theme, where we have stated, that the entire physiological and anatomical
organisation of a complex multi-cellular organism is geared towards providing
this particular community of cells, the multi-cellular organism, with the best
possible chances of survival. We have seen, before, how the living cell found a
possibility of existence over an extended period of pre-cellular evolution,
which took place over a time-span of a billion years, or so, and included an
unimaginable number of "natural experiments" with biochemical
possibilities of existence.
13 The criteria for survival, or
finding a possibility to exist, were always the same. Fragile, unstable and
transient chemical reactions and compounds found a measure of stability, and
were able to exist for a longer period of time, whenever they happened to
co-exist with complementary chemical reactions, and, eventually, the
conglomerate of biochemical reactions found a way to survive the ever-changing
circumstances by becoming sequestered as a blob of protoplasm surrounded by a
semi-permeable membrane.
14 There are always pressures that
tend to disrupt this protoplasmic, biochemical conglomerate, and, the cell has
to have continuous access to some sort of a suitable source of energy in order
to carry-out essential repairs. This is the reason, why living organisms are
always on the look-out for a supply of suitable energy, and, we can verify the
accuracy of this statement by the fact, that, after a few hours, our last meal
seems to have disappeared, and we are becoming hungry again.
15 As animals, we have taken a
short-cut. In stead of synthesising the required food-stuffs and building-blocks
from inorganic materials with the help of solar energy, we have come to rely
upon preformed, organic or living materials in order to sustain our existence.
As a member of the kingdom of animal species', we have no choice, but to kill
other life in order to sustain our own existence, be it plant life or animal
life, but, in our continuous quest for this ever-recurring need for
food-energy, we are constantly exposed to all sorts of perils. We may endanger
ourselves in a thousand different ways, as we are looking or hunting for food,
and, we may become a prey for other predators who are doing exactly the same;
looking for a chance to prolong their existence.
16 There is a constant struggle
going-on between the living organisms and their environment, and, we know, all
too well, that, in the long run, the environment always wins. For a while, we
may be successful and obtain sufficient food and shelter. We may prosper and
bloom in our youth, growing in vigour and mastery over our environment, but,
during adulthood, we consolidate, and, then, we begin to lose ground,
inexorably, inevitably. Slowly, our physical powers decline as we get older,
and, finally, our mental powers deteriorate as well. Our organism finds it ever
harder to sustain its integrity and existence. Internal regulatory mechanisms
begin to fail, and, some cells may escape from regulatory controls and begin to
grow without inhibitions. Perhaps, some vital pathways of communication or
blood-vessels are clogged by blood-clots and deposits of fatty materials, or,
bacterial and viral organisms may find a reduced resistance to their presence,
and go on a rampage.
17 Sooner or later, we all die,
and, all our cells in the body die, too, while the biochemical reactions of the
cells run-down to their lowest level of energy. These cells disintegrate by a
combination of automatic self-destruction, or "autolytic processes",
resulting from the inability to find or make use of a suitable energy-source,
and, a profusion of bacteria and other organisms that have found an abundant
energy-supply in the rotting flesh of our decaying body.
18 From the beginning of the
evolution of life, survival has been the ultimate criterium for the mechanisms
of natural selection, and, only those successful cellular communities that were
able to mature and reproduce, perpetuated themselves as a living species, while
others lost the battle with the environment and became extinct.
19 The functional and structural
organisation of cells forming a multi-cellular organism, was inextricably
inter-twined with their behaviour-patterns, and, we may, therefore, conclude,
that the behavioural responses, as well as the organisational patterns of the
cells themselves, together with their inter-relationships, were carefully guarded
and transmitted from one generation to the next with the help of a genetic
code.
20 The human being is heir to these
same developments, and, we have discussed, on previous occasions, why it seems
reasonable to recognise in man's emotional behaviour-patterns, elements of a
preformed, genetically encoded pattern of behaviour. On most occasions, these
behaviour-patterns have become strongly modified by secondarily acquired and
culturally transmitted guidelines or modifying factors.
21 For example, if we look at the
mechanisms of breathing, hiccoughing or the evacuation of a bladder or bowel,
or, the swallowing of food, we see, that these "behaviour-patterns"
are so stereotyped from one individual to the next, that we do not really call
these activities forms of behaviour, but, rather, basic physiological reactions
or "reflexes". We have, therefore, no difficulties accepting the
concept, that these stereotyped or reflex movements are genetically encoded.
22 If we look at voluntary
behaviour, we see, that a smooth muscular act, such as picking-up a glass of
water, differs little from one individual to the next, but, as we look at the
more complex movements, such as the way we eat or dress, we see, that other
factors bring-about a significant difference from individual to individual,
and, these differences become even more pronounced, if we compare one group of
people with another. Then, we see "cultural inluences" at work, which
are mainly due to the fact, that, we, as a group of people living together in
fairly small and isolated communities, have been living under somewhat
different circumstances. As a result, we use different objects, live in
different places, speak a different language, and, we believe in different
concepts and ideas.
23 If we look at people's behaviour
in the extremes of the emotional spectrum, such as the rage-reaction,
exuberance or ecstasy, the attitudes in victory or defeat, we see, that, people
resemble each other much more than when people behave more rationally, and
react more calmly or deliberately in their actions, thoughts and attitudes. For
these reasons, it seems justified to recognise in the primitive, unbridled
emotional reaction-patterns, traces of genetically encoded, inborn
behaviour-patterns, which are, nevertheless, almost always modified, at least,
to some extent, by cultural influences; e.g. by our will, by efforts to control
ourselves, as well as by the exhortations and admonitions from people around
us, etc., etc.
24 We have also discussed the
development of behavioural flexibility, or plasticity, which became a major
development in a variety of species', and, we have seen, how this trend
culminated in the human species with the development of a conscious perception
of reality. A conscious perception of reality requires a structure of beliefs,
as well as a deliberate and concious "will", necessary to shape,
consciously and deliberately, at least, a part of our behavioural responses.
25 We will not trace these
developments, here, in any detail, because we have done so before. Let us
re-iterate the conclusion, that we see in the human being a wide range of
responses fluctuating between the highly emotional extremes of aggressiveness
and defensiveness. The closer we are to these emotional extremes when
responding to the stimuli from the environment, the less influence we see from
our conscious or deliberate "will", and, the more stereo-typed these
reactions become.
26 Most of the time, we are not
anywhere close to these emotional extremes, and, we seem to drift, gently,
between mildly confident and somewhat anxious moods, where there is always a
mixture of emotional, pre-programmed, involuntary patterns of behaviour,
together with extensive modifications upon these patterns by our conscious
"will". We influence the pre-programmed behavioural reactions because
of the way we have been brought-up, and, to a lesser extent, we influence these
behaviour-patterns by a deliberate choice on the basis of our beliefs and
convictions.
27 We have also seen, that nature's
experiment with behavioural flexibility requires an enormous enlargement in the
range of recognition patterns, as well as a greatly increased complexity of the
categories into which the sensory input is classified by a neurological or
cerebral system of classification. This system has been elaborated in the human
species by a similar and parallel classification system of conscious, mental
images, where the conscious or verbalisable mental images are also classified
into categories of similarity in existence and event.
28 Man's world of perception is
astonishingly complex. We rely upon our neurological mechanisms to recognise an
object or event, or, to execute a smoothly coordinated movement, and, we rely
upon our mental imagery and its verbalisable classification systems to
interpret our environment in a conscious structure of beliefs. This conscious
structure of beliefs determines, in turn, the outline of our voluntary
behavioural responses.
29 We have come to the realisation,
that we refer, constantly, to our memory-banks in order to recognise our
environment and shape our responses, but, in addition, we carry-out complex
projections of probable consequences of a particular behavioural choice. The
imagined results of what would happen, if we choose to do so and so, is then
incorporated into the input to our behavioural choice.
30 So, we come to the conclusion,
that we live in the moment of the present with a mental imagery that is
constantly supported and maintained by a large variety of images from past
experiences, as well as a complex set of predictions or anticipations of what
is likely to happen in the immediate future.
31 We live, constantly, with a
mixture of memories of the past and anticipations of the near future, and, we
need this mixture in order to shape a viable response to the realities of the
present. We also range through a wide, sliding scale of positive-negative
interpretations of the existential significance of the moment, (coloured by
past experiences and future expectations), but, we may also hover around a
narrow zone of emotional near-neutrality, where the powers of rationality,
thought, logic and objective observations seem to reward us with a sense of
"being in tune" with our realities.
32 The entire field of the sciences
with their many interpretations has been based upon this zone of emotional
near-neutrality, but, let us not go into this, because, for the moment, we seem
to have sketched the basic outlines of the human personality with sufficient
clarity to be able to zero-in on more detailed aspects.
33 As we have mentioned, many of
these outlines have been discussed more extensively before, and, we have only
sketched a summary over-view of this field, which, unfortunately, still lacks a
broad basis of agreement amongst the peoples of the world.
34 It is my impression, that the evolutionary imagery of the biological sciences, which has slowly been built-up over the past century, is becoming a remarkably fruitful source for study and thought in our attempts to trace a broad, philosophical over-view of our existence. It is logical that such an imagery will meet considerable resistance, especially, from those, who rely strongly upon a religious interpretation of their realities, because this evolutionary interpretation is just as shocking and just as central to the concepts about human nature, as the discovery that the earth was not the center of the Universe.
.......
Chapter 3
Content
Looking at ourselves from an evolutionary point of view.
A fascinating blend of emotional and rational behaviour-patterns.
Verbalisable awarenesses; the tip of an ice-berg.
The possibility to deceive; a by-product of intellectual abilities.
The trade-off between scope and detail.
The need for cohesion in scientific knowledge.
We can not grasp the essence of being human from the "humanities"
only.
An increasingly important role for the biological sciences in philosophical
efforts to grasp the essence of human existence.
The role of intuition in a philosophical effort.
An emphasis on the negative, defensive aspects of human behaviour.
The price of specialisation.
The solution of "behavioural flexibility".
A more complex vision.
The subjective experience of a "free will".
1 If we look at ourselves from an
evolutionary point of view, we see, quite clearly, that our rational faculties
are a fairly recent development, which came-about as a result of the evolution
of behavioural flexibility and the ability to conceptualise. In contrast, our
emotions represent a much older heritage, in spite of the fact, that the
ability to verbalise or conceptualise our emotional experiences is a recent
addition to our rational and introspective powers.
2 There is, therefore, a
fascinating blend of emotionality and rationality, whenever we try to
conceptualise the more emotional aspects of our own behaviour. Just because our
emotional behaviour is much less dependent upon the ability to form, handle and
communicate concepts, we see, that it is more difficult to get a firm
intellectual grip over the structural and functional make-up of our
personality. Just because we communicate emotionally so much easier than by
intellectual arguments, we get the impression, that our emotionality is a more
highly developed and valuable faculty than our rational abilities.
3 We are still so little aware of
the hidden and emotional motivations in our behaviour, that we fail to
appreciate to what extent we use the tools of rationality as a weapon; either
aggressively or defensively. How often, do we realise, in a heated argument or
debate, that the real motivation is to shatter our opponents or defend
ourselves against attack, and, how often, do we realise, that we search for the
right arguments, attitudes, twists or witticisms, just as a hunter looks for
the right weapon or method to kill his prey?
4 Intellectual arguments become,
so easily, tools for a fight, and the content of the arguments has then little
real weight. This is perceived by many, bewildered onlookers, as intellectual
sophistry, or useless hair-splitting, but, rarely have the combatants been put
in their rightful place by a clear and concise analysis of the existential
battle that was raging behind their battle of words.
5 Our emotionality permeates our
behavioural responses to a far greater extent than we are aware of, in
particular, when we have a tendency to pride ourselves upon our intellectual
powers. While we think to argue rationally, we are, in essence, behaving as
clever opportunists, ready to move in for the kill, whenever the opponent shows
a sign of weakness.
6 Yet, it would be unfortunate to
throw-out all intellectual activities as treacherous and deceitful, just
because we have been intimidated by intellectual sophistry on a few occasions.
There is such a thing as intellectual honesty. There exists an attitude of
quiet persistence and curiosity about the nature of things, including the
nature of ourselves, and, there are examples, where people have chosen, on
purely rational grounds, an attitude of genuine sensitivity and concern for the
plight of others.
7 While many of us abuse our
intellectual powers in a blatantly egocentric and arrogant manner, without
realising what we are doing, we may also see some people come to a genuine
insight and understanding about the human phenomenon. Let us not throw the
knife away, just because we had the misfortune to cut ourselves with it!
8 If the power of emotionally
neutral observations and the lucidity of a truly integrated and broadly based
scientific reality perception can be a thing of beauty, as well as an asset
upon which we have come to rely to a remarkable extent, we should hesitate to
think lightly about the way it is used. We should carefully look at the way the
faculty of rationality developed, and, how it has been exposed to a variety of
contrasting influences. I mean this; we have to know, at least, to some extent,
how, and why, the sciences have given us a remarkably detailed picture of man
as a product of natural evolution on earth, in spite of the fact, that this
imagery has become scattered over a large variety of specialised scientific
disciplines.
9 While the contraction of the
scope of a scientific field is unavoidable, if we want to master, in detail,
the technology of a specific field of scientific research, we should keep in
mind, that the function of the researcher is nothing more than that of a
"machine", digging-out the coal or raw materials from the earth, or,
digging-up the fruits from the fields of knowledge. The products of research
are the basic ingredients of man's knowledge and insight, but, we still need a
lot of work to transform these basic ingredients into a coherent perception of
the overall reality.
10 The individual, who is going to
use these "raw data" to contruct a coherent imagery of reality, has
to have a far broader field of scientific vision than the scientific
researcher. The construction of a coherent over-view of reality requires a
vastly enlarged field of vision, because meaningful relationships often
transcend the borders of specific scientific fields, and, the philosophical
"worker" does not have to be a master in the techniques of
digging-out the raw materials of facts and data.
11 Unfortunately, in the last few
decades, the researcher has been glorified, because it remained relatively easy
to put the dug-out data to immediate use, but, now, the whole field of science
has become greatly fragmented. It is still possible for most scientific workers
to put their raw data into a framework that falls within their own specialty,
but, because this framework has become increasingly narrower, the fields
themselves are becoming less coherent in relation to each other.
12 We need, therefore, more people,
who are able to absorb the data and the gist, or essence, of a particular field
of science, and, we need people who can construct a broad canvas of
inter-relationships bringing-out patterns of coherence that span many
scientific disciplines.
13 The faculty of rational
evaluation is extremely useful, and essential, if we want to continue to
explore a perception of reality that is based upon emotionally neutral
observations. Even, if many people are inclined to shy-away from this area, we
still rely, often subconsciously, upon the fruits of this type of reality
perception; e.g., we seek medical help when we are sick, or, we
"research" the market, if we want to buy a toy or a tool we like to
have.
14 We may, indeed, be repulsed by a
blatantly arrogant and egocentric attitude of intellectual superiority, but, we
may also be "turned-off" by the complexity and confusion of the
scientific imagery, the demoralising squabbling between experts and various
schools of thought, as well as by the frightening and somewhat mysterious
powers of our most sophisticated technological machinery.
15 Any reason for turning-away from
the tools of rational evaluation and comprehension represents an unfortunate
event, and, we may be assured, that this broad field of scientific reality
perceptions and amazing technological mastery is so important, that we can not
hope to understand ourselves, unless we have, at least, a grip over the many
relevant fields of science and technology.
16 Fortunately, the time has
passed, that we could make a mental split between science and the
"humanities", in spite of the fact, that this is still not widely recognised.
Not so long ago, it seemed, that the road towards human understanding lay over
a course that looked somewhat down upon those "technicians" of
scientific and technological wizardry, but, it is becoming much clearer, now,
that we can not understand evolution without a fairly good grasp of many
hard-nosed scientific disciplines.
17 We can not hope to develop a
mental picture of the cell, or, about life in general, without knowing
something about physics, geology, biochemistry, biology, as well as the
physiology and anatomy of many living organisms. The time has passed, that we
can philosophise with impunity about man's nature, without knowing what the
imagery of the sciences of psychology, neurology, physiology or anthropology
have to offer us.
18 It is true, that each field by
itself still gives us only a fragmented picture, but, a philosophical attempt
at understanding man from a vantage-point that is exclusively rooted in the
humanities and ignores the imagery of the modern sciences, is doomed to
failure.
19 It is useless to talk in terms
of "higher" or "lower", when trying to relate the functions
of rationality and emotionality to each other. Let us only say, that,
rationality is a late evolutionary development, and, it represents the logical
culmination of an evolutionary trend that explored the possibilities of
behavioural flexibility.
20 The consequences of this
experiment with behavioural flexibility were gigantic, and, they are still
poorly visualised, because, only now, are we beginning to appreciate the fact,
that behavioural flexibility brought-about a vastly enlarged neurological
apparatus for the storage of memory-traces. This facilitated the function of
"recognition", as well as many motoric capabilities, and, last but not
least, the faculty of conscious awareness. Yet, in spite of a vastly increased
network of nerve-cell connections, the variety of circumstances an organism may
have to react to, became so great, that the genetic code could not instruct the
behaviourally flexible organism, with any precision, how to react in any one
particular situation.
21 Because of the limitations
associated with the genetic encoding of precise behavioural instructions in
behaviourally flexible animals, behaviour-patterns became "genetically given"
as an overall range rather than in the form of a detailed instruction. This
overall range of behavioural reactions functioned then as a set of general
guidelines and limits, where the specific adjustments in response to finer
fluctuations in environmental circumstances were left to the behaving
individual to decide.
22 This is the essence of
behavioural flexibility, which reached a new level of evolutionary development,
when proto-man, on the threshold of developing the capabilities of symbolic
representation, started to experiment with a process of voluntary image-recall
by imitations and gesticulations, and, later, by the far more rapid
communication of somewhat arbitrary and stylised sound-symbols; speech.
23 We have discussed all these
developments before, and, we are only recapitulating these aspects of
evolution, in order to give ourselves a background from which we can discuss a
more specific feature of the human personality.
24 We have also discussed the
manner in which we refine intellectual concepts. This involves a slowly
increasing precision of a concept by debate or dialogue, and, we apply the same
methods, when we try to understand the nature of human emotions, moods or
motivations. We are applying the tools of rational analysis and concept
formation in an effort to understand, why we feel or behave in a certain way,
under a specific set of circumstances.
25 However, this technique of
conceptualisation is not really scientific in nature, because we do not try to
design experiments, large questionnaires or polls, nor, any of the specific
techniques of gathering data which are used by psychologists or sociologists.
We are relying, primarily, on a method of introspection, or, rather, we rely on
the correlation of broad and wide-ranging observations, together with an
analysis of intuitive feelings and conclusions, which are, hopefully, based on
a sound and rational understanding of scientific observations and conclusions.
The validity of the opinions and conclusions will, therefore, depend, primarily,
on the degree of recognition or rejection which these thoughts will eventually
encounter, and, in this sense, the evaluation of its validity is, in essence,
artistic.
26 The focus of our attention in
this essay will be on the negative range. This is the defensive, anxious
spectrum of our behaviour, which comes to the fore whenever we interpret the
environmental stimuli as threatening. There are a great number of poorly
defined, but, nevertheless, different moods, feelings and behaviour-patterns
associated with a large variety of somewhat different circumstances, whenever
our negative emotional range has come to the fore as a behavioural response or
as some sort of an awareness.
27 It is useful, to remind
ourselves, here, once again, about the reasons for the evolution of rational
behaviour. We have seen, that nature's experiment with behavioural flexibility
led to the need for a mechanism that was able to adjust the behaviour of the
organism more precisely to local and temporary circumstances.
28 Genetic adaptations take place,
slowly, and a finely tuned adaptation is only possible, if a particular
ecological niche remains constant for a significant period of time. The
mechanisms of natural selection have, then, an opportunity to shape a set of
genetic instructions that is precisely adapted to a particular ecological
niche.
29 As we know, such a precisely
adapted organism is highly specialised in the range of its behavioural
reactions. Even a minor change in the ecological circumstances will then pose a
severe adaptative strain on the organism, or, rather, on this specifically
adapted population of organisms, and, the threat of extinction is near. A
highly adapted and specialised species has often lost a great deal of
flexibility or "molding ability" of the genetic code, and, even, a
minor change may require a degree of anatomical and physiological
"re-tooling" of the organism that is beyond the capabilities of this
particular genetic code or gene-pool.
30 In nature, there are many
circumstances that vary so rapidly, that a precise genetic adaptation is
impossible, especially, if we are dealing with large, multi-cellular animals.
If the variations in environmental circumstances are cyclical and recur at
predictable time-intervals, like seasons or tides, the genetic code can cope
fairly well by incorporating a mechanism, or, a change in behaviour and
appearance, allowing the organism to bridge a difficult but predictable period
of time.
31 If the variations are random,
however, the genetic code has no way of making use of many transient
possibilities of existence, and, it is here, that we see the reasons, why
nature started to experiment with the possibilities of a more flexible form of
responding to specific circumstances.
32 If an organism could change its
behavioural response according to the prevailing circumstances, making use of
transient possibilities of existence and avoiding transient threats or
difficulties, an organism, or, a population of organisms, could survive in areas
or environments, where organisms with a more rigidly encoded form of behaviour
could not.
33 While behavioural flexibility
opens-up new vistas of existence possibilities, we should not forget, that, any
natural experiment, any specialised development and every evolutionary road has
its own price to pay, because behavioural flexibility means, also, that an
organism begins to lose the availability of a precisely encoded, genetically
sheltered pattern of behavioural instructions, which has been shaped over
countless generations of evolutionary pressures. In stead, the organism is
given a broad, overall range of behaviour, but, many of the details of a viable
and necessary response are beginning to depend upon the perception and
interpretation of local circumstances.
34 With the opening-up of new
vistas of possibilities, we see, also, new vistas of perils. The requirements
for a more sophisticated perception and analysis of environmental conditions
are rising dramatically, and, the criteria of viability become now a shared
responsibility; partially born by the genetic code, but, partially, it has
become the responsibility of the actualised and living organisms of a species
to find a viable response. These living members have to decide, from one moment
to next, how to respond to a particular situation.
35 This idea is summarised in the
concept of "behavioural fine-tuning", and, it leads in the human
being, with its faculties of conscious awareness, to the experience and concept
of a "free will". We will not discuss, here, in any detail, the
aspects of the "free will", because we have done so before. We still
see, that, very strong stimuli, which are existentially significant and lead to
a life and death situation or decision, provoke the strongest emotional
responses, and, it is clear, that these responses are relatively independent
from, and poorly controled by, our rational faculties; e.g. a panic, a rage,
etc.
36 Yet, away from these emotional
extremes, we see an increasing level of control by our rational faculties over
the inborn, instinctive, or emotional patterns of behaviour. In the zone of
emotional near-neutrality, we see an almost exclusively rational form of
behaviour, but, it is important to realise, that we never see a complete
absence of emotionally or instinctively coloured patterns of behaviour. Our
behaviour represents always a blend of these two great inputs of rationality
and emotionality, and, this ever-varying mixture of emotionality and
rationality is one of the reasons, why human behaviour is so extremely varied
and complex.
.......
Chapter 4
Content
Rationality decreases as we slide further down the defensive scale.
The essence of "being depressed".
Paralysed by fear; a question of over-loading the central nervous system.
The panic-reaction; a useless form of agitated behaviour.
Alternating states of depression and hyper-activity.
The liability of a state of panic, hyper-activity, depression or paralysis.
Too stringent and thoughtless a form of self-discipline transforms us into
robots, but, an insuffient level of self-discipline makes us into a whining and
egocentric child.
The value of controled behaviour-patterns.
Learning to protect ourselves from attack and exploitation.
The strong personality.
Self-discipline, and the commercial interests.
Control, yes; suppression, no.
Oscillating rapidly, but gently, around the zone of emotional neutrality.
The attitude of "hope".
The practice of self-deception.
The emotional "ground-tone".
Why it is so difficult to grow-up into happy adulthood in a confused society.
The "saving grace" of working hard towards a long-term goal.
We need an elusive balance between achievement and failure.
Smouldering ghettos.
The wounds of chronic injustice.
The value of reflective thought.
A sense of sadness.
A few personal reflections.
1 We have covered, rather
quickly, the basic concepts of the human personality, seen from an evolutionary
point of view, but, we acknowledge, that, many questions about human behaviour
have not even been touched upon. Elsewhere, we have discussed the human
personality more extensively, but, we should keep in mind, that we are still in
an era of exploration, because many concepts still have to be widely accepted
throughout the living generations of mankind.
2 We have discussed, before, how
the creation of a globally acceptable reality image of ourselves is one of the
most ambitious but urgently needed projects we can undertake at this point in
time, in our social and evolutionary history. Slowly a composite picture of the
human personality is beginning to emerge, and, this image may, eventually, be
stylised and condensed into a more easily comprehensible and digestible form,
but, until we have reached this stage, we will have to reconcile ourselves to
the idea, that a great deal of hard conceptual work has to be done.
3 If we look at the defensive range of human behaviour, we see, clearly, that the component of rationality diminishes, as we come closer to the extreme ends of this spectrum of defensive behaviour-patterns. From a mild caution or slight uneasiness, we progress through a gradually mounting feeling of anxiety, until we reach the stages of panic or extreme depression.
4 It is interesting to note, that
the words "panic" and "depression" emphasise two contrasting
forms of behaviour, in spite of the fact, that both are a result of severely
negative, threatening or harmful pressures upon an organism. In panic, we see a
state of intense activity that is nearly always ineffective and does not
alleviate the pressures or stresses of the moment.
5 Here, we see a good example of
the failure and inadequacy of stereo-typed behaviour-patterns for behaviourally
flexible animals. These patterns represent an old inheritance, and, they have
been shaped by genetic instructions. Behaviour-patterns with a component of
rational fine-tuning are far more beneficial, especially, for the human being,
compared to the reaction-patterns at either end of the emotional scale.
6 In a severely depressed state,
we see an almost total absence of any behavioural reaction-patterns. The
individual appears paralysed, but, in our common use of the word
"depression", we limit its meaning to the more introspective and
specifically human aspects of negative feelings and gloomy experiences.
7 However, a more physiological
interpretation of the mechanisms involved, can give us valuable information
during our attempts to understand ourselves, especially, when we are driven,
for one reason or another, into a highly defensive attitude or mood. It is,
indeed, curious to note, how the extreme range of defensive behaviour can show,
either a frantic, poorly coordinated and highly ineffective profusion of
activities, or, a near-motionless state, where the organism seems to be
incapable of formulating any sort of response.
8 Actually, this is, indeed, the
crux of the matter. In such an extreme situation of defensive agitation, the
neurological and mental systems of the organism are "over-loaded",
and, they are unable to come-up with any sort of appropriate response. This is
the reason, why the response may manifest itself in ceaseless but ineffective
movements, or, as an absence of all movements.
9 In essence, the physiological
conditions of the organism are very similar in these apparently contrasting
conditions, but, it seems, that the paralysed state can easier revert to an
effective and coordinated response than the true panic reaction. It may well
be, that being paralysed by fear is one step short from a completely
uncontroled panic.
10 I realise, that we usually
reserve the term "panic" for the incoordinated and uninhibited
reactions of a group of people, but, I do not see any reason to isolate the
concept of a panic-reaction to a group. It is true, that, the frantic
activities, associated with a stage of extreme fear, seem to arise somewhat
easier, when emotional synchrony can sweep the level of anxiety into a feverish
pitch, but, there are many examples, where an isolated individual can fall prey
to this ceaseless, uncontrollable and senseless hyperactivity.
11 In psychiatric terms, it is more
common to speak about "hyper-activity", or "extreme
agitation", rather than panic, when we see this type of behaviour in an
individual. The field of psychopathology has recognised, for a long time, that people
may swing between extremely active or agitated states, and, periods of extreme
apathy, lethargy or depression.
12 We should remind ourselves, that
the terminology is somewhat confusing, because, in psychiatric parlance, there
is a tendency to see the alternating hyper-active and depressed states as
opposites of a spectrum. I prefer to see them as manifestations of a severe
anxiety, or state of defensiveness, well down the negative scale, and, the
oscillations between hyper-activity and absence of motion represent more an
apparent than a real contrast, especially, when we look at the mechanisms at
work within an organism.
13 Man has recognised, for a long
time, that the extremes of emotional behaviour are unproductive, and, every
society, be it large or small, be it a nation with its cultural guidelines or
the sensible parent as a leader of the family nucleus, has curbed these
emotional extremes with a certain element of vigor.
14 Sensible parents restrain the
unbridled manifestations of all emotions, and, they reward a calm, rational
control with an attitude of subtle respect. Every healthy society does the
same, and, we see, that a tolerance or exploitation of less restrained forms of
emotional behaviour, be it in violence, panic or sexual excitement, leads,
quickly, to social chaos, an atmosphere of weakness, as well as a dangerous
rise in social tensions.
15 We need restraint, just as we
need, on occasion, an outlet for built-up tensions. We need to learn the value
of control and self-discipline, just as we need to learn to relax, and, to be
aware of the emotional mechanisms that take place in ourselves and other
people.
16 Too stringent and thoughtless a
form of control or self-discipline will make us into non-understanding robots,
but, an insufficient level of self-discipline reduces us to a whining, spoiled
and egocentric child.
17 Self-discipline refers to a
variety of attitudes and actions we can adopt, and, we have discussed, here, a
rather specific form. We have discussed the fact, that we can control with our
voluntary "will", at least, to some extent, the level of anxiety or
excitement we are subjected to, and, the "will" functions, then, as a
means to prevent wild emotional swings. The will dampens our emotional
oscillations, and, this is one specific form of self-discipline.
18 Some people are so successful
with this type of control over their emotions, that they seem to deviate hardly
ever from the emotionally neutral zone. While they are sometimes accused of being
insensitive and un-feeling people, this is rarely the case. The discerning
individual will see under the veneer of outward calm a highly sensitive
intelligence, and, often, a quietly compassionate attitude of understanding.
19 Do not lightly dismiss such an
attitude as dull or useless, because this controled, self-disciplined
sensitivity allows us to tune our behaviour, most precisely, in accordance with
the prevailing circumstances. Those self-disciplined individuals, quietly
effective and unobtrusive in their accomplishments, form the backbone of every
social environment, and, rarely, do they abuse their intelligence for
egocentric purposes.
20 Certainly, intelligent and
efficient people are sensitive to the needs of their own existence, but, they
have learned to control their egocentric tendencies, as well as their emotional
swings, and, they are too intelligent and too much aware of the trappings
associated with a ruthless attitude of opportunism, to let themselves be goaded
into such thoughtless and exploitative behaviour.
21 Yet, self-discipline has other
aspects as well. Probably, the most obvious reason for excercising a measure of
self-discipline is the realisation, that we can minimise our vulnerability to
attack or exploitation, whenever we have learned to curb our desires and
instincts. In doing so, we lessen, not only, the chances of conflict with
others, whenever our desires and instincts infringe upon the interests and
rights of someone else, but, we become less gullible, less vulnerable to
exploitation and deceit, if we learn to control our passions and acquisitive
drives.
22 True, the primary motivation for adopting an attitude of self-discipline is the experience, or insight, that we benefit from such a stance. We realise, that we become stronger personalities, and, that we are more easily accepted by others, but, the real gain lies in the possibilities of understanding opened-up with an attitude of self-discipline.
23 We learn to accept, that the
reason for failing to achieve what we set-out to do, may be, at least,
partially, a result of our own faults and short-comings, and, we begin to avoid
the ever-present temptation to blame someone else for our failures.
Self-discipline leads to self-knowledge and a greater level of understanding of
others, as well as human nature in general. We become more thoughtful, and,
because of the increased ease of our existence, we have more time and energy to
think about problems that are a little further removed from our personal
concerns.
24 Doomed is the individual who
succumbs to the temptation of unbridled self-gratification in times of
prosperity, and, doomed are the indulgent, affluent societies that allow
rampant egocentric and commercial interests to pervert the attitudes of their
citizens by constantly appealing to their instincts for immediate
gratification.
25 It is sad to see, to what extent
the virtue of self-discipline is disappearing from the vocabulary and attitudes
of affluent people. Sure, it survives here and there, in isolated pockets,
usually on the basis of a religious outlook on life, or the unspoiled
simplicity of a frugal life in the country-site, but, by and large, the
affluent family, the well-educated individual, as well as the socially
conscious achievers have been brain-washed into believing, that self-discipline
is an archaic and stultifying attitude, which our modern, liberated
philosophies of consumption and entertainment have made obsolete.
26 The attitudes of frugality and
self-discipline are laughed at, in particular, by the sophisticated and clever
merchants of entertainment and excitement, because they realise, very well,
that the attitude of self-discipline is their most serious enemy.
27 Heaven forbid, that the people
would re-discover the virtues of self-discipline, because it would ruin their
empires built on titillation and indulgence. It would be a disaster for most
modern writers, if the people would go back to the old-fashioned virtues of
decency and self-discipline, because many of them have staked their livelyhood
on the expectation, that people will continue to read their
"shocking" vulgarities that pass as sophisticated entertainment.
28 What exactly happens, when we
excercise self-discipline? First of all, it allows us to survey the overall and
long-term consequences of our goals, which may have been set, largely, by our
instinctive drives or emotional desires.
29 Certainly, by far the most
efficient way to curb excessively egocentric goal patterns is a strong
inhibitory influence, or "taboo", from our social environment, but,
if we are able to control our desires ourselves, we see, immediately, a gain in
the level of our intelligence. Then, we are not blinded, anymore, by forbidden
desires, but, we are able to think through all the consequences of our
behaviour, whenever we would give-in to an impulse.
30 On occasion, our self-control
may become stifling, and, we may become afraid to follow any of our instinctive
or emotional impulses. As always, the extremes of every spectrum of behaviour are
less viable and less desirable than the optimum, middle range.
31 While we advocate a measure of
control over our emotions and impulses, we certainly do not advocate their
suppression. Sometimes, it is easier to suppress an instinct, or emotion which is
somewhat frightening to us, than to control it, but, the real solution is to
learn to control an emotional impulse, and yet, recognise and utilise all the
valuable aspects of such an emotional impulse.
32 We know, now, that a certain
measure of control over our emotional impulses keeps us closer to the zone of
emotional neutrality, and, consequently, our rational faculties are better able
to design a highly refined and appropriate response. If we are not too far away
from this zone of emotional neutrality, it is easier to regain our sense of
confidence, which belongs to the positive zone, and, we see, clearly, how we
tend to oscillate, fairly rapidly, but gently, around this zone of emotional
neutrality, as mildly defensive and mildly encouraging stimuli are assessed and
recorded, nearly constantly and simultaneously.
33 Then, we summarise our attitudes
in terms of "cautious optimism" or "guarded confidence",
indicating an awareness of this mix of slightly defensive and slightly
aggressive or confidence-inspiring sense impressions.
34 We should not forget, that sense
impressions and behavioural responses follow each other rapidly. The results of
a behavioural response have an immediate influence upon the way we interpret
the continuous stream of sense impressions, and, the way we judge the
significance of these sense impressions influences, to a significant extent,
the type of response we select as the most appropriate under the circumstances.
35 If we receive a series of sense
impressions indicating that we are facing a problem or a pressure, (which, if
left unchecked, may become more serious), we will find ourselves somewhat on
the defensive. If we have a reasonable measure of self-control or
self-discipine, we know, that it is foolish to give-in to the temptation to
bring us out of this somewhat defensive situation by ignoring the problem.
36 Unfortunately, it is a very
common attitude to try to solve a problem by distorting sense impressions, and,
by suppressing the disturbing or embarrassing evidence that is associated with
these impressions. We will later discuss, how this distortion relates to the
common defense mechanisms of the attitude of "hope".
37 If experience, far-sightedness
and a measure of self-discipline have taught us, that we are better of by
tackling the problem seriously and decisively, now, while the problem is still
small, we will do so, and, we will find in a majority of cases, that the
problem is rather simple, even, if it requires a little effort or some sort of
sacrifice.
38 For example, if we have
entangled ourselves financially by borrowing a little more than we should have,
or, if our relationships with other people have become somewhat strained,
because we have not been entirely candid or forthright, or, if we have become
emotionally entangled to the point, that we are endangering our family and
marital relationships, in all these examples, as well as numerous others, we
are slowly being driven into a defensive attitude, and, the most efficient and
only permanent solution is to make hard and difficult decisions, which may cost
us a serious effort, as well as a measure of embarrassment.
39 The temptation is always there
to "patch-up" a situation, hide behind slight
"inaccuracies", or, a slightly dishonest relationship or
communication. While such a solution may temporarily ease the situation, the
web gets thicker, and, we are likely to entangle ourselves ever further.
40 Self-discipline is invaluable to
come to real solutions and reduce our vulnerability, as well as the likelyhood
that we will hurt others. Those behavioural responses, which would lead to
feelings of guilt and a loss of self-respect, can only lead us further away
from a permanent solution, and, these behaviour-patterns will lead us further
up the scale of anxiety and depression. If we devise a behavioural response
that really solves the problem, we become more confident and less vulnerable,
and, our perceptions will slowly return to a more neutral zone as well.
41 However, some of us live with a
near-constant filter of anxiety, which colours all feelings, sense impressions
and behavioural choices with a defensive or anxious under-tone, and, often, we
are at a loss to explain such a persistent bias in our emotional under-tone or
"ground-tone". Such a persistent emotional bias, which occurs, most
often, as a bias into the defensive or anxious range, is not due to a series of
well-defined, negative experiences which have occurred in the recent past, or,
are taking place in the present, but this bias is due to a poorly defined set
of experiences in the far distant and largely forgotten past, where an
unfortunate childhood may have damaged, perhaps, permanently, the normal
balance between positive and negative evaluations.
42 We have elaborated these
mechanisms before, and, we will only refer to them briefly, here. It may be,
that genetic factors play a role as well. The organism may, indeed, have a
genetically weak physical and mental constitution, which may be perceived,
quite accurately, as a permanent and inborn vulnerability by the individual in
question. These people will stay low on the hierarchical "pecking
order", but the weakness may be more imagined than real, and, then, we
enter the field of psychopathology.
43 It is not clear, at the present
time, whether a persistently distorted bias in perceptions is due to traumatic
experiences early in life, or, the result of a defective mechanism, based on a
genetic fault; or, perhaps, on a combination of both. The influence and
effectiveness of self-discipline is less apparent in distortions of the
emotional bias or ground-tone, because the bias is so strong and so persistent,
and, yet, so poorly amenable to rationalisation and insight, that the
mechanisms of rational evaluation and will-power are insufficient to control
them.
44 These people are, indeed,
vulnerable creatures, but, occasionally, they make a highly valuable
contribution to society, in spite of their severe handicap, because they may
become gifted artists, who are able to contribute to society as a result of
their high level of sensitivity in a specific area of human endeavour.
45 For us, average and ordinary
people, self-discipline is a valuable tool to dampen our emotional swings, as
well as our most blatantly egocentric attitudes, and, this tool helps us
greatly to learn and understand what human life is all about. However, most of
our long-term goals are not simply aroused by a primary instinct, and, many of
our problems are not just due to an unwise management of finances,
relationships or personal habits. Many of us have to learn to live with serious
failures, chronic frustrations, and long-term ambitions that will never be
realised.
46 How full of enthousiasm and vigour
were we in our fortunate youth, and, we see this energy and idealism still
mirrored in the vitality of our healhty youngsters, but, we know, that, they,
too, will have to go through many disappointments, or, even, more serious
mental crises, before they reach maturity. We know, that some of them, for no
apparent reason or purpose, will be taken-away by accident, illness or suicide.
47 We know, how many failures and
heart-breaking disillusions will have to be endured by these youngsters, but,
we also know, how empty their victories and achievements may turn-out to be.
This seems to be one of the most profound ironies of human existence; we are
able, and willing, to channel a fantastic amount of energy and dedication into
the achievement of a goal or ideal, only to see the value of this goal
evaporate, as soon as we come close to it.
48 Some of us are apparently
oblivious to the odds against success, and, we load upon our shoulders the
near-certainty of failure by not being realistic about the circumstances of our
existence, and our powers of realisation. Yet, even, if we succeed, we are not
prepared for the fact, that, after a few heady moments of triumph and success,
life goes on, and, we seem to be back where we started; on the road towards
another goal, another achievement, another triumph, and the routine of hard
work and constant self-discipline becomes, then, almost a comforting routine,
interrupted, now and then, by a bitter disappointment, or a sweet moment of
success.
49 While we learn from our moments
of triumph, how transient success really is, and, how difficult it is to answer
questions about the meaning or purpose of all our efforts, we also learn, that
it is dangerous and disrupting to experience only failures, and, to miss always
this final moment of victory and achievement.
50 Only, if we are successful, at
least, once in a while, can we appreciate the relative value of our goals and
efforts. If we only experience failure, we are likely to become obsessed with
success and power of any kind, and, we may become a threat and danger for
others, or, for the society at large. This may happen, when we, finally,
achieve a short but sweet taste of victory, as we grab power and attention in a
daring act of criminal violence.
51 We seem to need an elusive
balance between achievement and failure, victory and defeat. While it is highly
unlikely, if not impossible, for a human being never to experience defeat, it
certainly is possible for many forgotten and forlorn youngsters to taste a
depressing succession of failures, or, to taste success exclusively in
anti-social attitudes and criminal activities.
52 Most of us are so busy looking
after our own well-being, that we have no time to look seriously at these
smouldering ghettos of seething frustrations and criminal activities, until we
are surprised and shaken out of our complacent doldrums by a violent eruption
of chronic frustration and hatred.
53 Perhaps, the greatest
frustration and sense of chronic failure comes, when we are subjected to a
persistent form of unjust treatment. Chronic injustice leads, eventually, to a
violent rebellion, unless the injustice is so severe and repressive, that life
ebbs-away into a dull, sub-human perception of reality. People live, then, in
such poverty, ignorance and depravity, that, only a vague feeling of
unhappiness permeates their existence, barely reaching a level of conscious
verbalisation or articulation.
54 However, most of us are more
fortunate, and, most of us experience a sufficient level of failure and
frustration to make us aware of the transience of life and our achievements. We
may, then, become aware of the remarkable similarities between people with
their diverging and conflicting interests. Yet, most of us have experienced a
sufficient level of success, encouragement and security to avoid the bitter
cynicisms of the perpetually frustrated individual, and, we are fortunate
enough to have avoided the obsessions and neurotic fixations that come with an
unending series of failures.
55 Reflection, or, rather, the
tendency to reflect and re-evaluate the situation we are in, or, more broadly,
the situation our society and the world around us seems to be in, is based on
an experience or sense of failure. We are looking for a way to overcome difficulties
in our goal-patterns, or, we are vaguely searching for an attitude, or a way of
looking at life, which may disperse this feeling of uneasiness, chronic
depressiveness, or melancholic sadness. These feelings may persist for no good
reason at all, in spite of apparently optimum circumstances.
56 Is such a feeling of melancholy
and sadness nothing more than a vague feeling of self-pity, or, is it an
expression of restlessness and boredom with a perfect but somewhat dull
condition of security and success? Is this feeling a sign of indulgence, a lack
of self-discipline, or, a lack of awareness, how well-off we are, and, how much
worse it could be?
57 Probably, there is some truth in all these considerations, and, if we ever would feel seriously unhappy, we would have become neurotic and spoiled in our position of security and affluence, but, if we use this vague sense of uneasiness and melancholy as a spur to search for new answers, new ideas, new attitudes, as well as a new avenue to create something we believe in and find beautiful, then, such a feeling may be highly productive and stimulating.
58 Perhaps, this vague sense of
sadness may be present in spite of optimum living conditions, because we feel,
that we are wasting time. We may feel, that we are becoming somewhat
complacent; that our energies are ebbing-away by a combination of continuous
comfort and a gradually advancing age. We become more set in our ways, less
flexible in our thinking, and, there is, perhaps, an uneasy feeling, that
ambitious plans will come to nothing.
59 We may become quickly aware of
the fact, that time is running-out; not only because of the inescapable logic,
that, every day, we have come a day closer to the moment of death, but, we may
also realise, more and more vividly, that our later years are becoming less and
less productive. We seem to suffer from increasingly larger and more frequent
"blank spells", where the mind is empty and stale, while there used
to be such a turmoil of ideas, waiting impatiently and fighting for a chance to
become written-down on a piece of paper.
60 Perhaps, our sadness may be due
to the vague feeling, that the people in our environment do not really
appreciate our somewhat esoteric and nebulous efforts. We would like the
opportunity to meet someone, who understands these ideas perfectly, and, who
would be willing and able to enter, immediately, into a spirited debate about
any of the many ideas we have been living with for such a long time. But, then,
we wake-up from these dreams, and, we realise, that it is impossible to find
such a person, and, that we will just have to express our ideas patiently and
clearly on paper, in order to give the younger generations a chance to look at
them.
61 On the other hand, we notice,
from time to time, how, to our surprise, an idea may be thrown back at us by
someone we have been talking to frequently. This indicates, that, at least,
some of the ideas have found a fertile soil and are starting to grow. As for
the "ideal debater"? One of these days, I will be able to
"create" him or her, and we will have a spirited dialogue, on paper.
62 Perhaps, these melancholic moods
are a reflection of the sadness we feel, when we see a culture being poisoned
by the pernicious forces of greed and commercial exploitation. It is sad to see
fine people, and, especially, potentially healthy youngsters, whose genetic
code is, still unaffected by pollution and radiation, to see such a potentially
healthy generation of young people grasp and grope for meaning; without guidance,
fragmented and confused, because we, the older generations, have allowed our
cultural code to wither-away for the sake of the television commercial and the
"fast buck".
63 It is sad to see conflicts
arise, time and again, because of the same mechanisms of ignorance and
primitive anxiety which prompted the prophets of biblical times to raise their
voices. What have we really learned during all those centuries, or, am I too
gloomy? Is my emotional bias too strongly coloured in the negative range to answer
this question with a few positive thoughts?
64 Yes, I do feel a sense of
frustration and sadness, because I know, that it is not necessary for people to
be so brain-washed by commercial greed or religious fraud. Certainly, there is
religious fraud, because, on many occasions, the high ideals and lofty morals
of Christianity are exploited by commercially oriented preachers, who are
teaching a gospel of Christ any way the congregation wants to hear it; as long
as they are willing to pay their dues.
65 Fraud is everywhere around us,
but, it goes largely unrecognised, and, the more society crumbles under the
weakening effects of fraud and corruption, the more strident and self-righteous
the people and their leaderships seem to become. We are becoming so defensive,
so chronically anxious as a society, that we lose, increasingly, the ability to
see the good points in a life-style or a philosophy that is different from our
own.
66 We think, that we are the heirs
and guardians of the Christian Faith, and, I suspect, that a good many
righteous Christians would not hesitate to throw nuclear bombs at those
Anti-Christs, the Communists; all for the love of their God!
67 We champion freedom of
expression and human rights, without knowing the perils of chaos, or the price
of human obligations. We despise the dictatorship of the Social Dogma, but, we
turn a blind eye to the dictatorship of the commercial enterprise. Perhaps, I
am saddened, because I know, that people will not listen to me. They can not
listen to me, because, if they would agree, the catastrophic collapse of our
affluent societies would be hastened.
68 Yet, I am not saying, that our
people are any worse than the peoples in those countries that seem to have a
better balance between human rights and obligations, between consumption and
self-discipline, between health and self-indulgence. People are people, and,
they may become magnificent and responsible citizens, or, they may become
anxious, frightened, self-centered and ignorant members of a decaying and
confused social environment.
69 Perhaps, I am too gloomy.
Perhaps, our society can regain control over the powerful commercial interests,
as well as over our own gluttonous attitudes. Perhaps, I see things too
melancholic or "black-biled", and, I do not want to leave the
impression, that I glorify the societies based on Dogmatic Socialism. I do not
believe that Dogmatic Socialism would be any better equipped to handle
affluence than the Capitalist societies, because, ironically, for many
Socialist societies, our level of material affluence is still one of their
major, long-term objectives.
70 Perhaps, I am not really all
that sad to live where I live, and, to live in our times, and, I was certainly
happy to have witnessed the little, healthy and athletic girl with the tears in
her eyes, who came from a country, where self-discipline is obviously alive and
well, as we see, so clearly, in the number of medals they took at the recent
Winter Olympics.
.......
Chapter 5
Content
Anger and anxiety caused by insecurity.
The leader who is losing his support.
A review of leadership mechanisms.
The jungle of international relations.
The temptation to grab and hold-on to power by force.
Increasing anxieties.
Social decay; a variety of mechanisms.
The need for sound fiscal principles.
We all have to learn to live within our means.
Missiles sitting powerless in their silos.
1 It is certainly possible for
fanatic, unstable and self-righteous people to obtain power, by military force
or electoral victory. They may use this power, eventually, to unleash a nuclear
war against what they perceive to be an utterly evil enemy. "Our
side" of the global balance of power seems to be more on the defensive,
than it has been for a long time, and, I believe, that the inexorable decay of
our weakened societies will be a direct cause for belligerent posturing and
unsophisticated behaviour-patterns, by leaders and peoples alike. Certainly,
this is quite a common and understandable reaction, but it is nevertheless a
frightening prospect because of the type and quantity of weapons available on
both sides.
2 Let us look at the mechanisms
and behaviour-patterns of a leader, who is in danger of losing his position of
power and dominance. The weakening of a leadership position and the erosion of
a leader's sense of security may have "natural causes", such as the
ageing of an established leader, and the growing vigour of younger challengers.
With the decline in physical powers, the leader has also become set in his
ways, and, often, somewhat complacent and insensitive to the need to seek
continued support from the other members of the group.
3 Even the leader of a small
group of socially integrated animals requires a measure of support from his
followers. If this support melts away, and, if the members come, intuitively,
to the conclusion, that they are not benefitting anymore from the leader's
leadership, they will start to resist his efforts to maintain his position.
More members begin to support a rival leader, who is gaining in confidence and
authority, and, eventually, the rival will challenge the older leader to a
fight.
4 The mechanisms of leadership
succession in the human societies are very similar in nature, in spite of the
fact, that, we have a much more varied way of contesting or defending a
leadership position. These mechanisms range from popular acclaim, all the way
through intrigue, deceit, flattery, conspiracy and assassination, but,
sometimes, the process of leadership succession has been transformed into an
orderly method of democratic elections, where every member of society has been
given the right to vote for the candidate of his or her choice.
5 Yet, we see, in essence, the
same reasons for the gradual weakening of a leader, or, anyone, who is in a
vulnerable position of prominence. There are always other people who would like
to occupy this position of privilege and prestige, and, the challenger is,
therefore, never far away. In an open and healthy society, a leader or
prominent figure will have to show, from time to time, why he or she is still
the right person for this position, and, here, we see the importance of the
factor of public support.
6 If a leadership has gained
access to power by force, e.g., a military coup, it is logical, that the
maintenance of this position of power will shift to the mechanisms of force and
intimidation. Even so, the military dictator needs, at least, a measure of
popular support, primarily, from his soldiers and officers, but, also, from the
society at large, otherwise, his tenure will become frustrated and nearly
impossible.
7 If the population of a society
has been polarised into highly antagonistic factions, a dictatorship will be
much easier to maintain, because the leader may woo one segment of the population,
which, together with the armed forces and its monopoly over the economic
resources of the country, is then in a position to dominate and exploit the
more impoverished segments of the population.
8 Human rights disappear.
Brutality, intimidation, and, even, torture and assassination become the
primary mechanisms of control. We see, then, a reign of terror, but, often, the
rest of the world turns a blind eye towards these atrocities, while dealing
blandly with the leadership in power.
9 Under the false doctrine of
"complete non-interference in each other's affairs", the people are
left to suffer under a brutal regime, in particular, when an oppressive
leadership has been persuaded or bribed into cooperating with the major,
powerful nations in its neighbourhood. Only in retrospect, are we able to see,
what has happened, because the peoples of the world are largely kept in the
dark about the events that are taking place in a society with an oppressive
regime.
10 It is tragic, and highly unjust,
if a nation supports a dictatorial regime in another nation, especially, if
such support is based on the cooperation with, and support for, the national
interests of powerful neighbours. For the sake of obtaining raw materials, oil
and other essential commodities, or strategic advantages, dictatorships are
being kept in power, and, the people are suffering as a result. The
responsibility for the persistence of oppression, poverty and all sorts of
injustices lies as much with supportive neighbours, as with the oppressive
regime itself.
11 Yet, let us return to the
mechanisms and behavioural reactions that take place, when a position of
authority is being challenged. As we have seen, such a development is, nearly
always, due to ageing or weakening of the leader, together with the growth in
vigour and boldness of younger rivals. The mechanisms of weakening may not be
primarily physical, however. Complacency, indulgence, insensitivity, as well as
the temptation to become more capricious, tyrannical or intimidating, are
hallmarks of a weakening mind, and, these mechanisms contribute to a sense of
alienation.
12 In a way, this trend represents
the essence of corruption, just as it is corrupt to abuse a position of
privilege for egocentric gains, and, to forget the responsibilities and
objectives of a leadership position. All these mechanisms are messengers of
decay, and, the rivals are quietly biding their time for an opportunity to
challenge and topple such a weakened leadership.
13 The temptation to hold-on to
power by a reign of terror, or, in less extreme circumstances, by favouritisms,
bribes, or, conniving alliances that accentuate the purpose of personal
security, all these elements indicate a gradual rise in the defensiveness of a
leadership.
14 Here, we see a good example, how
a reaction to a threat or a difficulty can be answered by a truly effective and
sensible response. If an individual in a position of leadership or prominence
can bring him- or herself to carry-out a truly appropriate and definitive
response to the mounting difficulties, such a course of action will bring the
individual back into a zone of emotional neutrality, or confident security,
while a patch-work response, a postponement of difficult decisions, or measures
of a self-disciplinary nature, only serve to aggravate the situation, driving
an individual increasingly onto the defensive scale.
15 Often, an individual in a
position of prominence or leadership becomes thoroughly confused by the
conflicting pressures upon its decision-making processes, and, such an
individual does not know, anymore, what to do. The overall meaning and
understanding of leadership requirements have disappeared, or were never fully
developed. A leadership may function quite well for a while, as it draws on its
intuitive wisdoms and natural talents, but, in times of severe crises, these
talents often run dry, and the leader begins a cumulative series of inadequate
reactions and decisions, which lead to a rise in anxiety, injustice and
suffering.
16 Even, if leaders are not able to
express, in conceptually precise and clear terms, what the overall functions
and requirements are for a successful and just leadership, I am convinced,
that, every natural leader has a good intuitive judgement about these matters, and,
he knows, deep in his heart, whether or not a certain decision or action is
right and just; whether or not his activities are the beginning of a submission
to egocentric pressures and anxieties.
17 Once a leader has chosen the
road of an egocentric defensiveness, the stage is set for a disastrous decline
in the quality of leadership behaviour, and, the mechanisms of social decay,
corruption, incidences of injustice, as well as a build-up to civil strife,
have, once again, been set into motion.
18 Even, if the leadership and the
mechanisms of succession have been safeguarded from the most serious forms of
corruption and decay by Constitutional Guidelines, it is still possible, that
the nation or society becomes complacent, lazy and unwilling to work innovatively.
Affluence lies at the root of such a weakening effect upon the society as a
whole, because people become accustomed to a soft and luxurious life-style and,
they are, in essence, unable to earn this life-style with hard work and an
attitude of self-discipline.
19 A society that begins to rely
upon a continuous influx of imported goods becomes weak and vulnerable, just as
it becomes vulnerable, if it has to rely on a foreign source of energy or a
continuous influx of capital investments from abroad. As a result of
increasingly egocentric attitudes, the level of internal disruptions rises,
strikes increase, workmanship declines, people feel deceived and exploited,
and, a few of the more intelligent members realise, vaguely, that they are
contributing to the decline of society by participating, out of necessity, in
these polarising mechanisms of deception and exploitation.
20 The larger corporations begin to
dominate the outlook and attitudes of the people in affluent, Capitalist
societies. The value of money begins to fluctuate, and, often, to devaluate.
The trust in governments and their institutions is undermined, and, wealth
begins to accumulate into isolated pockets of corporate holdings or private
assets. A majority of the people become entrapped in a life-style of chronic
indebtedness, wasteful consumptive habits, as well as a constant feeling of
insecurity. They are powerless to do anything about their predicament. Drug and
alcohol abuse rises, patriotism becomes a shrill and confused ideal, but,
people are still easily goaded onto the battlefields, either because of a lack
of employment or a facile trust in a "social saviour".
21 The high levels of anxiety and
confusion are reflected in the attitudes of the leadership. The nation has lost
its proudly independent and dominant position, but it is still not willing or
able to admit it. The more anxious and defensive we are, the less we can afford
to admit to ourselves, that we are failing. The nation and its leadership
become frustrated as it has to look-on, helplessly, without any effective
response, when other countries begin to encroach upon its interests. The nation
becomes helpless and humiliated, if a small number of its citizens are taken
hostage in a foreign nation, and, it is seen to be helpless and indecisive in
the spotlight of international attention that has been focussed upon this
drama, week after week, month after month.
22 It is not surprising, that a
leadership begins to make idle threats and unenforcible ultimata, whenever it
is becoming anxious and defensive. As prestige and self-confidence are
crumbling, a nation and its leadership are forced to "put up a
front", and, just as an animal will suddenly turn-on its predator in a
desperate last stance, so can a society that has been driven into a corner,
easily unleash a desperate war.
23 Threats and irresponsible
rethoric only serve to underscore the weakness of a nation and its leadership.
Respect declines, and, rivals are encouraged to challenge the authority or
sphere of influence of a declining nation in ever bolder moves. Slowly, the
nation becomes a focus of ridicule, in spite of its many good intentions and
its massive aid programs.
24 Yet, the people and their
leaders are so emotional in their reactions, and, they are so ignorant in their
attitudes, largely as a result of a constant commercial bias, that they are
unable to see themselves somewhat more objectively; as others see them. Here,
we see the incalculable value of self-discipline, and, the tragedy of every affluent
nation is the fact, that, prosperity and easy living conditions always
undermine the insight and willingness of people to excercise a measure of
restraint or self-discipline.
25 What does one have to do, if one
lives beyond one's means? One has to cut back, save, and work hard to pay-off
debts, because, as long as there is a debt to pay, earnings and productivity
will be drained by a combination of interest payments and debt repayments. If
such basic principles of sound management apply to an ordinay individual, why
should it be any different for us collectively? As a result of our ignorance in
economic matters, we still believe, that governments can "print"
their way out of a debt.
26 Certainly, the phenomenon of inflation
encourages the practice of borrowing money, because one can pay the lender back
with devalued monies. Often, one is able to borrow more than one pays back,
because, in spite of interest payments, the devaluation of a currency means,
that the repaid value is less than the borrowed value.
27 As long as governments are not
able, or willing, to curb inflation or eradicate it completely by guaranteeing
a constant value for their currencies, there will be no incentive to live
within our means, but, by borrowing more and more, and, by paying foreigners
large sums of money for the products upon wich we have become dependent, we
enslave ourselves to these foreign interests. We enslave ourselves to the large
corporations, and, we sell-off our country and industries to foreign investors,
bit by bit.
28 Unless we return to sound fiscal
principles, the spiral of inflation, impoverishment and financial entrapment
will continue to escalate. Unless governments ackowledge their responsibility
to guarantee, once again, the value of their currencies, people will rightly
sense, that they are being deceived and penalised for their efforts to save and
be frugal. Unless we learn to see, that we all have to curb our egocentric
instincts and desires, the level of suspicion and mutual hostility will
continue to rise, and, we will be incapable to avoid a disastrous collapse.
29 Unless we learn to see, that,
fiscal responsibility should not be limited to curbing the powers of
labour-unions, or to freeze the wages of ordinary people, such a policy of
fiscal restraint will continue to be looked upon as a ploy by the rich to get
richer.
30 Fiscal restraint, means, an
iron-clad guarantee of the stability of money; a balanced budget, regardless of
the price; a completely fair and progressive taxation upon all types of
earnings, including inventory and property appreciation, holdings, and all
sorts of financial gains and earnings, etc.
31 Fiscal restraint, means, a swift
and efficient retirement of the national, provincial and municipal debts, as
well as all personal debts. It means, controled interest-rates for short-term
borrowing, the elimination of useless products and jobs, as well as a serious
attempt to shift into a life-style of frugal conservation, backed by a universal
guarantee of a minimum standard of living.
32 "Utopian nonsense", you will say, "because in these sweeping statements you do not spell-out, how such a radical transformation of fiscal and taxation policies can be accomplished. We have discussed, frequently, the ways and means by which such a transition can be accomplished, and, we will not repeat the arguments, here. It can be done, and, it has to be done, if we want a world with more justice and less tensions.
33 We have to have complete
openness in society; in particular, we have to have complete openness about
financial matters, business assets, holdings, incomes, etc. We can only expect
our neighbour to go along with austerity measures, if he can verify for
himself, that we all are contributing our fair share to the efforts that are
needed to put our house in order. We should stop blaming each other for the
problems we are facing. We are on a dead-end road, if we think, that we can
have effective austerity by curbing the powers of those segments in society we
do not identify with, and, we are deluding ourselves, if we think, that we can
solve all the problems of society by taking-over the assets of the rich,
multi-national corporations.
34 We have to learn, once again,
what it means to live within our means, and, we have to learn, once more, that
the restoration of a situation of justice has to be done within our means. We
have to learn, that we have to make a comparable effort in return for the
products we buy. We can not continue to remain dependent upon foreign supplies,
if we want to have a say in the world. We can not continue to live in affluent
and abundant luxuries, while a significant portion of the world population
lives in poverty and under-privileged conditions. We are deluding ourselves, if
we think, that the rest of the world is going to continue to allow the
existence of a few pockets of overheated consumption, while it is becoming
aware of the gigantic injustices that still exist.
35 Let us not delude ourselves in
thinking, that the poorer nations can get what they want, if they are willing
to work hard for it. Most, if not all people who are living in poverty, work
already far harder, than we, in our affluent societies, and, the greatest part
of our affluence does not come from our own "hard work", but from a
reckless rate of depletion of natural resources and the exploitation of the
poorer nations.
36 It is a serious error to think that we will not be seriously challenged, as long as we have our inter-continental nuclear missiles, because injustice and desperation will, eventually, find a way to hold us thoroughly to ransom, while our missiles are sitting powerless in their silos.
.......
Chapter 6
Content
An anxious affluence.
The zone of rational behaviour.
Art, and the zone of emotional neutrality.
Finding happiness in religious attitudes and beliefs.
A number of questions and objections.
It is not useful to describe a position as right or wrong; it is more useful to
recognise the conditions under which a certain point of view becomes valid.
Why we want to be in the emotionally positive zone.
When religious view-points and attitudes are valid.
Charity is, in essence, an outmoded attitude.
Natural ethics.
The place of artistic endeavour.
In arts and sports, it is possible to exist in the emotionally positive zone
without hurting anyone.
The conditions necessary for this to be the case.
The rules of fair and open competition.
Draw-backs for science and technology, when coloured by emotional attitudes.
A rational diagnosis, and therapy, for the problems of man and his societies.
Justice for all, and a state of peaceful co-existence.
1 It is unlikely, that the
affluent nations will change their wasteful and consumptive habits voluntarily.
The level of suspicion and mistrust is still rising, as well as the disparities
between the rich and the poor. The processes of social decay and fragmentation
are going to continue, and, our leaders will be continuing their shrill
rethoric, but, there is always the danger, that anxieties and hostilities rise
to the point that a violent confrontation is likely to break-out. Such a war
will, most likely, be fought with nuclear, as well as conventional weapons.
2 We all know, that the chaos and
destruction of a nuclear war will be unimaginable, and, that the viability of
mankind may be seriously endangered by such a holocaust. We want to do
everything we can to avoid such a disastrous act of desperation from ever
taking place, and, we have to look at all possible mechanisms that may lead to
the outbreak of nuclear war; from a final desperate act to ward-off internal
chaos, an incidence of nuclear blackmail when nuclear devices have fallen into
the hands of terrorists, to a fatal accident and miscalculation.
3 Yet, what can we really do? It
seems impossible to change the momentum of a nation or society, and, the
reforms we are talking about are so dramatic, that few people will think that
it is possible to bring them about. What then, can we do?
4 If we want to solve the problems
of a society, we quickly run into opposition and revolt, because many people
will feel threatened by significant reforms. Everyone in a position of
privilege will feel threatened by a movement towards essential equality, and,
many people genuinely believe, that they deserve what they own. Besides, many
people will be skeptical about any sort of reform, because they have seen
revolutionary upheavals turn into renewed incidences of injustice and violent
dictatorships. Many people do not believe in the possibility of achieving a
situation of universal or long-term justice, or, they cling to the idea, that
those who have been left-out should work a little harder.
5 Some people believe, that it is
an inevitable fact of human nature for some to wind-up with everything, while
the rest of the people are enslaved to a small elite of super-intelligent
people entitled to rule the world.
6 We have discussed all these
attitudes and opinions before, and, we should not repeat the counter-arguments
here. We will only emphasise, once again, the conclusion, that we all have a
lot to learn about human nature, about the way we function, our emotions and
motivations, our personality structure, as well as about the similiarities and
differences between people; be they in our own social environment, or in a
far-away and little known corner of the globe.
7 We first have to learn to agree
about the way we function, feel and think, and, then, we can collectively
choose the way we want to live together. Only, then, will it be possible to
break through the apparently never-ending cycle of birth, growth and vigour,
stagnation, decay and dissolution.
8 Let us return to the negative
range of our emotional scale, and, we will try to analyse and understand, a
little better, what kind of behaviour will keep us in firm control of
ourselves, and, what kind of mistakes will lead us, surreptitiously, into the
zone of social instability and collective suicide.
9 Let us concentrate, therefore,
on the idea, that we function optimally within, or close to, this zone of
emotional neutrality, because, we have concluded, that, the further away we get
from this zone of emotional neutrality, the more difficult it is to control our
behaviour. We know, now, that our behaviour takes place on a sliding scale,
ranging from an aggressive, ebullient and confident attitude, to a cautious,
anxious or defensive mode of behaviour.
10 In the zone of emotional
near-neutrality our behaviour can be tuned to its most refined and appropriate
form by the voluntary will. We have seen, how the human species comes from an
evolutionary line of development, where the responsibility for survival has
been placed, at least, in part, on the ability of the living organism to choose
the most appropriate response under the prevailing circumstances. This has
become necessary in order to make use of rapidly fluctuating and transient
possibilities of existence.
11 Even, if you understand the
ideas behind such a sliding scale of behavioural extremes, it may be difficult
to agree with the concept, that behaviour in the emotionally neutral zone is
more viable or preferable than behaviour in the emotional range, because it
seems obvious, that we prefer to be in the positive range of our emotions,
where we "feel good", confident and secure.
12 "Is it not the instinctive
desire of each living organism to exist in such an optimum equilibrium",
you ask, "where it feels satisfied, satiated, secure and in excellent
condition?" You may argue, that the zone of emotional neutrality does not seem
to be the ideal zone to be in. We prefer to experience an emotion of
satisfaction, satiation, security and confidence, rather than a feeling of
emotional neutrality.
13 "Feeling happy and
experiencing a sensation of moving beauty, is, surely, a state we prefer to be
in, compared to a state of emotional near-neutrality, where we have to work
continuously, sorting-out a confusing mass of contradictory sense
impressions?"
14 "Certainly, our mind may be
most active in this zone of emotional neutrality, and, our powers of objective
observations are most highly developed whenever we exist in this zone.
Scientifically and technologically, we may be most successful, when we are
emotionally more or less neutral, but, this does not mean that we prefer to stay
or live in this zone".
15 "It is a zone of hard work and great achievements, but, where do we fit-in our artistic achievements? Certainly, you do not want to maintain, seriously, that the zone of emotional neutrality is the zone that gave us our writers, novelists, musicians and other artists? Are artists not emotionally motivated, before they can create their artistic works, and, do we, as members of the audience, not have to be emotionally sensitive, before we are able to recognise the value of a work of art?"
16 "How can you say, then,
that we should regard the zone of emotional neutrality as the most desirable
state to be in? What about our passions, our sensitivity to beauty, our
feelings of sexual arousal? Are we not performing in an emotionally aroused
zone, if we respond to this type of stimulus or impulse? You would like us to
remain in an emotionally neutral zone, but, if we do, the next generation would
have a hard time to see the light of existence, because more and more people
would come to the emotionally neutral conclusion, that it is too large a
responsibility to bring-up children."
17 "What about people who have
searched a life-time for the sensation of ultimate happiness or religious
ecstasy? Have they been wrong to look for these feelings of emotional
satisfaction, regardless, whether they found it in the privacy of their
individualised perceptions or in the hard work of being charitable to other
people? Are these forms of behaviour not preferable to a cold and calculating
intellectuality?"
18 "Look at our sense of
ethical behaviour. Does this experience not have to be based on an emotional
gratification; upon a feeling of "being good", whenever we help
others and reduce the level of suffering? Is it not realistic to consider it a
feeling of satisfaction, whenever we recognise a sense of gratitude in those we
have helped?"
19 "I think, that it is wrong
to give the zone of emotional neutrality such a prominent position, or, to
consider it to be the most desirable status of human existence. I believe, that
emotional neutrality has its place, just like emotional exaltation, and, I
think, that it is wrong to try to place the varying levels of emotionality and
rationality on a hierarchical scale of relative importance".
20 So, your counter arguments may
run, and, you would find a great deal of support for your position, because
this would, indeed, be the most common opinion of the thoughtful people of
today. Yet, are these opinions and interpretations correct? Are they completely
or partially right, or, are they "dead wrong"?
21 As usual, it is not very useful
to try to see a position as "right" or "wrong", or, even,
as partially right or partially wrong. It is more meaningful to try to define
an existing opinion or position as a special kind of validity. Perhaps, we can
show, persuasively, that these ideas and attitudes are perfectly valid and
right under special, or specified, circumstances, but, we may also be able to
show that we have to look, seriously, at some of the draw-backs or disadvantages
associated with an opinion that considers the previously outlined position as
being valid at all times.
22 In other words; we have to
generalise further. We have to examine, in depth, the position that has been
stated, and, we have to show, that we can resolve the tensions of the
discrepancies and disadvantages that become apparent in a totally consequent
application of the above position.
23 We hope to show, that the
position, taken above, is perfectly valid, provided, certain social conditions
and circumstances have been met or achieved. Under circumstances of a strictly
adhered-to social contract, we are, indeed, free to behave, far more
frequently, in the emotionally positive zone, but, we will have to acknowledge,
that it is a privilege to do so; that it is a privilege we have to earn, as
well as a privilege we have to make possible for everyone else on the basis of
just social relationships between the peoples of the world.
24 Let us explain this a little
more in detail. There is no argument at all, that we would "prefer"
to exist in the emotionally positive zone. Of course, we all like to feel good,
to feel confident and secure, to be victorious or ebullient, to feel sexually
stimulated, or, to feel a sensation of ecstatic happiness or moving beauty. The
question is, to what extent our desire to be in such a desirable situation,
comes into conflict with similar desires and interests of other people around
us.
25 In other words; is my desire to
be confident and happy, to exist in the positive side of the emotional scale, a
source of conflict, injustice or harm to others? Frequently, it is. Let us
examine the previous arguments a little more in detail.
26 If we have found the truth in a
Faith in God, we may consider ourselves a "saved sinner", or, we
consider ourselves as an individual, who has been chosen for a special purpose
by God. We may derive a great deal of strength and happiness in having found
such an Absolute Certainty, but, often, we lose the ability to understand a differing
point of view.
27 We lose the feeling for those, who disagree with us. We become inflexible and intolerant when defending our Faith, and, we do not have to search far in history, before we see appalling examples of religious fanaticism and intolerance.
28 The same arguments apply to the
even more egocentric and non-ethical ecstasy of a "higher
consciousness", which has preciously little to offer the peoples of the
world, except, perhaps, the temptation of an elitist exclusivity.
29 Similarly, we are wrong, when we
think, that our ethical behaviour-patterns have to be based on a feeling of
"being good", or, by feeling satisfied with the response of
gratitude. This is "charity", and, charity is, in essence an unjust
attitude, which has outlived its usefulness, because well-being is not an item
to be dispensed by benevolent people from a position of privilege, but,
well-being is a basic human right, acquired as a birth-right by everyone.
30 Ethics are based on the
understanding, that a position of privilege has to be shared in order to avoid
devastating tensions of injustice and social unrest. Ethical guidelines are
based on the realisation, that a position of privilege, wealth or power is, so
often, more the result of chance and fortunate accident, rather than merit or
hard work. Ethical principles are based on the insight, that the poor always
work much harder than the rich. Ethics are based on the acceptance of a social
contract, where we recognise the similarities of our competitive drives, and, where
we substitute, deliberately, the mechanisms of competitive strife with those of
a trustful inter-dependence in an atmosphere of essential equality.
31 Sure, we like to fulfill our
desires and fantasies to the full, but, unless we control the instinctive drive
for gratification and evaluate the consequences of our instinctive impulses
rationally, we seem to cause untold harm, suffering and hardship to other
people, and, perhaps, even, to the following generations.
32 Let us look at the questions,
that have been raised about the mechanisms of artistic achievement. Here, we
seem to have a better argument to support the view, that emotionality deserves
a higher place in our esteem than emotional neutrality, in particular, if we
consider the somewhat frightening achievements of science and technology. After
all, these are the acknowledged off-spring of emotional neutrality.
33 Indeed, art is based on the
expression of certain feelings, sensations or awarenesses, which are usually
coloured by fairly strong emotions. The value of a work of art is, partially,
determined by the level of validity and appeal it has for a fairly large number
of people. The more people recognise a work of art as conveying something that
is genuine and strongly expressive, the more value will be attached to this
work of art, but, we are quite well aware of the fact, that the world of
art-appreciation is also influenced, in many instances, by huge commercial
interests.
34 Nevertheless, in any work of
art, there is also an aspect of "technique"; of perfection; of care
and competence in the construction of this work of art, and, our admiration and
appreciation are intricately inter-woven with the technical features of a work
of art. But, the technical aspects of intelligence, care and hard work are
activities that fall in the emotionally neutral zone, is it not?.
35 Art gives us, therefore, a wide
focus for our interests and attention. It appeals, partially, to our more
emotional zones of behaviour, and, if we experience a strong sensation of
recognition that the art-form is honest, accurate and genuine, we feel a strong
sensation of beauty, which lifts us up and sustains us during the more
depressive periods in our lives.
36 Yet, the admiration for
technical aspects, the level of devotion and care, the ingenuity and
intellectually clever solutions of artistic problems, all these aspects fall
into the more neutral zone of our behaviour, but, they become part and parcel
of our ability to appreciate a work of art.
37 There is no doubt, that the
appreciation of art, and, in a somewhat similar manner, the appreciation of,
and participation in, a variety of sports, gives us a chance to exist in an
emotionally positive zone, which we feel to be preferable, or, at least, to be
a welcome change from the long periods of hard work in emotional neutrality.
38 It is interesting to note, here,
that in the arts, as well as the sports, it becomes possible to exist in an
emotionally positive zone without harming anyone else. However, we also notice,
that certain conditions are necessary for this to be the case. Certain
contractual agreements have to be adhered to, before we can say, unequivocally,
that a pre-occupation with arts or sports is not going to hurt someone else.
39 For example, in any competitive
situation, (which is nearly always present in sports, as well as the arts), the
rules of scrupulous equality and impartiality have to be adhered-to, and, they
have to be seen to be adhered-to, otherwise, the people who particiate in these
competitive activities, can not be sure, that, indeed, their position is just,
and, that the positions of the winners and the losers, are completely
justified.
40 If the agreement to adhere,
scrupulously, to the rules of the game or the dictates of an honest artistic
evaluation, has been violated, a feeling of injustice and frustration
inevitably returns.
41 In sports, as well as the arts,
the moment of victory and triumph is short-lived, but, powerful and sweet,
especially, if we can feel, that we genuinely deserve the victory, and, if our
competitors agree, wholeheartedly, with our victory. By far the largest amount
of time is spent in study, training and hard work, and, we know, that the goal
of ultimate achievement is only possible after careful, patient, intelligent
and dedicated efforts, under the guidance of gifted teachers or coaches. This
too, is work done in an emotionally neutral zone, where we are continuously
vigilant and willing to learn from our mistakes.
42 The ability to understand the
problems of artistic or sport's achievements depends upon our efforts in the
emotionally neutral zone, and, we can be sure, that the highest achievements in
any art, or sport, is achieved, only, with a healthy dose of dedication and
hard work in an emotionally neutral frame of mind.
43 If we look at the fields of
science and technology, it is easier to see, how important emotional neutrality
really is. We do not achieve any significant scientific accomplishments, if our
emotions interfere with our work, and, we become quickly aware of disastrous
results, if we lose a careful, diligent and considerate approach to the many
complex technological problems we are confronted with.
44 We see, how the attitude of
"hope", as well as other emotional sentiments, interferes with the
appreciation of scientific and technological problems, and, we are becoming
more aware of the need to school ourselves in a rigorous and disciplined
approach in order to seek solutions in a zone of sustained emotional neutrality.
45 Even, in our national and
international contacts, we can only understand, or, even, appreciate the
view-points and concerns of our adversaries, if we are able to keep a cool head
and take a distance from the problems we are dealing with.
46 While we like to dwell, for
short periods, in the emotionally positive zone, there can be little doubt,
that we can only understand ourselves, together with the conditions necessary
to create a just society, if we learn to discipline ourselves. Only, if we learn
to make full use of our rational faculties, will it be possible to avoid,
individually or collectively, the conditions and circumstances that will
pressure us into a zone of anxious defensiveness, and, possibly, a desperate
panic.
47 The problems of man, our
societies, as well as the world we live in, can only be solved, if we dedicate
ourselves to a diligent search for the mental imagery that lets us agree about
the nature and significance of our problems. Only, if we agree about the
diagnosis, can we agree about the therapy. Only, if we agree about the way we
should interpret our existence and behaviour, only, then, will it be possible
to agree about the meaning of this lofty ideal; justice for all, and a peaceful
coexistence for the whole of mankind.
.......
Chapter 7
Content
Do we really want Peace and Justice?
How many people remember the horrors of war?
Man loves to fight, and, it is not difficult to get him to fight for the glory
of the fatherland.
The horrible consequences of an aggressive euphoria.
An arena to act-out fantasies.
The need to remember the deeds and follies of mankind.
It is so easy to forget, but, forgetting may be a fatal flaw for human
viability.
The pivotal role of education for future generations.
Creating the conditions for a durable and viable cultural code.
The balance between freedom and conformity.
Practical agreements are more important than theoretical points of view.
The shared biological heritage.
If we could just agree, how to live together, and, how to share our resources.
1 The question is; do we really
want peace and justice? Do we want to give-up some of our privileges and
advantages for the sake of equalising opportunities for development and
standards of living?
2 Not really, because the reason,
why we want peace is the fact, that we are afraid for social turmoil and the
upheavals of warfare. We are afraid, that we are going to lose what we have,
but we are not really thinking of those, who will die or be maimed in a war,
or, those who have to live in poverty and deprivation through no fault of their
own.
3 Very few people can truly agree
with the concept, that, those, who have more should relinquish some of their
privileges and luxuries. Most of us feel, that this is a matter for governments
to decide, but, we forget, that, governments are, and should be, chosen by the
people, and, that they reflect, therefore, the will of a majority of the
electorate. Governments are powerless to change the status-quo, if we, the
majority of people want to hang-on to this privileged status-quo.
4 Besides, most of us like a good
fight, as long as we are convinced that we can win. We like a fight,
especially, when we are healthy, vigorous and young. We enjoy flexing our
muscles, to make our presence felt, to throw our weight around, to feel
important and be listened to. These activities soothe and inflate our ego, but,
we do not like to think about the possibility of defeat, or, what it will be
like for our adversaries, if we have defeated them.
5 How many of us remember the
horrors of war? How many know about the miseries of utter despair, humiliating
defeat, disastrous poverty or permanent injuries? History is foreign to most of
us, and, we frequently believe only partially what the older generations tell
us. We suspect, that we are being manipulated or scared into submission.
6 Man likes to fight, and, one of
the main reasons for this is the fact, that the prologue to combat, the
belligerent posturing, the threats and tough commitments, drive us increasingly
into the zone of aggressive euphoria. We revel in our positive notions. We feel
so good, so powerful, so righteous, and, the more we slide into the extreme end
of the positive scale, the less rational we become, and, the more likely an
armed conflict will break-out.
7 Soon, both parties will have adopted a public posture from which they can not climb-down without losing face. The die has been cast. The conflict becomes inevitable, as well as a matter of national pride.
8 Leaders have always been in the
forefront of making belligerent noises, grandiose statements and rallying cries
for battle, regardless, whether we look at our own leaders or those of the
enemy; whether we look at contemporary leaders, or those of the past. When they
have shouted themselves into a corner from which they can not escape without
loss of prestige, they send their peoples into battle with each other.
9 The ordinary people have to die
for a cause, which the law-abiding citizens of either side only partially
understand. Even, if some of them go to war willingly, or, even, with
enthousiasm, all for the "glory of the fatherland", they do so,
because their leaders have brain-washed them into believing, that they are
fighting for the ultimate cause of "Absolute Righteousness".
10 It makes me sick, when I see,
how the primitive emotionality of gifted leaders makes them into war-mongering
monsters, who are losing sight of the broad perspectives of human objectives,
and, who are, eventually, sweeping millions of ordinary people into a senseless
bloodbath.
11 Nobody knows, anymore, what is
going-on, or, what the outcome is going to be. Our emotions have run-away with
us, and the unbridled bellicosity, which is so often a hallmark of a prolonged
period of aggressive euphoria, is one of the most compelling reasons, why we
should look at the apparent attractiveness of emotional extremism with a great
deal of caution.
12 A man, or woman, who is sober,
emotionally neutral and mentally active, may not experience the satanic delusion
of being completely right and all-powerful, with God on his or her side, but,
neither is such an individual likely to plunge into an act of destructive or
suicidal warfare.
13 We still have to learn to
recognise the dangers of emotional extremes, and, in particular, the
dangerously violent swings in the moods of an unstable personality. As we come
closer to the extremes of our mood-scale, we become more prone to violent
swings, and, we begin to shift, rapidly, from extremely positive to extremely
negative moods and perceptions, and vice vera.
14 We may easily destroy ourselves, either, as the result of a blinding euphoria, a rageing belligerence, or, an utter despair, because in all these emotionally extreme conditions, we fail to make use of the remaining possibilities for recovery and improvement.
15 I propose, that we, ordinary and
average people, who have learned the value of a controled emotionality, will
provide for those of us who are incurably addicted to highly emotional
experiences and patterns of behaviour, an arena, where they can act-out their
fantasies. We provide them with an environment, where they can engage in
all-out combat; where they can kill each other, if they like, and, where they
can experience all the violent emotions, from glorious victory to utter
despair.
16 However, we will contain them
and sequester them from the rest of society, but, we will let our children
watch and study them. I am certain, that, by far the majority of our youngsters
will learn, with a certain measure of horror, how important it is to learn to
control their emotions and solve problems by a process of rational compromise,
rather than with violent conflict. And, if a few of our youngsters want to join
them in the fray, well, let them perish or learn the hard way.
17 I am proposing this plan only
partly facetiously, because, in all seriousness, I believe, that we have to
provide a forum, where some people can actually experience the consequences of
unbridled emotionality, while others may learn from the experiences of others
through a process of close observation and intense reflection.
18 Of course, I do not propose this
to be a jail, where people are thrown into if they do not behave. It should be
a voluntary arena, where only criminals convicted of incorrigeable violent
behaviour are forced to spend a certain period of time, as a last resort to try
to rehabilitate them. However, this is only one option in the search for
solving the problems of incorrigeable behaviour, because we have also outlined
the concept, that the most violent and psychopathic forms of behaviour may have
to be eliminated through the death-penalty, when all efforts at rehabilitation
have failed completely.
19 In the societies of the future,
we have to provide contemporary and future generations with the possibility to
have a vivid mental imagery of all forms of human behaviour, and, we have to be
able to see, clearly and honestly, the many and varied consequences that flow
from these behaviour-patterns.
20 We should have on record
completely honest, detailed and full accounts of human behaviour in all its
aspects; from the killing and maiming of people in battle, the atrocities and
cruelties carried-out by psychopaths, as well as the crimes of those, who kill
and terrorise in order to maintain their position of power. In addition, we
should be well aware of the acts of despair, as well as the manifestations of a
bleak depression, which tend to make people into caricatures of what they could
be.
21 We have to learn to face the
consequences of all possible forms of behaviour, at any time, and, as soon as
we forget to teach our children realistically, what the consequences are of all
sorts of behavioural extremes, we will, once again, set the stage for chaos,
war and catastrophe. Then, we will learn, from first-hand experience and in an
actual situation of reality, (with all the existential consequences that flow
from such a situation in real life), the lessons we forgot to keep in mind, and,
which could have refreshed our memories, if we had made the effort to remain
vigilant and reflective.
22 Man is a species whose viability
depends, to a large extent, upon the way he adapts to rapidly changing
circumstances, and, in order to know, how we have to finely-tune our behaviour
to the prevailing circumstances, we have to know a great deal about the
consequences of various behavioural options. We may obtain this body of
knowledge, in part, from personal experience, but, we can learn much more, if
we are willing to learn from the experiences of others.
23 This is the reason, why it will
become ever more important to know the experiences of previous generations,
and, we will really have to study these experiences carefully and honestly, in
order to have some idea, how to avoid the many pitfalls of the present and
safely exploit the opportunities for survival, as they come along.
24 Any human being, who fails to
see the importance of learning honestly and diligently from the experiences of
others, including previous generations, may become a menace to society, because
one may, then, engage in reckless pursuits that could imperil us all.
25 Education will become ever more
important in the future, as we become more aware of the fact, that our survival
depends on intelligent, collective and individual choices, but, education will
have to evolve from the rather unsatisfactory methods that are currently in
use; where a teacher does his best to "pump" as many facts into his
pupils as he can, about the subject that happens to be his teaching
responsibility.
26 It is ridiculous, and senseless,
to let students memorise a series of facts, data or events they do not really
understand, and, the unfortunate result of such an archaic and thoughtless
method of teaching is the fact, that the process of learning becomes irrelevant
to teachers and students alike.
27 We have to start teaching our
students, first, those aspects of life they can directly relate to. These are
the concerns and events that fall, directly, within their sphere of
experiences, but, from this basis we should trace the broad outlines of human
awareness in order to prepare them for adulthood and the burdens of
responsibility. Only, if education becomes a coordinated and serious effort to
expand the intellectual and emotional horizons of our youngsters, only, then,
can we say, that we have begun to understand, how and what to teach.
28 At the present time, only an
occasional youngsters gets something out of the educational experience. The objective
of the expansion of emotional and intellectual horizons is, still, such a
nebulous concept in the minds of most educators, that we have not begun, as
yet, to teach our youngsters adequately.
29 Certainly, to have a truly
effective system of education, the whole atmosphere in society has to change,
and, it is irrealistic to expect a successful and disciplined form of
education, as long as the atmosphere in society is indulgent, lax and confused.
30 A society can only create an
educational system that is in tune with public opinion, and, in most affluent
societies, we still have to discover the value of a measure of self-restraint,
before we can expect to see an effective educational program.
31 We can only create a
comprehensive, globally relevant and understandable system of education, if our
attitudes, view-points and life-styles have converged into a lean, viable and
just standard that is shared throughout the world. It may be too late to see
this trend emerge, and, it may well be, that the momentum of chaos and
confusion will wipe-away, whatever educational system we have. It is also
possible, that the changes in the educational system will be so slow, that it
is not my good fortune to see the beginning of a turn into the right direction.
32 Yet, after I am gone, there will
be many other concerned people in every society around the globe, and, perhaps,
they can streamline their ideas and agree amongst themselves, what our human
priorities should be. Perhaps, they can make a start with the construction of a
globally acceptable perception of reality.
33 A widely shared and agreed-upon
reality perception has to arise, before we can agree amongst ourselves about an
educational curriculum. We are back to the importance of a globally acceptable vision
of reality, as well as an agreed-upon perception of the meaning of our
existence, but, I would like to emphasise, once again, that such an agreement
has nothing to do with a belief in an "Absolute Reality".
34 As a matter of fact, we can only
find common avenues for our reality perceptions, if we explore, carefully, the
ideas and concepts we can agree about, and, which seem to offer the best
possible solutions for the problems we face. The only realistic way to come to
an agreement about a globally relevant perception of reality, is to
distinguish, clearly, between those concepts and ideas that can be left,
safely, to a measure of individual variability in interpretation, and those,
which require, for practical purposes, a much clearer and sharper definition,
as well as a measure of consensus.
35 Just as we can agree about the
rules of traffic, while leaving each individual free, where to go, and, what
sort of vehicle to drive, so should it be possible to agree upon the rules that
regulate the transactions and contacts of people, while leaving each individual
free about the details of his or her innermost convictions and beliefs.
36 As long as we can agree amongst
ourselves, that we should live under essentially equal opportunities for
development and essentially equal standards of health and freedom, we do not
have to agree about all the aspects of human existence. As long as we agree,
that we have to start on the road towards global equality and harmony, we may
discuss and debate the various ideas about how to get there.
37 However, we can leave it to each
individual's point of view, whether one is a creature of one's God, or a
product of natural evolution. The only reason for dealing with dogmatic beliefs
and attitudes are the consequences of such convictions, especially, if they
begin to interfere with the rights and freedoms of other human beings. For
example, it is important to debate the practical issues of ownership on various
levels of social existence, because the level of ownership, be it on a private,
a corporate or a national level, has significant consequences for the balance
of powers, as well as the implementation of a contract of essential equality.
38 We should consider and discuss
the balance between rights and obligations, rather than the will of God, the
destiny of man in an after-life, or the sins of other people. Let us examine
ourselves with scrupulous honesty, and, let us acknowledge as legitimate
ambitions in others, whatever ambitions and behaviour-patterns we consider to
be legitimate for ourselves.
39 Common sense and honesty,
openness and a willingness to question everything we hear or see, to make sure
we understand something as precisely as possible, will go a long way towards
the necessary foundation for global cooperation and harmony.
40 We will have to acknowledge a
position of privilege frankly, but, we will also have to acknowledge, equally
frankly, that we will resist being robbed of our privileges, whenever someone
forces us to give-up a position of privilege and comfort we think we deserve.
41 While it is ignorant and
short-sighted to become narrowly concerned with our own problems when basking
in affluence, comfort and wasteful habits, it is equally ignorant and
short-sighted to grab for the primitive tools of power and violence, as long as
we have not exhausted all other possible avenues to effect a change in the
balance of powers and conditions of social injustice.
42 Before condemning elitism and egocentricity
in others, let us make sure, that we are generous and broad-minded ourselves,
and, that we avoid being caught-up in a fanatic effort to bring-about
short-sighted and dogmatic revolutionary reforms.
43 Before we become absolutely
convinced, that our way of looking at the world is the only just and right way,
let us soberly reflect upon the fact, that our most intransigent enemies think
just like us.
44 Absolute Certainty and our
unquestioned faith in an Absolute Truth, act like an emotional filter,
colouring the perception of all our realities. Such an attitude makes us rigid,
and, we lose viability in the long run, while paying the price of a staggering
level of suffering and destruction.
45 The resilience of hopeful
expectations and strength of character that come with an absolute faith and the
certainty of being in the right, may be valuable, but rather primitive, tools
to withstand severe stress, but, in the complex societies of today, and the
future, the accent will have to lie on the prevention, rather than the
resistance of stress. This can only be done by hard and conscientious work in
an emotionally neutral frame of mind, because, only then, can we maintain
essential equality of existence and a fair sense of justice for everyone. It is
not sufficient to extend the sphere of concern and implement the principles of
justice only to those, who think and believe as we do.
46 Relativity in the perception of
reality is nothing more than the common-sense realisation, that we all share a
tendency, as well as a need, to construct a picture of reality that is centered
around the interests and concerns of our own existence. Yet, to acknowledge the
common bonds of existentially similar, or, even, identical requirements, will
give us the best possible opportunity to see each other as people, sharing a
same fate and a same need, regardless of creed or ideology.
47 If we could just agree amongst
ourselves, how we should live together and share our resources, potentials and
problems, we will have reached a sufficient level of understanding to make a
fruitful diagnosis of mankind's ills, and, we will be well on our way towards a
long-term condition of social and individual health.
.......
Chapter 8
Content
We are not there, as yet.
A gloomy prospect for modern, affluent, Capitalist societies.
The blessings of having plenty of room to get-away from each other.
Subjective reflections.
Controling our feelings of despair and euphoria.
We want to be able to trust each other.
We are afraid of being deceived and exploited.
A few ideas about how to create a stable, viable, large-scale society.
The mechanisms of "hope".
Hope is re-enforced by emotional resonance.
Hope is a deliberate filter for our sense impressions and interpretations.
The high price of religious fervor.
We are all human beings, friends and foes alike.
No weak-kneed attitude, begging for mercy, but, no stubborn and unnecessary
resistance either.
Contacts, laid during a situation of conflict, may bloom into a greater degree
of mutual understanding, even, friendship.
Let us be weary of facile propaganda.
Let us remain calm and controled.
The horrors of a nuclear holocaust.
1 However, we are not there, as
yet. We have not even begun to move into the right direction. There is no
widespread awareness, that we need a global integration of mankind, nor am I
aware of any trend towards a globally acceptable interpretation of reality.
2 If I look around me, I see a
slow, but steady rise in the level of anxiety. Increasingly blatant egocentric
attitudes seem to be rewarded, time and again. Many modern, affluent societies
are slowly fragmenting, and the antagonistic factions are becoming more hostile
towards each other.
3 The various regions of my
country are drifting further apart, as people squabble over the ownership of
resources and the distribution of revenues and royalties. Many societies seem
to have a tendency to fragment along ethnic lines, and there is also a
polarisation between the work-force, the business community, and the various
bureaucracies.
4 The general public gets
squeezed, and becomes increasingly cynical. I am not very optimistic about what
I see in my social environment, but, then, what is happening, here, may not be
representative for what is going-on throughout the world. The people of my
country are still living a rather sheltered life. Conditions are still quite
stable. There is no significant poverty. There is no civil violence, as yet,
and, by and large, the people are soft, indulgent and spoiled by constant
affluence and commercial enticements.
5 The level of education and
general comprehension is fairly low. Many people are blissfully ignorant about
the major problems people face in other parts of the world, and, they are
equally unaware of the relative prosperity and ease of living they enjoy in
their own social environment.
6 Because our country is sparsely
populated, rich in resources, vast in territory, and, by and large, cold and
inhospitable, we do not experience any of the population pressures, which are
so obvious in densely populated areas.
7 Apart from a few overheated,
unhealthy urban pockets with dense populations, we can still get-away from each
other if we want to. This is the reason, why our urban over-crowding is not
really a serious problem. People can get-away, and, they do so, on the
week-ends, while the population of a small, poor and densely populated country
has a much more difficult time to get-away from it all. This is one of the
reasons, why the people of my country can tear their country apart without
anyone lifting a finger, because, we can all retreat to our enclaves and look
out the window to see what is going-on.
8 In a way, I have done the same
thing. I have made use of a certain affluence and the spaciousness of this beautiful
country to retreat to the country-site and to think about what is going-on. I
look out the window, too, and I listen to what is happening, monitoring the
significant events and developments on my short-wave radio. I read books and
listen to the music of composers from the past.
9 I am not optimistic about the
developments I see, but, then, I enjoy the opportunity to relax and reflect,
and, I hope that my writings may, some day, make a contribution to the
comprehension and awareness of people all over the world.
10 I am also subject, like everyone
else, to certain mood-swings, and, while I believe to have a reasonable degree
of control over my emotions, I notice, how necessary it is to make a deliberate
effort, time and again, to bring myself back into a sphere of emotional
neutrality.
11 It seems, that, without such a
deliberate effort to control our emotions, we have a tendency to oscillate more
wildly between opposing moods, in particular, when we respond to an emotional
synchrony.
12 In the phenomenon of
"emotional synchrony", we see a clear example, how the constant
re-enforcement of a certain mood may lead to extreme emotional tensions. It is,
as if the emotions are constantly amplified by the synchrony of people
re-enforcing each other's mood. This may lead to the feverish belligerence of a
war-psychosis, but, it may also result in a desperate panic or a leaderless
stampede.
13 We need to control ourselves,
and, we need to encourage others to control themselves, and, occasionally, we
have to take firm control over people, whenever they appear to lose the ability
to behave rationally.
14 While I am not particularly
impressed with the level of education in my country, and, while I deplore the
easy indulgence, gullibility and commercialised religiosity which seems to be
so prevalent on this Continent, I know, that, I would not have had the chance
to retire so early in my career in any other social environment, and, I would
not have had the freedom to choose a life of frugal near self-sufficiency, with
a complete freedom over my time.
15 Even in the people around me, I
sense a basic decency underneath the confused attitudes of egocentricity and
wasteful, consumptive habits, and, I know, that the people of my society, just
like peoples all over the world, would welcome the ideals of global cooperation
and integration, as long as they could really trust these ideals and did not
have to sacrifice too much.
16 No-one wants to be exploited
when listening to altruistic impulses, only to find out, later, that one has
been cleverly deceived. We want to be able to trust each other again, but, we
also want to know, for sure, that our trust is reciprocated and is not being
abused.
17 We still recognise the fact,
that we have to create genuine equality and justice on a global scale, but,
those, who live in affluent societies, do not know where to start. We do not
want to give-up anything, because we are afraid that our neighbours or
governments, the big corporations, as well as the many powerful special-interest
groupings will benefit from our acts of good-will, and, we are afraid, that our
efforts will turn-out to be fruitless. We are afraid to be deceived and
exploited, and, this is the principal reason, why the attitudes of belligerent
egocentricity are now tacitly accepted as normal.
18 We have a good idea, how we can
rid ourselves from such a collective attitude of defensive suspiciousness,
because we know, now, that we have to increase the level of transparence in society
to such a level, that we can verify for ourselves, whether or not our acts of
trust and good-will are matched by similar acts of trust and good-will from our
neighbours; whether or not our governments are using the fruits of our
collective acts of good-will and trust in such a way, that the original
intentions and objectives of these acts are being realised.
19 Let us hope, that we will be able to see a trend developing towards an increase in mutual cooperation and trust, because we know, that the road of increasing egocentricity leads only to violent conflict, chaos and death. At the same time, we should, in these last few pages, fulfill a promise we made earlier in this essay, when we announced that we would discuss the functions of the attitude of "hope".
20 What is hope? Hope is an
attitude of expectation, where we derive a great deal of comfort by
contemplating, almost continuously, the expectations for an improvement in the
near future. Obviously, we hope for something better, when we are under a
certain amount of stress. In our attitudes of hopeful expectation, we are
trying to cope with the disturbing realities of the present, but, we see, also,
that this attitude of hopeful expectation is an emotional and, often, not a
very effective response to the problems and stresses we face.
21 If we look a little more closely
at the conditions, where hopeful expectations begin to play a major role in our
defense against a stressful situation, we see, that the stress is already
fairly severe and long-standing. We have exhausted the rational attempts to
fight or resist this stress. In addition, we see, that we are increasingly
driven into a defensive corner of hopeful expectations, whenever a rational
analysis of the factors that give rise to this stress, only indicate, that the
level of stress is likely to continue or to get worse.
22 If a community has been occupied
and subdued by an occupying power, and, if armed resistance has been overcome
by captivity and an overwhelming force of oppression, then, the mind tries to
rid itself from the continuously depressing effects of a rational evaluation of
the situation. This is done by "hoping", that something will happen,
which will make the conquerors leave.
23 If rational thoughts and
evaluations keep telling us, that things are likely to get worse, we tend to
ignore such rational considerations, or, we ridicule such rationality and
condemn it as "treacherous", if we are still in a relatively powerful
position. If we have already been defeated, we can only hope, that the
situation will improve, somehow, in spite of all the rational evidence to the
contrary.
24 No wonder, that we are thrown
back to this marvelous but, often, so painful attitude, where we place our
Faith in the Lord. We place the burdens of worrying about the problems of our
existence and the stresses of the present, on God. Hope is re-enforced by a
mutual resonance, and we see many remarkable examples in history, how a small
community was able to tolerate nearly unbearable levels of stress as a result
of this mutually re-enforced attitude of hope and faith.
25 Yet, the price is high, and,
such an attitude of hopeful expectations requires an enormous amount of energy.
There is always the possibility that doubts about the validity of our hope and
faith will surface again, and, these doubts have to be stifled and suppressed.
If hopes and prayers remain unfulfilled for a prolonged period of time, we are
beginning to wonder, why it takes the Lord such a long time to answer.
26 An attitude of hope and prayer
is a powerful way to sustain a severe stress for a relatively short period of
time, but, it is less effective to solve any of the real problems, or, to
answer any of the questions, why we find ourselves in such a stressful
situation in the first place.
27 During an attitude of hope, we
filter, deliberately, our sense impressions, thoughts and observations in such
a way, that we accentuate the positive findings out of proportion to the
negative sense impressions. We constantly bring to the focus of our minds those
hints, possibilities or thoughts, that may indicate an impending improvement,
while we shut-out, nearly completely, all the rational observations that give
us a negative but more realistic view of the situation at hand.
28 Let us examine the reasons, why
a suppression of these negative but rational data may be detrimental to our
ability to solve practical problems. If we cloud our reality perceptions with
the undifferentiated glow of hopeful expectations, we lose the ability to make
full use of data that are available. Our rational faculties could analyse these
data, provided, we would be able to control the somewhat anxious and depressive
feelings that are associated with analysing a situation that is clearly a
disadvantage for us.
29 Yet, the rewards are high. We
may see possibilities that would completely elude us, if we would give-in to
the euphoria of hopeful expectations, stubborn religious resistance, or, the
undifferentiated feelings of a hopeless despair. We may be able to review,
clearly and calmly, the series of events, as well as the sequence of our own
behavioural reactions, which, eventually, culminated in the position we find
ourselves in. We may be able to see, where we made mistakes, or, where we
contributed to the problems we are facing, or, where we were to blame for the
attitudes of belligerence, aggressiveness or hatred from our victorious
enemies.
30 We may be able to see, that, the
soldier, who is looting our property or putting us in confinement, is acting on
orders from his leadership, just as we have been called to arms and would have
done the same, if we had been victorious. We may discover to our surprise, that
the enemy soldier does not have any clearer perceptions about the war than we.
31 We may suddenly discover, that,
he too, is a human being, just like ourselves, and, that he does not like to
fight or be involved in the war anymore than we. We may discover, that he is
homesick, loves his family and carries a photograph of his wife and children. Suddenly,
we realise that we are both in the same situation, and, that neither of us
exactly understands, why we are in conflict with each other.
32 While a thoughtless and anxious
desire to collaborate with the enemy will rightly evoke only suspicion and
contempt on either side, we should not forget the possibilities, that are given
in the contacts arising from a situation of conflict. There are many
opportunities to accentuate the common, humanitarian features of each other's
existence. There is a good chance, that our enemy does not want to make our
life anymore miserable than he has to, provided, that he can trust us to some
extent not to kill him or injure him in a moment of friendliness or
inattention.
33 If we understand, that he is
doing a job on orders of his commanders, just as we are under orders of our
leadership, we may explore, together, the possibilities to make each other's
life as tolerable as possible. This is not treachery. This is not deceitful to
the interests of the fatherland. This is good common-sense, as well as an
acknowledgement of reality as it exists. It signifies the realisation, that we
all are pawns in high-stake power-plays of our respective leaderships.
34 Let us not adopt a weak-kneed
attitude of begging for mercy at the slightest hint of stress, but, let us
remain calm at all times. Let us never forget, that there are two sides to any
story, and, let us never forget, that, in a situation of armed conflict, the
soldiers on both sides have been given a slanted interpretation of the
background events, putting each side unquestionably in the right.
35 The contacts between enemy
soldiers during a war may give us a chance to communicate and to find-out, what
the other side believes to be true. In a historical overview, as well as in the
conflicts between rival adolescents, we can always see the seeds of
communication and mutual understanding arise during and after a period of
belligerent contact.
36 Let us always be aware of facile
propaganda and resist a gullible acceptance of whatever our leaders want us to
believe. These are attitudes that lead to uncompromising belligerence, and,
eventually, to bloodshed.
37 There is a lot to be learned, if
we remain emotionally neutral under all conditions, and, the fruits of
understanding are plentiful, if we can resist the temptation to be goaded into
a dull and undifferentiated emotion of hopeful expectation, the bellicosity of
aggressive exuberance, or, the annihilating destructiveness of hopeless
despair. With such attitudes, we lose everything, but, there is no need to lose
everything. Let us be weary of facile conclusions about who is right and who is
wrong. Regardless, how unlikely it seems to us, as we are involved in a
conflict-situation, we may not be totally right, and, let us keep in mind the
undeniable fact, that the other side is just as convinced to be right as we
are. Let us not forget, that the soldiers on the other side are also doing
their civic and military duties, because they have been called-upon to defend
their fatherland and the interests of their country.
38 If we remain calm, emotionally
neutral and sensitive to the arguments put forward by both sides, then,
conflicts can be avoided, and, if the belligerent parties are so involved and
emotionally aroused that they do not want to listen to reason, or, do not want
to compromise and negotiate in good faith, then, citizens of the world, let us
make sure, that we have the power, the discipline, as well as the resolve to
intervene and force them to come to their senses.
39 If we fail to do so, we may,
eventually, find ourselves completely powerless, as we watch the super-powers
of the world lapse into a catastrophic emotional turmoil of blind, aggressive
hatred or a black despair. Then, citizens of the world, we may see the people
in power push those fatal buttons that unleash a nuclear holocaust. Then,
citizens of the world, we will be witnessing the suicide of mankind, as it
destroys itself in a moment of utter frenzy and madness.
40 It does not matter, then, whether
or not a few miserable remnants of humanity may survive for a few more
generations, because the technology for survival will have been lost forever,
and, these miserable remnants will be unable to cope with the disastrously high
levels of radio-active contamination and other toxic pollutants.
41 Then, citizens of the world,
those last few citizens will witness, how more and more of their children are
born, hideously deformed, mentally and physically defective, totally incapable
of sustaining the fight for survival. It will be a slow and miserable death, so
full of despair and so depressing in its scope, that no attitude of hope, not,
even, a desperate attempt to analyse and think rationally, is going to make any
difference.
42 Our youths will be crippled, sick, diseased, mentally abnormal, and, everyone will be going insane, before the genetic code of the human species will finally become totally and irrevocably extinct.
43 Never again will there be a
human species on this earth. Never again, will there be a human awareness or a
sensation of beauty and gratitude. Never again will there be hundreds of
millions of people watching a young girl skate beautifully to an Olympic
gold-medal, and, never again, will we see those moving tears trickle down her cheeks,
as she stands, there, on that platform; a glorious symbol of human achievement.
......
Summary
1. A small vignette.
The figure-skater.
Tears of relief and gratitude.
The sensations of beauty and happiness.
The value of long-term goals.
The fusion between goal and achievement.
No trace of a cheap triumph.
A sense of indebtedness to the people
Emotional resonance.
True achievement does not have to lead to an egocentric victory.
Sentimentality; an emotional over-reaction.
The need to understand our own behaviour.
2. The free-floating cell.
The basic discrimination between benefit and harm.
Aggression; "moving towards"; "ad-grado".
Negative and positive stimuli.
The sense of vision.
The search for a possibility to exist.
The short-cut of animal existence.
The inevitability of death in the end.
Human behaviour-patterns.
The closer we behave to an emotional extreme, the less our behaviour is under
the control of rational evaluations.
Behavioural flexibility, and the ability to finely tune our responses.
The functions of the "free will".
A fusion of contemporary sense impressions with the memories of the past, as
well as the expectations for the immediate future.
Evolution; a second shock for Christianity, after the discovery, that the earth
was not the center of the Universe.
3. Looking at ourselves from an evolutionary point of view.
A fascinating blend of emotional and rational behaviour-patterns.
Verbalisable awarenesses; the tip of an ice-berg.
The possibility to deceive; a by-product of intellectual abilities.
The trade-off between scope and detail.
The need for cohesion in scientific knowledge.
We can not grasp the essence of being human from the "humanities"
only.
An increasingly important role for the biological sciences in philosophical efforts
to grasp the essence of human existence.
The role of intuition in a philosophical effort.
An emphasis on the negative, defensive aspects of human behaviour.
The price of specialisation.
The solution of "behavioural flexibility".
A more complex vision.
The subjective experience of a "free will".
4. Rationality decreases as we slide further down the defensive
scale.
The essence of "being depressed".
Paralysed by fear; a question of over-loading the central nervous system.
The panic-reaction; a useless form of agitated behaviour.
Alternating states of depression and hyper-activity.
The liability of a state of panic, hyper-activity, depression or paralysis.
Too stringent and thoughtless a form of self-discipline transforms us into
robots, but, an insuffient level of self-discipline makes us into a whining and
egocentric child.
The value of controled behaviour-patterns.
Learning to protect ourselves from attack and exploitation.
The strong personality.
Self-discipline, and the commercial interests.
Control, yes; suppression, no.
Oscillating rapidly, but gently, around the zone of emotional neutrality.
The attitude of "hope".
The practice of self-deception.
The emotional "ground-tone".
Why it is so difficult to grow-up into happy adulthood in a confused society.
The "saving grace" of working hard towards a long-term goal.
We need an elusive balance between achievement and failure.
Smouldering ghettos.
The wounds of chronic injustice.
The value of reflective thought.
A sense of sadness.
A few personal reflections.
5. Anger and anxiety caused by insecurity.
The leader who is losing his support.
A review of leadership mechanisms.
The jungle of international relations.
The temptation to grab and hold-on to power by force.
Increasing anxieties.
Social decay; a variety of mechanisms.
The need for sound fiscal principles.
We all have to learn to live within our means.
Missiles sitting powerless in their silos.
6. An anxious affluence.
The zone of rational behaviour.
Art, and the zone of emotional neutrality.
Finding happiness in religious attitudes and beliefs.
A number of questions and objections.
It is not useful to describe a position as right or wrong; it is more useful to
recognise the conditions under which a certain point of view becomes valid.
Why we want to be in the emotionally positive zone.
When religious view-points and attitudes are valid.
Charity is, in essence, an outmoded attitude.
Natural ethics.
The place of artistic endeavour.
In arts and sports, it is possible to exist in the emotionally positive zone
without hurting anyone.
The conditions necessary for this to be the case.
The rules of fair and open competition.
Draw-backs for science and technology, when coloured by emotional attitudes.
A rational diagnosis, and therapy, for the problems of man and his societies.
Justice for all, and a state of peaceful co-existence.
7. Do we really want Peace and Justice?
How many people remember the horrors of war?
Man loves to fight, and, it is not difficult to get him to fight for the glory
of the fatherland.
The horrible consequences of an aggressive euphoria.
An arena to act-out fantasies.
The need to remember the deeds and follies of mankind.
It is so easy to forget, but, forgetting may be a fatal flaw for human
viability.
The pivotal role of education for future generations.
Creating the conditions for a durable and viable cultural code.
The balance between freedom and conformity.
Practical agreements are more important than theoretical points of view.
The shared biological heritage.
If we could just agree, how to live together, and, how to share our resources.
8. We are not there, as yet.
A gloomy prospect for modern, affluent, Capitalist societies.
The blessings of having plenty of room to get-away from each other.
Subjective reflections.
Controling our feelings of despair and euphoria.
We want to be able to trust each other.
We are afraid of being deceived and exploited.
A few ideas about how to create a stable, viable, large-scale society.
The mechanisms of "hope".
Hope is re-enforced by emotional resonance.
Hope is a deliberate filter for our sense impressions and interpretations.
The high price of religious fervor.
We are all human beings, friends and foes alike.
No weak-kneed attitude, begging for mercy, but, no stubborn and unnecessary
resistance either.
Contacts, laid during a situation of conflict, may bloom into a greater degree
of mutual understanding, even, friendship.
Let us be weary of facile propaganda.
Let us remain calm and controled.
The horrors of a nuclear holocaust.
........