Click here for PDF format of this essay
THE ADOLESCENT PERSONALITY
A Study in Thought
sa076
by
Marius Heuff
Chapter 1
Content
The adolescent personality; a separate entity?
A metamorphosis.
A matter of definition.
A common bond of youthful exuberance.
Various ways of looking at the realities of adolescent existence.
An inexorable process of divergence between adolescents.
A look at the purpose of acquiring intellectual skills.
Physical growth and sexual awakening.
A turbulent time.
There is no coherent and generally agreed-upon imagey about the human
personality.
Difficulties for a common-sense discussion about the adolescent personality.
A bold attempt.
An emphasis on the common features of adolescence; their origins in childhood,
and the evolutionary background of our mammalian heritage.
1 "Are you sure, that there
is such an entity as the adolescent personality?", you may ask, as you
read the title. "Is this not an example, where we create, rather
arbitrarily, a separate category, without any real need for doing so?
Certainly, we can group-together a few common denominators in the behaviour and
personalities of young people, as they get ready to mature and find a place in
society, but, this does not mean, that we should give these common
characteristics a separate form of existence by calling them "the
adolescent personality".
2 "If we give-in to the
temptation to create new entities, whenever our fancy decrees, we will only
burden ourselves with vague and unnecessary words and ideas, which do not
really serve a useful purpose. By creating the concept of an adolescent
personality, we may give the impression, that all young people go through a
certain stage in their behaviour and personality make-up, which sets them apart
from the children they were before, and the adults they are going to be. If we
group these people together, as adolescents with their own peculiar
characteristics, we may suggest, that all young people go through a very similar
phase, and show a similar appearance, somewat like the transformation of a
larva into a moth during the puppal stage of metamorphosis".
3 "I think, that it is far
more realistic to see the adolescent as a young individual, displaying,
already, most of the characteristics of the adult personality, because, then,
we emphasise the variability and complexity of the behaviour of young people,
and, we do not give the erroneous impression, that there is a marked uniformity
in the behaviour of young or adolescent people. Certainly, researchers can
tabulate the behavioural characteristics of a large group of high-school
students and present the common features as the prototype of the adolescent
personality, but, what does this really mean? Does it mean, that young
adolescents share a common personality which is reflected in the stage of their
life-cycle, rather than the specific features of their genetic endowments,
together with the chance-contacts and specifics of their personal
history?".
4 "Of course, we can
emphasise the youthful exuberance of their elan vital. We can emphasise their
expectations for the future, their energy and enthousiasm, as well as their
failures and moods of depression. We see, that, some people are well on their
way to become prominent members of society, well-educated, secure and
well-adjusted, while others remain drifters at the periphery, with friends and
associates who are also on the fringes of society. We can emphasise the
sensitivity of young people to justice, or, rather, to being treated unjustly,
and, we may see, how their vitality translates into anger and violence, but,
somtimes we see, how they seize upon an opportunity and develop rapidly their
abilities and skills in a way that amazes their teachers and guardians".
5 "Adolescence shows a
fascinating field of potentials and early starts in development, but, why
should we call this a separate category of personalities? Why should we not
consider them to be in a transitional stage, between the world of childhood and
maturity, making tentative preparations to enter, somewhere, this
overwhelmingly complex and layered world of the larger adult societies?
Class-mates and friends of school will quickly become absorbed in different
social strata, and, they will lose sight and contact. If you want to use the
title of the adolescent personality for a view that is specifically oriented
upon this transitional period, where the human being has the somewhat ambiguous
privilege of growing-up into adulthood, then, I can agree with your choice of
title, and, I will now let you discuss the adolescent personality, without
further interruptions from a critical reader".
6 Thank you, and you have pointed-out an important observation. Indeed, we have to scrutinise, time and again, whether or not our concepts and ideas serve indeed a useful purpose; whether or not they are perpetuating, somewhat unthinkingly, a notion that is accepted on the authority of tradition, but has become vague and outdated. You are quite right to point-out, that the adolescent indvidual is in a transitional stage between childhood and adulthood, and, that he or she already displays the major behavioural trends of his or her personality, which will be visible for the remainder of this individual's life, and, I agree, also, that there is such a remarkable variety of personalities during this transitional stage that it is superficial to visualise a "typical" or representative personality of the adolescent.
7 However, we should, indeed, not
forget, that adolescents share a very important and powerful process of
physical change, which colours their behaviour to a remarkable extent. We are,
indeed, not dealing with anything as dramatic as a complete meta-morphosis,
but, the physical and mental processes of maturation, of sexual awakening and
physical growth, together with the social and emotional changes associated with
this period, all these happenings are so dominant and profound, that we may,
indeed, consider them to give adolescent behaviour a characteristic set of
features.
8 The physical changes that take
place in the period of adolescence, starting with puberty and ending somewhere
in adulthood, are well known, and, even, the psychological manifestations are a
frequent subject of attention and discussion. However, we still tend to
concentrate on the experiences, tensions and emotions of adolescence, rather
than on a clear, lucid and rational over-view of the whole process. This is
partly a result of the fact, that we are so much a part of this process, either
as an adult dealing with young people, or as an adolescent trying to understand
what is happening, and, trying to cope with the many tensions that are
invariably a part of growing-up in a complex society.
9 Usually, we concentrate on an
empirical evaluation of these tensions and mechanisms of adolescence, because
we do not have a clear intellectual picture of these processes. While the
sciences of psychology and child education are full of opinions and schools of
thought, it still remains difficult to put the whole field of adolescence, as
well as the myriad of behavioural aspects, into a lucid perspective, because we
have not developed, as yet, a choherent and generally agreed-upon image of the
human personality.
10 We are, intellectually as well
as emotionally, somewhat confused about the whole field of adolescence,
including the phenomenon of sexuality and human emotions in general, and, we
look, therefore, to a portrayal of these mechanisms in an artistic or dramatic
form. While we find it extremely difficult to decide, intellectually, whether
or not a particular view, theory or opinion has merit, we find it easier to
recognise, or reject, a specific portrayal of a conflict-situation in a
dramatic or comic perspective of human relationships, especially, relationships
between young people.
11 For this reason, our world of
entertainment is full of portrayals of specific situations, but, it is uncommon
to see a readable, common-sense discussion about the phenomenon of adolescence;
a discussion that does not lose itself in technical research details, or, vague
platitudes that hide the inability to trace, boldly, the common denominators
and general features of human behaviour, regardless of its stage of
development. This lack of a commonly agreed-upon scientific hypothesis of human
behaviour is not the only reason, why it is so difficult to come to a generally
acceptable, common-sense discussion, because many cultural variables play an
important role in the way we interpret the essence of human behaviour.
12 You have guessed it. We will try
such a common-sense approach, and, hopefully, it will turn-out to be a readable
and sensible discussion about the behaviour of young people. We will not refer,
in detail, to any specific school of thought or field of research, but, I like
to be guided, primarily, by what we all can see and observe around us, if we
use a dose of common-sense and a general awareness of the modern sciences.
13 I like to use an approach that
is somewhat different from an attempt to be completely thorough and
comprehensive. In stead of discussing many aspects in detail and sketch a
rather static portrait of young people in a particular stage of their
development, I am going to refer, constantly, to the more common features and
characteristics of adolescence, as well as to their origins in childhood or the
evolutionary history of mammalian life. I will also refer, frequently, to the
inter-play between genetic and environmental influences, as well as the later
stages of human development, because, as you mentioned, adolescence is, in
essence, a transitional stage and can best be illuminated by looking at the
stages it came from, and, the developments into which it is evolving. I will
refer to ideas I have developed more extensively in other essays on the nature
of the human personality, but I hope to make this discussion lucid, logical and
relatively easy to follow, because the subject-matter will be treated
informally.
.......
Chapter 2
Content
Every living organism represents a channel for the dissipation of an
energy-gradient.
High-energy electron-bonds, formed by the capture of solar energy.
A synopsis of the evolution of the living organisation.
The need to spend energy is a characteristic shared by all life-forms.
A constant expenditure of "maintenance energy".
"Elan vital"; a measure of surplus energy.
A remarkable surplus energy at the onset of healthy adolescence.
The need for guidance, and the likelyhood of experiencing frustrations.
A willingness to take risks.
Data selection, according to the "filter" of our mood or outlook.
Socially determined deviations from a well-accepted "norm".
Anger and frustrations, based on sharp disparities in living conditions.
Young people are ready to commit their youthful energies to an ideal.
An increased emphasis on the realities of social conditions.
Learning to "fit-in".
Developing a skill to make a living.
The specialised "niche" in the social environment.
Building self-confidence.
The need to develop all faculties harmoniously.
Every individual can develop a few skills "above average".
Personality development, and an unavoidable divergence in skills, talents and
social status.
Learning to analyse the many reasons behind diverging personality developments.
The influence of class-divisions upon the outlook of the adolescent
personality.
Mobility through the social classes represents a sign of social well-being.
Social mobility preserves the factor of "social status" as a
reflection of individual merit.
Problems associated with "over-privileged" youngsters.
The phenomenon of "late maturers".
Youngsters with learning disabilities.
Physically or mentally handicapped people will always need special schooling,
as well as a carefully protected niche in society.
1 Every living organism is a
channel for the dissipation of energy, and, it dissipates, at least, a small
part of the energy-gradient that has been built-up in the form of high-energy
electron bonds by the capture of radiant energy from the sun. These excited
electrons provide the energy for the many biochemical reactions upon which the
functions of the cellular protoplasm depend.
2 Animals are living organisms
that have abandoned, or lost, the ability to capture this solar energy
themselves, while the world of plant-life has retained the ability of
photo-synthesis. Animals developed the ability to move their bodies around, and
hunt actively for their food. These activities are coordinated by the central
nervous system and are carried-out by the muscular and skeletal systems.
3 We have often looked at this
remarkable flow of events, which is initiated when a fertilised egg-cell finds
a possibility to exist and unfold its potentials; when it finds, e.g., a secure
place in the womb of a mammal. Even, after birth, we see a prolonged period of
rapid growth and astonishing developments. This constant flow of energy, which
is channeled through a growing organism of living existence, is gradually
transformed from a "building" activity to an activity of
"energy-dissipation". The latter is represented by movements and all
sorts of activities, carried-out by the organism. We all know, how active a
healthy child is, and, how it can not sit still for any length of time.
4 This drive to spend energy is a characteristic shared by all life, and, we know, how each cell, as well as every organism, has to spend a minimum amount of energy to "repair" its fragile biochemical and structural relationships, because this fragility is the inevitable price the living organisation has paid for its capability to react to subtle environmental stimuli, as well as its fluidity to adapt to changes and seek the most optimal circumstances of existence.
5 Apart from this
"maintenance-energy", a surplus of energy is channeled into a variety
of activities, such as growth and development, or the behaviour of exploration
and aggression, where all sorts of obstacles and features of the environment
are examined. Or, we may see a tendency to dominate and manipulate the circumstances
in which the organism finds itself. This surplus energy, the "elan
vital", is especially marked in the young child, but, there, the energy is
absorbed, primarily, by the rapid growth of the body and the maturation of
several organ-systems, in particular, the central nervous system. At the onset
of puberty, another major development sets in, where the organism undergoes a
series of marked anatomical and physiological changes, together with further
growth, as it matures sexually and psychologically into an adult member of the
species it belongs to.
6 The "elan vital", or
surplus energy, is quite remarkable, provided, the youngster is healthy and
well nourished, and is not frustrated in its development by severe physical or
psychological handicaps. This abundant vitality is a characteristic colouring
the behaviour of adolescents to a remarkable extent. It provides, not only, the
physical energy and strength, but, also, the enthousiasm for, and abandonment
to, a believed-in Cause. Because the experience background of the adolescent is
small, the youngster, or adolescent, is not as easily deterred by negative or
caution-inspiring impulses; it has little to lose in the way of "social
prestige", and, the abundance of energy at the beginning of what appears
to be a long life, makes the young people much less concerned with security and
the maintenance of a stable financial or social position. The latter concerns
characterise the behavioural attitudes of the mature adult, who is keenly aware
of the fact, that his period of expansion and advancement in the social
hierarchy, has come to an end.
7 The attitudes of youthful
exuberance, the willingness to take risks and to make commitments, as well as
the unconcern with long-term consequences, are characteristics of healthy and
normal adolescent behaviour, but, we should remind ourselves, that we can see
as many exceptions or apparent exceptions to this general feature, as we can
see examples of it. As is the case with all phenomena in society, the variety
of phenomena is so great, that we can always "filter" a certain
series of data from the pool of sense-impressions representing "the
society", depending on the filter we use, or the colour of the glasses we
put in front of our eyes.
8 In many social environments or
circumstances, the development of adolescence is not really "normal".
There may be a high level of frustration, especially, when we look at the urban
ghettos, which are so prevalent in many affluent free-enterprise societies. The
contrast between the living standard and opportunities of youngsters coming
from under-privileged segments of society, and the glittering consumerist lure
so blatantly advertised by the large commercial interests of society, create a
high level of anger and frustration distorting the normal development of the
human being. Yet, even within such a group of somewhat under-privileged
youngsters, we see, that, by and large, youngsters are energetic and
enthousiastic, and, they are ready to commit their energies to an ideal, if
they are given a chance to do so.
9 If there is no ideal, or, a
realistic goal they can latch onto, then, a period of confusion arises, and the
lack of direction, the surplus of youthful energies, together with the mounting
resentment and frustration, may explode into violence and rebellion. Large
societies, in particular, when they are guided by a free-enterprise, or
"laissez-faire" economic and social philosophy, are unable, and
unwilling, to cope with these developments of social injustice in a fundamental
and definitive manner. All they can do, is react to crises with a measure of
concern and anxiety, as well as a band-aid approach to social problems. As soon
as the violence has subsided, the public attention shifts to something else,
and, the same festering frustrations are allowed to build-up their energies of
anger and rebellion for the next round of explosive violence.
10 It is true, that, all
youngsters, even, those who are privileged and have a good chance of obtaining
a prominent position in society, have to learn, that the period of
"play", of unhampered activities and unbridled fantasies, is coming
to an end. A youngster has to learn to "fit-in", somewhere in his or
her social environment, and, where a youngster is going to fit-in depends, to a
large extent, upon the accidents of birth and the specifics of one's
up-bringing. If a normally endowed youngster has the good fortune to have been
born into a family with good or satisfactory relationships, and, if such a
youngster is sufficiently motivated to develop, at least, a part of his or her
potential, this youngster will learn, not only, to speak and behave
appropriately for his age, (as well as for the social stratum he or she has
been born into), but, he may, also, be fortunate enough to be stimulated into
developing a particular skill, which will then function as a pass-port to
acceptance and success for the rest of his life.
11 The most dramatic examples of
such a specialised niche in society are, e.g. the development of an artistic or
athletic skill, such as singing, playing an instrument, drawing pictures, or
the ability to skate or play a sport well. The youngster who develops such an
ability will have a certain "edge" over those who do not, because, to
excell in a particular area gives an aura of "prestige", which is a
strong factor in developing confidence and positive relations with others.
12 However, this development has to be balanced and the attitudes of confidence should not dominate unduly. If too much emphasis is placed on developing a particular talent, other necessary capabilities may remain under-developed, and the youngster will become extremely dependent upon one particular ability. Such an imbalance in the growth of an individual leads, easily, to a variety of personality deficiencies, and, it leaves the individual more vulnerable compared to a situation, where the "talent" has been blended harmoniously within an overall development of human faculties.
13 We have argued, before, that,
all normally developed, healthy children can develop one, or, even, a few
skills "above average", and, therefore, the highly important stimulus
of confidence and prestige should be available to all youngsters. True, not
everyone can sing or play an instrument, but, those, not gifted artistically,
may show a remarkable capability in athletics, handicrafts, the ability to help
others, or, some people may just do well in assimilating the subjects that have
to be learned at school. Yet, we know, that such a beneficial development for
each and every youngster is rarely accomplished in our affluent,
free-enterprise societies. In every class-room, we see youngsters who dominate,
often, merely on the grounds of having a physical advantage, and, we see a
majority of average students, plodding-on, rather indifferently, through a maze
of curricular and extra-curricular activities. If we look carefully, we see
constant shifts taking place. Fortunes shift often quickly; personalities
change, some become more confident and dominant as they finally
"bloom", while others may go through periods of doubts and
difficulties at home, of contacts with less desirable "elements" in
society, etc.
14 The patterns of dominance shift
continuously, and, if one would follow the "career" of each student
as he or she goes through the last four or five years of high school, one sees
a remarkable process of differentiation taking place. This differentiation is
partly due to physical differences. Some children grow rapidly and mature
quickly, others seem to be lagging behind; at least, for a while, and, they may
suddenly develop somewhat later. Personalities become more accentuated. Some
seem to be increasingly more "in tune" with their social environment,
as they do well in school, do their best to get good marks, feel comfortable
with their teachers and other adults in society, and, are finding,
increasingly, the particular "niche" in society in which they are
going to function.
15 Other youngsters have more
difficulties. Most often, these difficulties are not intellectual, but
psychological. Perhaps, some of these troubled youngsters come from homes where
there are strong tensions, preventing the adolescent from concentrating on his
work at school. Often, his own emotions and motivations are stimulated in such
a way, (primarily, by the contacts of the home environment and the particular
stratum of society he comes from), that he or she remains ambiguous about the
"society of adults", or, the "straight society" to which
the school and its teachers belong.
16 The awakening sexual interests
are also a severe distraction, especially, for those youngsters who are
experiencing some difficulties in their loyalties and affinities. However, all
through adolescence, youngsters are beginning to look more critically at
themselves, and, they are also beginning to look at the larger social
surroundings. What they see depends, to a large extent, on their own moods of
ambivalence and confusion. In particular, youngsters with ties to a social
segment that looks with suspicion at the society at large, will have
difficulties relating to the people of the "straight society",
especially, since their suspicions and ambivalence are often re-enforced by
ignorant and discriminatory attitudes of those who belong to this straight
society, and, who have no knowledge of, but only a fear for, the segments of
society that come close to the "under-world".
17 Not all youngsters from the
lesser privileged layers of society will fall-back into these layers, because
we see many dramatic exceptions, if an intelligent and observant youngster is
able to see, early, that the straight society has possibilities for him; that
he can, and will, overcome prejudice and discrimination, and, that the straight
society is not as hostile as his own environment has always made him believe. We
see also the opposite, where privileged youngsters from well-meaning, and,
often, well-to-do families, sink into a morass of undisciplined, egocentric and
sensual behaviour-patterns, and are unable to maintain their privileged social
status.
18 Their lack of discipline, their
chronic sense of failure, their gradual awareness of growing resentment and
estrangement from the people of their own social environment, all these factors
make them easy targets for the unscrupulous and criminal elements of the social
environment, until they become themselves unscrupulous, egocentric and
completely amoral personalities, trying to survive, as well as they can, in
their private world of dreams, emotional and sensual gratifications, drugs and
alcohol. Often, these people were "over-privileged" as youngsters,
and, they have been over-protected by anxious and somewhat indecisive parents,
who did not have the insight, nor the moral fortitude, to set a good, decisive
example and to make their children obey a set of productive, common-sense rules
of acceptable behaviour.
19 It is, indeed, remarkable to see
these differences and this large variety of potentials unfold, as youngsters go
through their period of adolescence. Some advance beyond expectation, and, they
show great promise by the time they graduate and enter university; many of them
are well on their way to become ordinary, solid and comfortable citizens, full
of the contemporary prejudices of their social class, but, also, capable of
sensible and sustained support for their friends, relatives, and those they can
communicate and feel comfortable with.
20 Then, there are always a few, in
each class, who remain "problems" to the end of their schooling days.
They are often ambivalent and frustrated. Some are highly intelligent, some are
rather dull, but, they all share a sense of confusion and non-knowing, and,
they have difficulties relating to other people. The intelligent
problem-youngsters have always a strong tendency to become, or remain, shy and
introvert, and, they become loners, but, they may learn, eventually, how to
put-on an acceptable facade. They will, then, find a niche in society,
somewhere, but their behaviour is not transparent, and, they are, therefore,
easily mistrusted by the people around them. They will never fully identify
with other people, and, their behaviour will have secret and hidden corners.
They will always be aware of the tensions that exist between them and their
social surroundings. These are the "late maturers". They may,
eventually, overcome their egocentric orientation, including their fears and
anxieties, as they learn, to their surprise, that other people have similar
problems and fears. Then, they may bloom into sensitive, artistic people, with
a great deal of insight for the problems of human existence, but, most of them
remain somewhat frightened and hidden personalities, all their lives.
21 The less intelligent
problem-youngsters remain problems all their lives, because their intellectual
abilities and skills are so minimal, that they will not be able to enter the
ranks of skilled workers. Yet, many of these youngsters are physically
remarkably strong, but not particularly agile, and, if they have the good
fortune to find proper guidance, they may be quite happy in an environment that
makes good use of their physical strength, and yet, does not abuse or exploit
their intellectual slowness and gullible attitudes. Many of these people are
not as retarded as they appear, because, often, a fault or hiatus in the
educational program, or, the lack of a proper stimulus at the appropriate time,
has made their handicap seem worse than it really is.
22 Others are, indeed, on the
borderline between normal and subnormal intelligence, and, they have been very
poorly endowed intellectually. Those with physical or mental handicaps of an
inborn nature, will always need special schooling, as well as a carefully
protected niche in society. This, in a nutshell, is what everyone can see, who
wants to look around and observe the younger generations at play, and, at the
serious business of growing-up. Let us discuss, in the next chapter, the
inter-play between genetic endowment and enviromental stimuli, which produces,
eventually, in each and every one of us, this specific mixture of capabilities,
tendencies, attitudes and beliefs, which constitutes our particular
personality.
.......
Chapter 3
Content
A remarkable parallel between the mechanisms of natural selection, and the
forces that guide the development of a personality.
Adaptations and specialisations in function.
A loss of genetic flexibility, resulting from specialised adaptations.
An infant presents itself to the world with a large variety of potentials.
Some potentials develop, others wither-away.
Normal infants have a complete range of potentials, but, at somewhat differing
levels of endowment.
Remarkable similarities and differences between youngsters.
The inter-play between the genetic blue-print and environmental factors in
physical and mental developments.
A comparison between physical and psychological mechanisms of unfolding.
Defining the essence of a "talent".
The disastrous consequences of parental "neglect".
When there is an undue stimulation of the defensive pole of the personality.
The undesirable results of "being spoiled".
Stimulating the attitudes of egocentricity and indifference.
Normal parents and ordinary circumstances provide the most natural and
healthiest balance between positive and negative stimuli.
There has to be a limit on the amount of attention given or received.
When a society has lost the ability to rely upon natural instincts and normal
circumstances.
A highly neurotic attitude that is likely to fall into both traps at once.
No wonder, affluent population groupings show, often, a dismal record in the
quality of their off-spring.
1 There is a remarkable parallel
between the mechanisms of natural selection, and the force-fields that guide
the development of a personality. The behavioural characteristics, as well as
the specific individual abilities which come to the fore as an individual finds
his way through life, are very similar to the circumstances that determine,
whether or not an individual or a small community will survive.
2 We have discussed, on a number
of occasions, how each generation of a species "presents" itself, so
to speak, as a "spectrum", or a range of possibilities and
capabilities, to the forces of natural selection. This range or spectrum of
genetic potentials is spread over the actualised or living members of a
species. If the forces of natural selection are significant, they will exert an
influence upon a segment or population of a species, which finds itself under
constant selective pressures from the environment. Then, only a fraction of the
spectrum of genetic possibilities that is represented by the living
generations, participates in the processes of pro-creation, because only the
most successful members survive into adulthood and find the possibility to
produce off-spring. This means, that, only those members with the most
advantageous combination of genetic possibilities transmit their particular
genetic endowment to the next generation, which forms, once more, a spectrum
from which natural selection "selects" a segment for further
pro-creation, etc.
3 As a result of such naturally
selective mechanisms, we visualise, that the genetic make-up of a species is
being shaped, because advantageous traits are rewarded with viability and
become more prominent in the "gene-pool", while less advantageous
traits tend to lose their foot-hold in the genetic make-up of a species,
because members with less advantageous traits do not participate, anymore, in
forming the next generation. We have also seen, that such a process of
"adaptative evolution" can lead to a very high level of specialisation.
Then, the gene-pool, (the genetic instructions that form the living generations
of a species), is highly selected, and, it forms an organism that is precisely
adapted to a specific set of circumstances. However, many traits that were
indifferent to the species during the time of this evolutionary adaptation, may
have been lost during these selective processes, and, therefore, the gene-pool
has become "narrow"; it shows only a small range of variability, and,
this means, that such a species will have lost a great deal of its adaptative
potential, if it becomes, once more, the subject of intense evolutionary
pressures as a result of changing circumstances.
4 The human infant presents itself
to the world with a large variety of capabilities and potentials. We know, how
varied man becomes later in life, and, we know, also, that most of the
characteristics or capabilities that have been developed, depend on accidental
circumstances. This means, that, most people have nearly all capabilities as a
potential in them at the time of birth, but, only a small fraction of these
capabilities are developed during their life-time, and, the other potentials
wither-away. People vary somewhat in the quality and intensity of their
genetically endowed capabilities, and, we assume, that a great deal of this
variability in talent is due to differences in endowment. However, just as our
bodies, limbs and organs vary, if we look for minute details and differences,
so is it obvious, that, psychologically, we all differ to some extent, yet, we
also know, that each normal and healthy organism, born into a species, comes
"completely equipped", each with a slightly different set of
anatomical, physiological and psychological potentials.
5 We have discussed on previous
occasions, how difficult it is to answer the question, which capabilities and
features in any one particular individual represent a genetic influence, and,
what is the result of environmental or accidental circumstances. Here again, we
may obtain a significant insight when we look at our body. The remarkable
similarity in the body-plan from one individual to the next, indicates,
clearly, that the overall organisation of the multi-cellular body has been
formed by genetically coded instructions, but, each organ, each limb, each part
of the body differs a little from one person to the next. These differences are
partly due to this limited range of variability in the spectrum of genetic
instructions, and, partly, these differences are due to environmental
influences.
6 For example, some people use
their muscles more than others, and, we differ in the environmental or
climatological factors we have been exposed to; we eat differently, and, we
have a different history of accidents and illnesses. Besides, each and every
cell in our body has been built-up from materials or substances that were
present in the environment, and, the organisational sequences, coded by our
genes, may have been altered or interrupted by an environmental agent, leading
to minor or major congenital defects, or deficiencies.
7 The point is this; the
inter-play between genetic blue-print and environmental factors is extremely
intricate, as we have discussed many times, but, essentially, the same
mechanisms of inter-play are at work, whenever we look at a human infant during
its development into a fully mature human being. The infant presents a wide
spectrum of psychological potentials as part and parcel of the same genetic
code, which organised the building-blocks of the environment into the
multi-cellular body of this infant. Physically and psychologically, the infant
is going to grow and mature, as well as age and die, in a complex series of
changes, which are, in outline, under the control of the genetic code.
8 At least, we have good reasons
to believe, that the process of growth and maturation, which was started by the
fertilisation of an egg-cell, continues until a fully grown individual has
emerged. If the environment continues to be favourable, the processes of growth
and maturation continue to unfold, but, the factors of the environment are
continually influencing the content or the constitution of the living
organisation. For example, it depends on the molecules available as food,
(which are incorporated into the body structures), whether or not the
constituents of a cell are "normal", healthy and adequate, or,
perhaps, marginal and diseased. If the environment contains insufficient
essential building-blocks, or, if dangerous poisons and toxins have become
mixed-in with these building-blocks, the health and the existence of the cell
and the organism as a whole, are seriously threatened.
9 The same mechanisms play a role
in the contents of awareness or the repertoir of experiences and sensations,
which an individual accumulates during his or her life-time. If these
experiences and stimuli are good, "just right", or conducive to an
active unfolding of various, genetically given potentials, then, such an
unfolding is going to take place, but, if the experiences and stimuli are
"traumatic" and damaging to the unfolding of normal
behaviour-patterns, then, the individual may "shut-down" the process
of unfolding and starts to experience problems in his ability, and need, to
relate to his social surroundings.
10 Even, without coming to any
judgement about the quality of a particular experience or stimulus, we have
good reasons to believe, that the content of our awareness, (of all that we
know and believe in, as well as many of our inclinations, trends or behavioural
characteristics), are the product of these chance-encounters, contacts, stimuli
and experiences, which we have undergone ever since early childhood; after our
central nervous system became capable of registering and storing the essential
outlines of such experiences and awarenesses.
11 However, just as the organisation of our cells depends on genetic instructions, so are the mechanisms that process our sensory awarenesses and conscious experiences, largely given by genetic instructions. We do not have to "learn" to be fearful, when we experience a situation or stimulus we interpret as "threatening", and, we do not have to learn to relax and be content, if we are secure and protected, warm and dry. Allready as an infant, we show these basic behavioural reactions, and, it seems justified to consider these primary reactions as "instincts", which are part of the genetic make-up we display in the existence of our body.
12 Later, we learn to
"recognise" and apply a name, or label, to a familiar object or item
of awareness. What sort of language we learn, depends, entirely, on the words
and concepts our social environment uses, but, the ability to learn to speak,
to read and write, to walk and run, to draw pictures, or sing a song, to think
and experience sensations, all these capabilities, or potentials, are given to
us by the genetic code, and some potentials are given more strongly than
others.
13 If a particular ability is quite
strongly endowed genetically, we speak of a "talent", in particular,
when such an artistic or athletic ability manifests itself at an early age.
However, the way this talent develops; whether it is developed really well, or
only haphazardly, and, even, the choice of the abilities and potentials that
are stimulated into some sort of prominence, depend, to a large extent, upon
the situation and circumstances of the social environment in which a child is
growing-up.
14 Here, we see, clearly, a
parallel with the mechanisms of natural selection. If a particular social
environment, such as the family in which the child is growing-up, recognises
and stimulates, early, a number of potentials and abilities, then, these
abilities are likely to emerge, because the child is encouraged to display and
develop these abilities and affinities. However, if the environment is
indifferent, and, if the child is "neglected", then, even, the most
common and certainly the most important potentials, are not fully developed. If
a child is neglected and lacks the normal bonds of affection and stimulation
between mother and child, the child suffers from an inadequate exposure to the
experience of being content, relaxed and secure, and, as a result, such a child
becomes tense, irritable, introvert, easily frightened, and, later, unduly
aggressive or indifferent in its contacts with other members of the social
environment.
15 If the pole of defensiveness is
unduly stimulated by neglect, isolation, or a lack of stability and security,
early in life, we may reasonably assume, that, the experience of not being
wanted, will have a lasting influence upon a personality. However, let us not
jump to the conlusion, that each and every unfortunate experience will have
such a disastrous effect on the development of a personality, but, it is undoubtedly
true, that a systematic neglect or lack of contact with a normally behaving,
affectionate parent, or set of parents and other family members, is definitely
going to have a profound effect upon the development of a personality.
16 We should also avoid the
erroneous conclusion, that, the more a child is "molly-coddled", the
happier and more brilliant its development is going to be. If a child is
"spoiled", meaning, that it does not learn at an early age about
limitations to the amount of attention and affection it can get, or, if it
fails to learn to share attention and affection with other children, then, we
see, also, a severe defect in the development of the personality. The child
becomes extremely egocentric, jealous and indifferent towards others. As
always, normal parents will provide naturally, without having to study books
about child education, a balance between these extremes. Natural instincts are
powerful enough, in all mammals, including the human being, to give adequate
protection, attention and stimuli to youngsters, but, normal parents will also
have sufficient demands upon their time and attention, (by other children as
well as other chores), to avoid the danger of giving their children an abnormal
amount of attention and protection.
17 Of course, if a social
environment has lost the ability to rely upon its natural instincts, and, if
its members are torn between the egocentric desires and pleasures of a life,
free from the care for children, and the guilt that comes, when a child is born
to them, essentially unwanted, then, we see a highly neurotic attitude, which
is likely to fall into both traps at once. On the one hand, the parents may
leave their children frequently to hired help without really scrutinising the
quality of care given to the children in their absence, and, they may lavish an
extra-ordinary degree of emotional and undisciplined affection and freedom on
their children, when they take care of their youngsters themselves. This may
induce a volatile mix of hidden resentment against a vaguely perceived neglect,
and, the spoiled, undisciplined behaviour that has been made possible by
ambivalent attitudes and parental guilt-feelings. No wonder, affluent societies
or affluent pockets of existence show, often, a dismal record in the quality of
parental care for their off-spring.
.......
Chapter 4
Content
Molding a personality through the mechanisms of "reward" and
"correction".
The need for discipline and self-discipline.
Inborn trends and environmental factors form the primary mechanisms of
influence for the unfolding personality.
A complex mosaic of influences.
The relativity of being a "stranger".
Discrepancies in judgement and perception between members from different social
strata.
Practices that sustain an exploitative upper class.
The need for a congruence in reality perceptions in order to communicate
fruitfully.
A subconscious effort to "streamline" reality perceptions.
Living with a high level of anger and resentment.
The accumulation of wealth rests, increasingly, on the gullibility and
exploitation of other people.
A baffling range of attitudes, made clear by careful analysis.
A variety of basic personality patterns.
The judgement of normality has to be made within the context of a specific
social structure.
The draw-backs of a "laissez-faire" attitude.
Living and working in an atmosphere of diseased behaviour-patterns, abnormal
relationships, and unhealthy living conditions.
A watch-dog mentality in a socially conscious environment.
It is impossible to impose the Socialist virtues by force; people have to be
ready for them.
The increasing demands of social responsibility.
A happy balance between freedom for personal differentiation, and safeguards
for a contract of essential equality.
1 In essence, a child will
respond to its environment in such a way, that behavioural traits, potentials
or abilities, which are being "rewarded" with praise, attention or
active encouragement, come to the fore, while those behavioural characteristics
that are frowned-upon, "corrected" or punished, are suppressed. We
see, therefore, clearly, that the education of a child can not take place
without, at least, some restrictions to its behavioural range. Certainly, it is
wise to recognise, that a stringent suppression of essentially normal traits is
a harmful attitude, reflecting, primarily, parental anxieties or social
prejudices, but, a philosophy that advocates total freedom for the behaviour of
a child, does a dis-service to its personality. Such a philosophy fails to see
the benefits of a moderate and carefully shaped pattern of guidance by the
mechanisms of discipline and self-discipline.
2 The "natural
selection" of environmental and social pressures upon a developing human
being shape the personality characteristics. This is done by accentuating
traits, which find favour, and, by discouraging those that cause displeasure.
True, many "traits" or behaviour-patterns come through strongly, in
spite of parental or social displeasure, and, we only have to look at the many
occasions where the behaviour of a child or adolescent goes "beyond"
the acceptable norms as "mischief", or in the form of more serious
acts of a criminal nature. However, most normal individuals will have a
sufficient sense of respect for the social guidelines and mechanisms of
authority to stay within the socially acceptable range of behaviour, and, if an
individual slides into a more permanent behaviour-pattern of criminal
activities, then, we have to look for a different explanation.
3 The crux of the matter lies in
the fact, that a child or adolescent behaves, by and large, in response to the
pressures of his social surroundings, but, we should keep in mind, that the
social realities may differ markedly from one child to the next, especially, in
the large affluent and complex, class-ridden societies of free-enterprise. We,
as a member of the "straight" society, may interpret the social
realities quite differently from an individual, who has always remained
ambivalent and confused about the values and priorities within this large,
overall, straight society.
4 Obviously, if a child grows-up in a slum, or ghetto, where the prevailing judgement towards the rest of society is one of alienation and hostility, it becomes very difficult to deal with people who are considered an "enemy". Every symbol of authority these children are being taught in school, including the teacher, is looked-upon with suspicion, because, very likely, the authority will turn-out to be hostile to the social environment the youngster comes from. When an adolescent tries to break-out of such an environment, he runs continuously into people, who remind him where a came from; who laugh at his manner of speech and behaviour, his ideas and ambitions; who are hostile and prejudiced to every "stranger" and potential competitor for the privileged positions they occupy.
5 Suspicions linger-on. Both
sides of a class-barrier display an attitude of hostile tensions. Loyalty is
extended only to those, who come from the same social class. Parents, friends
and relatives may be criminals and crooks in the eyes of the "straight
society", but they were the protectors and the providers of security,
warmth and affection for the individual, who is trying to break-out from his
social milieu, and, it is logical, that the adolescent has a difficult time
sharing, or, even, comprehending the judgements of the straight society he is
trying to join.
6 The discrepancy in judgement
and reality perception between members from different social strata is logical,
but, the fact, that members of every layer and segment of society identify,
primarily, with their own social environment, and have, necessarily, somewhat
suspicious, hostile or envious attitudes towards other groupings, is often
overlooked by those, who try to exhort people to be more tolerant towards each
other.
7 Hostility and contempt for the
lower social strata shine-through easily, and, often, without inhibitions,
crushing any attempt by a member of a lower class to penetrate into a more
privileged social milieu, but, the hostility towards the higher strata is
usually camouflaged by envy and an attitude of caution. If an individual from a
lower or middle class still has the hope and ambition to "make it
big", and penetrate this world of lavish spending and luxurious
life-styles, the attitude is one of blind admiration for the glamour of wealth
and power, and, the individual remains, often, oblivious to the many hidden,
and, sometimes, overt criminal practices and attitudes that sustain the
privileged position of power and wealth of an exploitative upper class.
8 In short, we all weave a mosaic
of positive and negative stimuli and impulses in the sphere of our reality
perceptions, including our judgements about the people around us, and, we reveal,
here, our heritage of behavioural flexibility, because the higher, flexible
animals also classify their environment into stimuli that have a promise of
advantage or a potential for harm. We all vary somewhat in the way we weave
this mosaic of conflicting judgements and evaluations, but, a specific layer or
stratum in society tends to share roughly the same pattern of sympathies and
antipathies. A congruence in such a mosaic of reality perceptions gives us a
basis for contact with those, who share our cultural characteristics, while a
marked discrepancy in judgement about the phenomena of society make it more
difficult, if not impossible, to communicate, and contacts must remain,
necessarily, somewhat superficial in order to avoid suspicions and sentiments
of hostility.
9 An animal will accept, by and
large, the perceived pattern of obstacles and possibilities "as it
exists", and, the animal organism tries to "live wih it", but,
man has a strong tendency to manipulate his immediate environment, and, he is,
therefore, inclined to try to change obstacles by force, rather than merely
going around them.
10 The cultural code of a society
represents a subconscious effort to "stream-line" the reality
perceptions of its members, and, to make it possible for each social class to
acquiesce in the position it finds itself in. Occasionally, such a code leads
to a remarkably rigid stratification in social classes, or "castes",
but, on other occasions, the awarenesses and beliefs of a current ideology propagate
the notion, that there is nothing sacred or divine about a social
stratification, and, that any class-division merely represents an opportunistic
attitude of the wealthy, who live off the labours of the poor. Such an
interpretation of reality propagates the belief, that the poor work, primarily,
to maintain the privileges and positions of power occupied by a wealthy elite.
If such views become generally accepted under the working classes, the society
becomes inevitably polarised, necessitating an ever more oppressive regime to
keep the under-privileged masses, in line. This leads, ultimately, to an armed
struggle; a popular up-rising, over-throwing and destroying this privileged,
exploitative elite.
11 However, most of us live in a
society that has not developed such a strong conviction that the social order
has been divinely ordained; nor, have the tensions and frustrations led to a
full polarisation between the social groupings, or, the beginnings of
revolutionary war-fare. Most of the under-privileged youngsters and adolescents
live with a mixture of anger and resentment towards those segments of society
which live a life of luxury and privileges, holding-on to an inherited fortune
in assets or power.
12 However, most people are too
busy finding a place in society to realise, fully, how closed these privileged
positions remain for those not born into the privileged segments of society.
Perhaps, in the more fluid free-enterprise societies, a majority of the people
still believes, that it is possible, with luck and determination, to
"become a millionaire", but, increasingly, people are beginning to
realise, that such notions are becoming completely irrealistic pipe-dreams,
and, what is even more important, we are beginning to realise, now, that the
accumulation of wealth and assets, must rest on the gullibility and
exploitation of others, and, this process can, therefore, not be considered as
the fruits of honest and hard work.
13 Many people will argue, that
there is nothing wrong with the exploitation of an opportunity, or a resource,
in order to "make money", but, the consequences of an unbridled
exploitaton of limited resources and the unabashed appeal to consumerist
instincts has disastrous results for the community as a whole. Some of the most
ardent free-enterprisers are now beginning to understand, at least, to some
extent, the limitations of the philosophy of free-enterprise, and, they are
beginning to see the undesirable side-effects of a completely free play of the
forces of supply and demand.
14 However, this is a sideline,
which we will not explore, here. We are beginning to see, that, a great variety
of behavioural attitudes and responses, as well as the sometimes baffling
attitudes of hostility and disbelief towards a society and its "authorities"
by under-privileged youngsters who are being given a chance to advance
themselves socially, are a result of profoundly differing reality perceptions.
What seems an incomprehensible waste of an opportunity given to a youngster to
break-out of a vicious cycle of poverty, discrimination and crime, may appear
to the youngster as an attempt by a hated enemy to lure him away from his
family and friends.
15 It remains extremely difficult
for those, who have found a niche of comfort and easy existence, somewhere in
this large and multi-layered fabric of the straight society, to realise, how
suspicious and hostile some of the under-privileged groupings remain to anyone,
who does not belong to their social class. Under-privileged people do not have
an awareness of an overall society. They only differentiate between
"us", a small group of people, who are loyal towards each other, and
the rest of society, consisting of many different strata of enemies.
16 Yet, in spite of the apparently
strange behaviour of adolescents and people from social strata we are not
familiar with, we may state, that, every individual tries to survive as well as
he can within this particular mosaic of social obstacles and possibilities of
existence. If we want to understand the logic of someone's behaviour, we must,
first, understand, what someone's particular reality perception includes. Then,
we have to separate the reality perceptions that depend on personal
inclinations and peculiarities, from those features, which represent the shared
reality perceptions of a particular social stratum. For example, if an
individual is very "moody" and swings rapidly between a pessimistic,
depressive reality perception and an agitated euphoric or "manic"
phase, then, we see a markedly fluctuating pattern of behaviour that is
primarily the result of personality characteristics, rather than the social
interpretation of the stratum the individual belongs to.
17 Similarly, strange, secretive
and apparently abnormal behaviour-patterns could be the result of the
assimilation of peculiar, or, even, outrageous ideas and concepts from a small,
secretive, fanatic sect or brotherhood. Then, the behaviour of a member may be
actually more "normal" than it appears to the outsider, who sees only
the discrepancy between the norm of behaviour of his own social grouping, and,
the behaviour of a member of such a secretive and anti-social sect. We are not
implying, here, that a behavioural act becomes less criminal, if it can be
"explained" by a strong social influence, but it is important to
know, how, and why, criminal or anti-social behaviour arises, before we can
design a social order that does away with a layering of social strata and makes
it impossible for exclusive, elitist, and, often, near-criminal, secretive societies
to bloom because of public neglect and indifference, as well as the fallacies
of a laissez-faire philosophy.
18 Once we know something about a
particular social environment, as well as the peculiarities or personal
characteristics of an individual living in such an environment, we can see the
inter-play between these factors more clearly. We see, then, how an individual
tries to gain acceptance or entrance to a position of privilege, esteem or
power, or, how he or she cleverly avoids the obstacles of social responsibility
and exploits the possibilities for personal gain. We see, also, how markedly
varied the prevailing social atmosphere may be.
19 In a laissez-faire, large and
complex free-enterprise society, there are few pressures or demands made upon
the individual, as long as he or she finds a way to "make a living",
and, as long as the individual is able to sustain an accustomed way of life. As
long as an individual does not "get caught" by the explicit laws of
society, there is a great deal of latitude and freedom; in the way someone
wants to live, as well as in the way someone can secure an income. We have
discussed, before, why such a laissez-faire attitude invites pockets of hidden
and, often, overt criminal activities, and, why large segments of urban
populations, eventually, live and work in a diseased atmosphere of abnormal
behaviour-patterns, abnormal relationships, and generally unhealthy living
conditions.
20 On the other hand, a society
that tries to give each individual a scrupulously equal opportunity and an
equal standard of living, has to be continuously on its guard to
"chastise" the more egocentric and secretive tendencies that live in
us all. Such a society becomes, quickly, burdened with a watch-dog mentality,
where ideologically "pure" individuals become the guardians of public
attitudes and morality, and, eventually, they become a coercive influence upon
the masses, which have to be indoctrinated, constantly, about the virtues of
brotherhood and equality.
21 It is clearly impossible to
"impose", by force, the moral virtues of an advanced Socialist
ideology, and, the system of enforced Socialist virtues deteriorates, quickly,
into the tyranny of an exclusive political Party that dictates its will to the
people, in spite of the fact, that the Party-elite tries to adhere genuinely to
the precepts of universal equality. It is obvious, that, such a society places
a far greater demand for social responsibility on the individual as he or she
is growing-up and trying to find a niche in society. These demands to conform
to the social ideals of society may, indeed, mold the individual into an
enthousiastic believer in an egalitarian social system, in particular, if the
individual is helped by such a benevolent social environment and finds a good
opportunity to develop an academic, athletic or artistic career.
22 However, a majority of people
will, probably, not find such a harmonious and wholehearted acceptance into the
ruling circles of a dominating ideological elite. While most of them acquiesce
in a role of minor importance, they remain somewhat suspicious of the
Party-elite, and, we see, therefore, essentially similar attitudes of the
masses towards any elite, regardless, whether the elite dominates on the basis
of wealth and economic power, or, on the basis of ideology and military
power.
23 We have argued, before, that it
is, indeed, important to design a social system with a code of ethics that
strikes a happy balance between a measure of freedom, or latitude, in personal
differentiaion, and, a measure of control that safeguards the social contract
of equal opportunity and social justice. However, a social environment should
not be obsessed with the manifestations of egocentric concerns. On the other
hand, the institutionalised neglect of the laissez-faire attitude, together
with the divisive divergence of social classes in a free-enterprise system, do
not really form a social system at all. They form only a mass of competing
interests and individuals, who are maintaining a semblance of coherence, as
long as frustrations can be soothed by a rapidly rising level of consumption
and affluence.
24 We are now beginning to see,
that these soothing features are falling-away, and, the free-enterprise
societies will have a difficult time to prevent their fragile social structures
from falling-apart. They will increasingly feel the need to impose dictatorial
rule by a wealthy elite, which can buy its security and power by controling the
military and the industries. However, let us go back to the adolescent
personality after this digression into social polarisation and the difficulties
of finding a viable model for the large-scale, contemporary societies.
.......
Chapter 5
Content
Opportunities for study, when there are identical twins.
Learning to differentiate inborn from acquired characteristics.
The qualities of leadership.
Learning to dominate, when necessary, and to tolerate dominance, when it is
appropriate to do so.
A long hierarchical ladder of relationships.
The sliding axes of behaviour.
Enlarging the sphere of individual and collective concerns.
The reasons for extending to each other a package of rights and obligations.
Ethical concerns have a tendency to stretch only to the limits of the social
environment we identify with.
Flashes of insight mark the beginnings of reflective thought.
Neglected children learn to survive by their own wits.
Why weak and indecisive parents keep supporting their children in affluent
societies.
The lure of excercising a measure of parental control.
Adolescence should be characterised by a gradual but consistent withdrawal of
material and psychological support.
Developing a marketable skill.
A remarkable change in social status during adolescence.
Problems with acquiring an extended sphere of reality perceptions.
Why a sharp division of the social environment into friends and enemies is not
realistic.
Short-comings in the development of a personality.
Most of us find an acceptable place in the social hierarchy.
Filtering a series of contradictory facts and observations from the pool of
social phenomena.
Looking with anxiety at our leaders, because they have the power to do a great
deal of harm.
The world of international diplomacy and military posturing seems to be
divorced from the concerns and realities of ordinary people.
The need to have "quality control" over our leaderships.
Questioning the arms-race.
The dangers of vacillating too long.
1 The child is encouraged by its
environment to develop certain skills and behavioural traits, while other types
of behaviour are frowned-upon and are, therefore, suppressed. Nevertheless,
each child differs in its particular affinities and tendencies, and, even,
siblings, growing-up under very similar circumstances, show quite different
personalities. We have discussed, before, that we should not jump to the
conclusion, that these differences are, therefore, due to genetic variations.
However, when we look at the development of identical twins, where we know,
that they have an identical genetic blue-print, we see, indeed, a remarkable
similarity, in physical as well as psychological make-up.
2 It is fair to say, therefore,
that in each trait or skill, we see a combination of the genetic foundation or
"anlage" for this skill, as well as a series of environmental stimuli
and contacts, which determine to what extent this anlage is being developed,
and, how it fits-in with other skills and traits. We have discussed the fact,
that children may vary markedly in their attitudes towards other people, ranging
from the shy and introvert personality that looks upon others with a mixture of
suspicion and uncertainty, to those, who feel comfortable in the presence of
others. This last category will, invariably, discover, that it can
"manipulate" others, and, these people will use their ability to be
popular or attractive as a means to find security and a position of privilege.
3 Sometimes, the ability to win
approval, praise, or, even, admiration, is limited to the development of a
particular skill, be it artistic, athletic or intellectual, but, in others, the
ability to manipulate and dominate is a function of the entire personality.
Here, we see, then, to some extent, the quality of political leadership emerge,
when youngsters develop the ability to dominate and lead. Of course, many
"fall by the way-side", as they fall into the temptation of
manipulating people, primarily, for their own egocentric objectives. Quickly,
such an egocentric attitude will be rejected, and the "leader" has
then lost his appeal. Often, truly concerned leadership may only come to the
fore, later in life, when a personality has become "more mature", and
an individual finds himself, rather unexpectedly, in a position, where others
look towards him or her for advice, help or leadership.
4 Most people find a workable or
useful balance between the extremes of an exclusive attitude of suspicion and
hostility towards others, and, the shameless manipulation of people for
personal gain. Fortunately, most people learn, somehow, in the natural wisdom
of normal family and social relationships, that the world is neither so harsh,
that, every move has to be fought for, nor is it so tolerant and admiring,
that, every wish and whim will be granted. Somehow, we all learn, that there is
a middle way; that there are people we can trust, or, even, dominate, but, we
also learn, that there are people we can not dominate and who may dominate us.
5 We find ourselves, somewhere,
in a long hierarchical ladder of relationships, and, these contrasting factors
of cooperation, dominance and submission work together in order to unfold this
genetically given, instinctive ability to form satisfying social relationships
on a small scale. This means, that we can all slide along the axis of socially
acceptable behaviour. This axis functions in addition to the sliding scale
between aggressiveness and defensiveness, which we have already discussed. We
have seen, how each organism, including human beings, can slide along the axis
from a negative, defensive attitude towards a positive, aggressive or ebullient
attitude. We can also slide from an attitude of fierce egocentricity, (where we
think or concern ourselves, exclusively, about our own well-being), towards an
attitude of concern for others.
6 Certainly, we enlarge the sphere
of concern only very gradually, and, we can only feel true concern and sympathy
for a few people we truly care about. In addition, we can adopt a more
intellectual and ethical attitude, where we know, that we should give a larger
number of people, even, those we do not know personally, the opportunity to
live a decent life and develop some of their potentials, because we recognise,
not only, an inherent justice in an attitude that promotes the sharing of
privileges, but, we also know, from experience, that social tensions, such as
the emotions of suspicion, jealousy and envy, can only be softened, if we learn
to give each other a package of equal rights and obligations
7 However, let us not forget, that
our ethical concerns only stretch to the limits of the social environment we
identify with. If we identify only with a small segment of the society at
large, and, if we see the remainder of the society as "enemies", we
can not expect to behave ethically, nor, can we expect to be concerned about
the well-being of all those "strangers". We, as members of a straight
society, often forget, that, those in under-privileged strata, see us
essentially as enemies, and, we are thoroughly shocked by their hostile and
un-ethical attitudes towards us. Yet, we do not find it strange at all, that we
"hate" our enemies, and, that we have no inclination to extend our
ethical concerns and principles of justice to those, whom we consider to be our
enemies.
8 The basic drive in each one of
us, whether we are children, adolescents or adults, is "to survive".
We all find ourselves in a particular position within our social environment.
As a very young child, we have, of course, no awareness of our own existence,
but, as soon as we are three or four years old, we experience "flashes of
insight", where we suddenly see ourselves as a person; as an individual,
existing somewhere, dependent upon protection and nourishment, from our family
or the small group we belong to, and, we feel ourselves to be surrounded by a
large world of strange and unknown people.
9 This large world of people
around us presents a mixture of threats and promises, of fear and excitement,
of obstacles and opportunities. We remain aware of our dependence upon our
family, and, in particular, our parents, and, we experience the fact, that the
main source of parental authority comes from the ability to control this sphere
of dependence. We can be punished, send to bed without food, or, we can be made
to do one thing or another, if we do not behave according to parental
instructions, because we have, in essence, nowhere to go. This is the reason,
why children, who have no strict or formal home, learn, quickly, how to survive
by their own wits, and, they develop, not only, a wisdom and an agility in
obtaining what they need, but, they also escape from "adult control"
because they do not need, anymore, this sphere of protection. However, in most
instances, children survive on their own, because they have become orphaned,
or, the family relationships have become extremely fragile, or, the social
situation is highly abnormal, e.g., in the refugee-camps of war-torn areas.
10 We see, here, the main reason,
why, in affluent societies, weak and indecisive parents keep supporting, at
least, partially, their adolescent children, who often remain somewhat lazy,
dull and vague in their goals, just because their parents keep providing them
with an easy source of shelter, food and money. The reason, why parents are
inclined to do this, (in spite of the fact, that these adolescents, often,
behave quite impudently towards them), lies in the remnant of parental control,
which these parents are, intuitively, reluctant to give up. Just because they
still provide a home, shelter and some pocket-money, the parents retain some
control over their off-spring, because the other lines of authority, such as
respect for parental advice and opinion, have long since evaporated in an
atmosphere of disputes and mutual accusations.
11 Adolescence should be
characterised by a gradual, but steady withdrawal of material, as well as
psychological support, because it is important, that these youngsters start to
learn to make their own decisions. If they know, that, soon, they will have to
make a living with their own skills and efforts, they will take more seriously
the task of finding a place in the society at large, as well as the efforts
needed to obtain a marketable skill. If parents cling to their vestiges of
power and influence by continuing to support their immature adolescents, they
will create somewhat weak, vacillating and childish personalities; who miss the
most opportune moments in school to provide themselves with a skill. This
skill, as well as the unfolding of an all-round personality will give them
access to a class of professionals and skilled workers.
12 Therefore, adolescence is
characterised, not only, by the physical and psychological changes that are
associatd with the onset of puberty and the maturation processes of the body
and the mind, but, adolescence is also characterised by remarkable social
changes, where the world is expanded greatly; from the immediate and
comfortable social surroundings of the small group, the youngster is required
to expand rapidly his or her sphere of knowledge and contacts. While trying to
form a new and greatly expanded sphere of reality perceptions, every individual
is still guided by this mosaic of interpretations which colours his or her
particular reality experiences.
13 Now, we understand the reasons,
why a variety of approaches are used in coping with the problems of an extended
sphere of reality. Not only, are obstacles or negative impressions a cause for
fear and withdrawal, but, they may be changed into a challenge or an
opportunity by a deliberate attempt to alter the perception of their
existential value. As confidence grows, and, as the sphere of reality
perceptions becomes much larger, intelligent youngsters see, ever more clearly,
that they are not so different from the others after all, and, that, even,
youngsters, coming from a totally different cultural or social background,
share many similar hopes and fears, desires and doubts, ambitions and
responsibilties.
14 The divergence between
youngsters going through the final years of high-school, is, perhaps, best
characterised by emphasising this critical enlargement of the awareness-sphere,
as well as the unfolding of the attitudes of comprehension. Those who become
more confident and can relate, better, to a variety of people, are gaining a
foot-hold in society, and, with their growing confidence, they will also
develop more easily their talents. They will exploit, more thoroughly, the
opportunities that arise. These youngsters learn, that the strong divisions in
friends and enemies is not realistic, and, that it is possible to overcome
suspicions and hostilities with a friendly attitude and an open approach. Yet,
even so, disappointments occur, and, even, the most intelligent people learn,
that they can be deceived and manipulated by clever entrepreneurs and
ruthlessly egocentric personalities, who have also learned the secret of
unlocking an attitude of confidence with a facade of trust and friendliness.
15 Those youngsters, who remain
locked into their world of hostilities towards the larger society, as well as
the restrictive loyalties towards their own social grouping, and, those, who
remain dreamers, absorbed by sensual gratifications and an undisciplined
behaviour-pattern, have a much greater chance to be left behind. They keep having
diffculties relating to other people, and, their confidence remains bruised by
repeated failures. They never develop fully the intellectual capabilities they
have, just because these capabilities may be somewhat more difficult to develop
compared to those, who learn and grasp easily. Their reality perceptions remain
more confused, and, they never learn to articulate their thoughts and feelings
appropriately.
16 This inability to communicate
with confidence, and, without a sensation of fear, makes it more difficult for
them to approach others, or, to be approached. Frustrations and resentment
remain in the fore-front, as chronic tensions are sustained by repeated
failures and unresolved short-comings, and, eventually, their reality
perceptions develop an aura of chronic suspicion and prejudice for this larger
and strange social environment. Here again, let us acknowledge, that, most of
us grow-up somewhere in between these extremes; neither do we find a completely
happy acceptance by the social environment we belong to, but, neither are we
completely frustrated in our attempts to find an acceptable niche, and,
therefore, the levels of resentment, frustration and suspicion remain
manageable.
17 Most of us find an acceptable
place, somewhere, on the scale of this complex hierarchical ladder of the
larger, conglomerate societies. Very few will reach a pinnacle of power or
independence, where we have no superiors above us, and command a vast territory
and a large number of people, but, neither are we completely at the bottom,
trampled upon by everyone around us, completely without power and prestige,
only an object of scorn.
18 The ambivalent moods or feelings
in relation to our social performance and the reality perceptions we have
built-up, explain, why it seems so extremely difficult to agree amongst
ourselves upon a definition of society. The validity of social observations and
phenomena, or, the validity of seeing a particular personality in a specific
light, can always be questioned, because we have so few criteria to decide,
whether or not a particular evaluation has merit. The area of awarenesses and
sensations is so vast, and so contradictory, that we can always filter a series
of contradictory facts and observations from this overall pool of social
phenomena, depending on the type of observation we are looking for, or, the
colour of the mood we happen to be in, when trying to evaluate a number of
social experiences and awarenesses.
19 If each one of us lives, at
least, to some extent, in a world of our own making, (depending upon the
reality perceptions we happen to have adopted), then, we should look, once
more, with a great deal of anxiety at our leaders, who claim to act and decide
in the name of the "common good of society". If you and I live in a
particular world of our own making, why would our leaders, then, not be
caught-up in their own particular world of beliefs and opinions? Yet, they have
a great deal of power and access to all sorts of weapons. Their particular
perceptions and beliefs may influence us a great deal, because they control, by
and large, the news-media, and, it may be, that, some day, their particular
reality perception will show them a threat that calls for a nuclear strike, or
some other disastrous military adventure. Once again, millions of people will
die and suffer, because our leaders and military strategists have been
misguided in their beliefs, and have made an error of judgement.
20 The world of international
diplomacy and military posturing seems to be so much a world on its own,
divorced from the concerns of common people. The world of diplomatic and
military posturing seems to be acted-out by the leaders and influential
establishments of powerful countries. It looms as a grave danger that hangs
over the entire world, and, this chronic threat of a "run-away"
reality perception, makes it necessary, that, we, ordinary people, have to
concern ourselves, intensely, with the question of "quality control"
over our leaderships.
21 Is it really necessary for those
privileged and powerful people, who have made it, somehow, to the top, (by
lucky accident, by the power of the gun, or, sometimes, by popular support), to
sooth their fears about the powers and intentions of other leaders, (who are,
after all, their colleagues in different countries), by a frantic manufacture
of more and more arms? Our leaders seem to exist far too much in a world of
fears, and, they are obsessed by the attributes of power and influence. Such a
world is a result of their own reality perceptions, but, as long as they have
access to power, their fears and obsessions remain a grave threat to us all.
We, ordinary people, do not have easy solutions, nor do we have easy means of
preventing our leaders from unleashing another war, because, after all, if we
had such compelling and persuasive reasons and arguments to make them dismantle
all this weaponry, we would have made our voices heard a long time ago.
22 Many of us are vacillating, and,
we do not know, whether or not we should have those arms, but, while we can not
decide to take a stand, the threat of a continuing arms-race and the potential
for a nuclear war, are becoming ever more likely, and, they constitute a gloomy
reality of mass-destruction and a suicidal conflict for all of us. We may make
ourselves extinct by the failure to make a clear move towards safety, just as
we may be killed by a rageing forest-fire, if we vacillate too long in our
deliberations about the best route for a dash to safety.
.......
Chapter 6
Content
The evolution of the adolescent personality.
The world of motivations.
The many aspects of manipulative skills.
Being subjected to a large series of chance-happenings.
Becoming a source of influence and guidance for young people.
All communications have a subtle emotional under-current.
The disadvantages of popularising too much.
Commercialism; a communication that is not concerned with "a truth",
but with satisfying a need.
Preserving a measure of idealism amongst teachers and young people.
When the cultural code becomes a confusing jungle of contradictory trends and
guidelines.
Passing the banner of cultural leadership to more deserving social
environments.
The universal lure of affluent luxury and the freedom to indulge.
Effective teaching is not easy in a confused and vacillating society.
Diagnosing the many tensions and frustrations within a social environment.
Education should be centered around the ability to observe honestly and
articulate clearly.
Minimising apparent differences in aptitude.
Resisting the temptation to let the more talented pupils dominate the
class-room.
1 Let us return to the evolution
of the adolescent personality in the last few years of a high school
environment, and, we should look at the way human motivations and abilities
develop. We have seen, that, all human beings share the essential drives
relating to their existential needs, such as the drives for security, shelter,
food and sex. These drives may activate all three existential poles of our
behaviour at one time or another, but, as we have outlined before, motivations
are much more varied than instinctive drives, because a motivation is a
verbalised goal that has been derived from the basic instinctive drives.
Certainly, a number of instinctive drives may combine and form a labyrinth of
motivations, but we also know, that a professed or articulated motivation can
often be referred to a more basic, or "deeper" drive, which is the
"real reason" for someone's behaviour.
2 Let us review, briefly, the
world of motivations, in particular, as it plays a role in young adults and
adolescents. We resemble each other very much in the instinctive poles of our
behaviour, but, the way these instincts are activated and manifest themselves,
is remarkably varied. The layer of motivations is far more complex than the
basic instinctive drives, because, what we, consciously or subconsciously,
select as a worthwhile goal, depends, to a large extent, on the accidents of
our personal history.
3 It depends on the traits and
skills that have been selected or activated as a result of various
chance-contacts and genetic propensities, and, it depends on the opportunities
we perceive, at the present time, in the sphere of our reality perceptions. A
mood or motivation may also depend, to quite a large extent, on the way we are
being manipulated by others. This form of manipulation may not have an
exclusively egocentric motivation, because our parents, guardians or educators
may be genuinely inspired by an ideal or ethical attitude, which they hope to
transfer to us as a lasting motivation or guiding principle.
4 This bring us to the
observation, that, indeed, we are, as a rule, subjected, not only, to a large
series of chance-happenings and events during the period of formal education,
but, we are constantly subjected to a variety of influences, as people try to
convince us to believe this or that; to adopt such and such an attitude; to
guide our efforts and talents in one way or another.
5 We always have to choose, and,
rarely, do we feel, that the people in our environment who are exerting such an
"educative" pressure upon us, are entirely familiar with our
inclinations, or, understand completely our doubts and hesitations. However,
let us acknowledge, that we do not always understand fully, the wisdom or
motivations of the people who are trying to influence us. Of course, we will,
eventually, do the same. As an adult, we will have developed a well-articulated
belief or opinion about the way society should behave or operate, or, what we
should or should not do in a particular situation, or, what is good and bad;
what is worthwhile accomplishing, and, what is a waste of time and effort.
6 As soon as we have developed
these characteristics of maturity, (sometimes quite early, but, then, often on
a fairly narrow basis of traditional acceptance), we, too, become a source of
influence and guidance for young people, who are under-going the problems and
excitements of facing a large variety of opportunities and possibilities, which
is, after all, the hall-mark of adolescence.
7 Certainly, there is nothing
wrong with trying to influence the attitudes and behaviour of other people,
but, it depends, entirely, on our motivations and skills of comprehension and
insight, whether or not such stimulating influences have a beneficial effect.
We are all familiar with examples, where well-meaning people have completely
failed in their efforts to persuade someone else, or a group of people, because
there was an insufficient measure of real communication and intuitive understanding
about the motivations and emotions playing a role. How often is a proponent of
a perfectly logical and lucid argument not baffled to find only resistance and
disbelief, because he or she fails to appreciate the atmosphere of suspicion
and hostility surrounding any uni-lateral attempt to impose a specific point of
view?
8 All our communications and
encounters have a subtle aura of emotionality, even, if we try to be objective and
calm in the evaluation of our experiences. We can not help, but look upon every
new situation, new idea, or new teacher, with a measure of suspicion and
mistrust, and, this aura of mistrust is only dispelled with great difficulties.
9 It is important, that, we, as
teachers in charge of educating the younger generation, are aware of these
fundamental emotional and motivational mechanisms, and, it is not wise to deny
the existence of these mechanisms, nor, is it wise to use a variety of
"tricks" to compensate for a situation that is often difficult and
discouraging. For example, one temptation is to bring a subject in very
"popular terms", but, such a method of over-simplifying the
subject-material and creating an exaggerated bias in interpretation and presentation
towards the cultural milieu of the students, are unfortunate and short-sighted
short-cuts towards an easy and quick acceptance by a suspicious and hostile
audience.
10 The audience of students and
adolescents is essentially the loser of such a method, because young people
never realise, until much later, that such a simplification and deliberate
distortion only impoverishes the possibilities for understanding and learning.
In a way, this is an example of "commercialism", because a commercial
interest is not concerned with the communication of "a truth". A
commercial interest wants to give the audience what it wants, in order to make
a profit, and, a commercial interest does not care about the quality of a
product, nor about its effects upon people, as long as people like the product
and are willing to pay for it.
11 However, most teachers and
people concerned with the guidance and education of young people are not that
cynically inclined. There still is, at least, a measure of idealism amongst the
members of the teaching profession, because they carry, after all, the main
responsibility for the transfer of the cultural code upon which so much of the
viability of society rests. However, what happens, if this cultural code has
become a confusing jungle of contradictory trends? What happens, if teachers
have become themselves confused products of a defectively transmitted cultural
code? Then, there is no focus for idealism anymore. Then, the good-willing
instincts of confused people only manage to create an even greater confusion.
Then, it is not surprising, that the accent shifts towards a purely egocentric
attitude, amongst teachers and pupils alike. "I go to school to make a
living, or, I go to school to learn something to make money with". This becomes,
then, the over-riding, and, perhaps, the only sensible motivation, because, how
can one believe in the motivation of learning to become a good citizen, an
informed standard-bearer of the cultural code of our times, if we do not know,
anymore, what it means to be a good citizen, or, which cultural traits and
characteristics are valuable and should be transmitted to the next generation?
12 You may want to point-out to me, that I am concentrating too much on the confused and chaotic cultural picture of the large and affluent free-enterprise societies, and, you may want to tell me, that, many smaller and ideologically more coherent social environments are not plagued by these problems to the same extent. Somewhat smugly, you may want to point-out, that you have decided, a long time ago, that "the West" was corrupt and decadent, beyond repair, and, that it is inevitable, that, sooner or later, the more vigorous, "younger" nations with a more coherent and socially advanced ideology, will take over the role of leadership in the world. Yes, you may be right, and, it would not be more than historical justice, if the banner of cultural leadership and social justice would pass to more deserving societies.
13 However, I hope, for your sake,
that the infectious contamination of affluent laziness and consumerist
expectations will not nibble on this core of moral strength and social resolve,
before the younger and more vigorous societies have had a chance to prove their
worth as cultural leaders.
14 One of the most striking
features of modern times, seems to be the amazing persuasiveness of a
consumerist life-style of affluent luxury, together with the freedom to
indulge. In spite of the many difficulties which the older, affluent societies
are going through, the lure of egocentric power and wealth seems to be one of
the most powerful stimuli for peoples all over the world.
15 Sure, there is really nothing
surprising about it. Only recently, have the peoples of the world seen, be it
from a distance, what affluent living is like, and, you can not blame them for
wanting a piece of the action, regardless of the problems, the inequities, the
pollution and the impoverishments that come with the dubious blessings of
affluent entrapment and apparent freedoms. I am not so sure, at the present
time, that, those societies, which seem to be poised for a take-over of the
affluent West, will be able to do so, before their own strength has been sapped
by the same basic temptations of indulgence and affluence. Ironically, the most
sobering reactions against the excesses of consumerist affluence come from
those, who have experienced, closely, the excesses of a sumptuous life-style
and the emptiness of chronic affluence.
16 No, teaching is not easy in a
confused and vacillating social environment, and, the task of teaching is
relatively easy, but, perhaps, also somewhat dull, if the society is still
firmly in the grip of an absolute Faith, or, an infallible Social Doctrine.
Only in a balanced society, with a deliberately created balance between
individual freedoms and social guidelines, (between individual rights and
privileges on the one hand and social obligations and contributions on the
other), only there, can we see an exciting, varied, intellectually stimulating
debate emerge about the direction society should take, together with the
problems that need to be tackled.
17 However, before we try our hand at the problems of society, we have to learn to diagnose the problems and short-comings, and, we can only understand the reasons for these problems, conflicts, tensions and frustrations in society, if we learn to diagnose these same tensions and conflicts within ourselves and between ourselves. Perhaps, education should, indeed, be centered around the ability to observe honestly, and articulate clearly, our own motivations and desires, but, we all know how difficult this is, and, how easy such an excercise is dominated by a few individuals, who feel comfortable at this game and like to display their dexterity, while the rest listens and watches in a painful silence, dreading the moment they may be called-upon to articulate some of their thoughts and feelings.
18 As is so often the case, this
apparently so large and unbridgeable gap between students is more apparent than
real. We do not really differ that much in our abilities to express ourselves,
but, some have had the good fortune, that such an ability has been encouraged
from an early age, and, they have come to rely upon this ability, and, they
feel confident using it. Others have had the experience that no-one wanted to
listen to them, whenever they tried to communicate some of their thoughts and
feelings; or, worse, they have been laughed at, brushed-off, or told to
"shut-up". As a result, this ability is then suppressed, since the
activity of communicating, at least, in a more or less public manner, is
associated with feelings of embarrassment and inadequacy.
19 This is the reason, why some
seem to flourish, perhaps, even, wallow, in a dubious effort to become, or
remain, a center of attention, while others can not do anything more than
mumble a few incoherent words, as they are severely inhibited and shy about the
whole situation.
20 These people like to be left
alone, or, they like to engage in activities they feel more comfortable with,
and, they like to do something, they know, they can do well. However, if the
capability to think and speak clearly would be excercised, systematically, from
an early age, and, if teachers would resist the temptation to let those pupils who
are good at it, dominate these sessions, then, it should be possible for
everyone in the class to learn, at least, a basic skill in communicating and
thinking, just as every pupil has to acquire a working knowledge of reading,
writing and arithmetic, before he or she can be promoted to the next grade.
.......
Chapter 7
Content
Eliminating the elements of unfamiliarity and mis-understanding.
Conflicts, due to minor irritants and a lack of privacy.
We want and need contacts.
We are so remarkably similar in our needs and aspirations.
Appreciating the wide variety and range of awarenesses, thoughts and feelings.
A great respect for individual human life.
Sharing the same "body-plan", including the outlines of our
personality.
Excercises in thought and communication.
Understanding and insight will not prevent every situation of conflict.
Why should we give-up a position of privilege, when we can fight-off a
challenge with relative ease?
Why we need an explicit social contract of essential equality.
Analysing, how, and why, inequalities develop and persist.
A central role for the attitude of trust.
A review of the attitude of trust.
The meaning of "a smile".
A review of early childhood developments.
Egocentric attitudes can be manifested defensively or aggressively.
Normal youngsters experience, from an early age, that they are not the only
focus of adult attention.
The need for a "physical correction" on the rear-end.
A child has to learn, how to deal with competitive pressures.
Damage to the development of a growing personality by ambivalent or
over-protective attitudes.
1 Let us not come to the somewhat
facile and irrealistic conclusion, that a vastly enlarged ability to
communicate with each other, and, hopefully, understand each other's position,
ambitions, fears and hopes, will, automatically, lead to the development of
friendship and brotherly love. Many conflicts still occur and erupt into
bloodshed, in spite of the fact, that the participants are perfectly well aware
of each other's motivations and intentions. Then, the elements of unfamiliarity
and mis-understanding do not play a signficant role. There are often
circumstances in which we decide, deliberately, to attack a competitor, we
know, quite well. Knowing something or someone quite well, does not necessarily
mean to love and appreciate. Indeed, the most violent quarrels between human
beings occur, when people, who know each other well, have to live at close
quarters and are constantly irritated by each other's peculiarities.
2 True, such conflicts burst-out
as an emotional explosion, whenever a limit has been reached in the tolerance
for each other's annoying habits, and, rarely, is the violence based on a
coolly calculated opportunity to gain an advantage, or to eliminate a competitor.
This points-out, of course, the very important factor of adequate housing and
living conditions, so that people, in particular, the adolescent generation,
has a shelter of privacy, a place to study, read or think, or, a place to
get-away from other people for a while. We need privacy, in order to digest the
many sensations, emotions and impressions that follow each other so rapidly in
a vast and changing world of growing-up and adolescent relationships. However,
we also need and want contact with each other, but, we need to learn to talk to
each other honestly and sensibly, and, we need the guidance of a teacher, who
really understands the overall objectives of such an excercise.
3 The primary objective is to
learn to see our own emotions, fears, hopes, aspirations and dreams, and, we
need to learn, that other people have similar fears, hopes, dreams and
aspirations. We only learn this by exchanging information about ourselves; what
we would like to become, do, learn or be involved with; by telling each other,
what we hope for, or fear the most, what we are puzzled by, and, what sort of
judgements we have already formed, or, have taken-over from our parents and the
environment we come from, without giving them much thought. We learn, then, not
only, a good deal about our own personality, but, we also learn, to our
surprise, that others have a remarkably similar personality-structure. We
learn, that other people have similar fears, hopes, aspirations and overall
objectives, in spite of the many differences in ability or perception we can
see to exist between us.
4 In short; what we should learn from these excercises in communication, is the fact, that we are much more alike than we thought, and, that, many, if not most of our fears and private thoughts, trends and inclinations, turn-out to be quite common motivations or instinctive drives. At the same time, we will begin to appreciate the enormously varied spectrum of human awarenesses, and, we may get a feeling for the large variety and diversity of reality perceptions that occur between the members of a social environment.
5 Perhaps, this is, indeed, one
of the most important fruits of the development of the capability to
communicate meaningfully; nl., that we learn to appreciate the remarkable psychological
similarities that exist between people, just as we will always marvel at the
remarkably similar construction of our physical existence. At the same time, we
also learn to see the enormous variety of awarenesses and sense-impressions,
thoughts and feelings, each individual is capable of.
6 We should learn, therefore, to
have a great deal of respect for each individual existence, because we all
share this remarkable ability to be consciously aware, and to behave with care
and concern for other people. At the same time, we may learn to appreciate the
fact, that each one of us is unique in the content of his or her experiences,
feelings, thoughts and beliefs. We are all unique, but, in essence, we are all
similar, because we share the same "body-plan". We share the same
structures of the central nervous system which make our conscious awarenesses
possible, and, we share the same instinctive drives and existential needs. We
are so similar in wants and needs, and, yet, in all the aspects and features which
I believe to be true and which form my particular sphere of reality perception,
I see that no-one is exactly identical to me, and, no other person perceives
reality in exactly the same way I do.
7 These excercises in thought and
communication should teach us a great deal of understanding about ourselves. It
will make us aware about this great experiment by nature with the possibilities
of the living organisation, as well as the remarkable capabilities that result
from nature's experiment with behavioural flexibility. We become especially
aware of the ability to represent numerous awarenesses and abstractions, common
denominators and classifying principles with the help of a symbol, a gesture, a
sound or a written sign. These experiences should teach us, together with this
entire fabric of knowledge, information and experiences that forms the
curriculum of a broadly based education, how we function, what we need, what
the reasons are for our feelings, fears, goals and dreams; where we resemble
each other, and, why we can also consider each human being a unique entity.
8 Certainly, all these
capabilities and insights still do not prevent us from clashing with each
other, from time to time, but, I believe, that the behaviour of man, in particular,
in small transparent groupings, is perfectly capable to accept the compromise
of a scrupulously adhered-to principle of equal opportunity and equal standards
of living, especially, when such a choice is appreciated as an alternative to
the effort of combat and the risk of losing everything.
9 Perhaps, the most difficult
situation for sharing with those around us, and behaving rationally and
reasonably, occurs, when we find ourselves in a position of power and
privilege. If we know, that we can fight-off a challenge with relative ease,
why should we give-up our position of privilege? Why should we do so, if we do
not trust those around us? If we have become so dependent upon this position of
power and privilege, that we do not know how to function without it, why, then,
should we give it up voluntarily?
10 Indeed, the temptation, as well
as the genuine need to cling to a position of privilege and power, will be a
major topic for discussion and debate, because we see, here, on the one hand,
the most primitive traits of our biologically inherited trends and
behaviour-patterns come to the fore, and, on the other hand, we have, here, the
crucial problem and temptation that is present in us all. This dilemma requires
careful understanding, before it can be solved by an intellectually explicit
and finely detailed contract of social relationships.
11 We have discussed, before, how
the larger society evolved from a much smaller unit of social integration, and,
what sort of cultural development had to take place, before a viable cultural
code could supplement an increasingly inadequate genetic code. The
supplementary cultural code was necessary, before the larger societies could
find a measure of viability. Perhaps, it is one of the most important educational
tasks of the future, to show the younger generations the need for such a social
contract of essential equality, spelled-out in a set of explicit rules and
regulations. We have to show people, that we need an explicit social contract
of essential equality in order to establish and maintain the conditions of
equality in standards of living, justice in privileges, and rights under the
law, as well as essential equality in the burdens, responsibilities and
contributions exacted from the members of a large and complex society.
12 At the same time, it will be a
difficult but necessary task to analyse, how, and why, inequalities develop and
persist, and, how pockets of exploitation, injustice and a dependence upon
privileged positions can be dismantled without bloodshed, and, without causing
its own particular brand of injustice and resentment.
13 Central in these discussions and
excercises in communication, and, a main-stay in our educational efforts to
encourage desirable character traits, will be the attitude of trust. We have
traced, before, the development of trust, and, we have seen, how the infant is
so completely dependent upon its social environment for survival, primarily the
mother, that there is a "blind trust". Of course, the infant is not
consciously aware of being trustful. It will cry, when something is wrong, but,
it can not even indicate a difference between being hungry or being wet. As
soon as its needs have been fulfilled, it will relax and fall contently asleep.
After a few weeks, it starts to "look around" and smile occasionally.
14 The smile is a reflex
contraction of some of the facial muscles, and, it is part of a pattern of
grimacing that is already visible in the pre-human, anthropoid species'. It is
difficult to relate the smile of an infant to any particular emotional
expression, because the infant is still such a "blank"; a
reflex-organism, without any specific awarenesses or relationships. However, it
would be erroneous to come to the conclusion, that the infant is not aware at
all, because it certainly will react to an unpleasant stimulus, such as a
sudden loud noise, a sudden drop of its body, etc. These reactions are a reflex
response. These reactions represent stereotyped, inborn responses that are
nearly identical for every stimulus "startling" the infant, and, such
a repsonse is, therefore, aptly called a "startle response".
15 The smile is a different sort of
reflex, however, because it is not a reaction to being startled; on the
contrary, it is, probably, a manifestation of comfort and relaxation, and, it
seems to be triggered by the vague awareness or recognition, that a particular
stimulus is "promising" or comforting, or, that it is indicative of a
beneficial event in the immediate future, such as being fed or given a clean
diaper.
16 The smile may, eventually,
become a more specific response of recognition, when the infant recognises a
familiar face or voice, or, a familiar situation or happening. The main point
we want to emphasise, here, is the fact, that, each and every human being only
survives, if it is surrounded during infancy and early childhood by an
environment of shelter, nourishment and care, and, every one of us, regardless,
how suspicious, misanthropic or defensive our behaviour may have become at a later
age, we all started by trusting, blindly, the surroundings and the social
environment we were born into.
17 The awareness of the importance
of this unbroken sphere of shelter and atmosphere of trustful reliance, has
led, naturally, to the concept, that severe defects of the personality, which
may show-up during childhood and adolescence, are due to deficiencies in the
quality or the constancy of this umbrella of shelter and care. Indeed, a child
that is "dumped" from one set of circumstances to the next, and, who
experiences a confusing variety of conditions upon which it has to rely for its
security and nourishment, may become highly tense, irritable, defensive and
introvert, but, others, who go through essentially a similar set of
circumstances, may develop an early knack of making use of the variety of
circumstances that are offered.
18 I mean this; some children
grow-up quickly, and they learn how to exploit the situation of having a number
of different people as their guardians or providers, and, they learn to
manipulate, for their own benefit, of course, the fluctuating and often
inconsistent conditions of their childhood environment. Other children become
confused, withdrawn, defensive and full of mistrust under similar conditions.
These behavioural reactions appear to be a complete opposite of each other,
brought-out by essentially similar conditions. Are these different adaptations
due to subtle differences in the genetic endowment, or, do we have to look for
slight differences in evaluations and initial choices of reaction-patterns to
explain these different modes of adaptation to difficult and confusing
circumstances?
19 A marked accentuation of a shy,
introvert, defensiveness, as well as a marked, early development of the ability
to manipulate other people, show, both, a strong egocentric component. However,
this egocentric trait is manifested, either, defensively, or, in a more
aggressive, manipulative mode of behaviour. In short, a defective,
inconsistent, fluctuating and psychologically inept behaviour-pattern of the
adults towards the young child, has a tendency to activate egocentric traits
and tends to suppress the attitudes of a trustful reliance, which is so much
the hall-mark of the well-protected child.
20 However, the normally developing
child in a normal family experiences, not only, the interested, intelligent,
encouraging and protective attitudes of concerned parents and guardians, but,
it will also experience the competitive drive and instincts of other children,
siblings, friends and play-mates, who are competing with each other for the
attention and the privileges of the adults, or, for the possession of toys, or,
for a chance to play a leading role.
21 Normal youngsters experience, therefore, from an early age, that they are not the only focus of attention. They experience that there is a limit to what they can get, and, that there is a limit to the behaviour that is tolerated by the social environment. The normal child realises, at least, intuitively, that other children may be more powerful and may dominate the situation, at least, from time to time, and, a normally developing child learns, that he or she may be forced to share toys, or, that one may become the target of a physical attack, if jealousy, anger or frustration lead to an expression of violence.
22 Certainly, a world-wise child
learns to retaliate at an early age, but, wise parental guidance, or the
influence of prudent adult guardians, will quickly intervene and show the
quarreling youngsters, the negative results and consequences of such violent
ways of trying to obtain the desired results. Quickly, both parties to a fight
are being subdued by a "physical correction" on their rear-end, and,
they are shown, that, by cooperating and controling their tempers, they can get
much more sympathy and attention from their environment than by a persistent
attitude of quarreling and whining. In every normal and common-sense family, a
child is shown, from an early age, that it has to deal with competition; that
it has to learn to control its temper, and, that the rewards of an attitude of
cooperation are far more desirable than the negative results that come with a
stubborn persistence in egocentric attitudes.
23 Certainly, for one reason or
another, some children find it much more difficult to learn to cooperate than
others, and, we may postulate, that we see, then, already a certain
"damage" of the personality development, where the egocentric pole is
being stimulated unduly by an insecurity and inconsistency of the parental
environment, while children who face little competition from others, are
invariably "spoiled".
24 If the parents are stable and
intelligent adults, they will do their best to provide a lonely child with
play-mates, so that it can learn, from an early age, the social skills and
attitudes that are so necessary for a normal personality development, but, if
the parents are not so intelligent and give-in to the temptation to shelter
their children from the hardships they had to struggle with themselves, then,
we see, by and large, a disastrous personality development. The children become
selfish and undisciplined, and, while their school years will correct, to some
extent, these defects, there is a strong likelyhood, that these parents will
keep providing their children with "protection" against the
"wrongs" perpetrated by other children and teachers against their own
flesh and blood, who, of course, "never do anything wrong".
.......
Chapter 8
Content
The variable factors of parental protection and social stability.
Absorbing the prejudices and traditional views of the social environment.
How to enlarge the cultural basis of the well-integrated members of a social
unit or sub-grouping.
Minimising the differences between "we and they"; friends and
strangers"; good and evil.
We always seem to hanker for the experiences of combat and victory.
Mankind will soon have its combative hands full with a never-ending battle
against pollution and environmental deterioration.
A shifting threat.
Social cohesion was promoted, in the past, by focussing the attention upon a
"common enemy".
Attitudes of cooperation and respect are based on an enlargement of the sphere
of mutual trust and concern.
1 Let us be aware of the fact,
that, in real life, we rarely see "pure" examples of one sort of
social environment or another. Most children grow-up in a parental atmosphere
that is less than perfect. While most parents certainly try to provide a good
home for their children, and, while they usually do not lack in affection for
their offspring, parental behaviour is often punctuated by serious errors,
lapses in discipline, marital discord with fights and frightening, or, even,
dangerous, rifts in the atmosphere of shelter and stability, which the child
relies upon to such a large extent.
2 Yet, at the same time, these
problems of the adults, their fights and reconciliations, the variable quality
of protection and stability, the varying contacts with other children and other
people, all these factors provide this curious mix of beneficial and adverse
stimuli, which most people seem to need in order to become sensible adults
themselves.
3 Certainly, there is no
evidence, that we can raise children in an experimental setting, where all the
apparently needed factors are put-together, artificially, in what seems to be
optimal proportions. We need ordinary families with their ordinary faults and
short-comings, and, we need the common play of emotions and tensions in order
to provide the average, ordinary child with the best possibilities to become an
average, but well-integrated member of society. Then, we see people, who fit-in
well with the social surroundings into which they have been born, and, in which
they grew-up, but, they also absorb from their culture all the prejudices and
traditional views and attitudes about their "common enemies", and, we
know, now, that a lack of identification with a much larger social grouping is
a severe handicap to establishing a larger and viable society.
4 How are we going to enlarge the
cultural basis of average, ordinary and well-integrated members of a particular
social environment or sub-grouping? This is an important question, because we
can only expect the emergence of a viable social structure on a much larger
scale, (eventually, a global scale), if people from different social strata,
ethnic or cultural sub-groupings, and with greatly varying cultural and
educational backgrounds, are able to identify with each other, in spite of the
fact, that they remain complete strangers.
5 Perhaps, it is somewhat ironic
or contradictory to expect people to identify with other people they do not
know personally, but, we see an analogous situation, here, because it is
possible to identify with our own society and national compatriots, even,
without knowing everyone personally. Yet, we have to know about people, and, we
have to know about them as a group. We have to come genuinely to the conclusion
that they are people "just like ourselves", before we can identify
with people we do not know personally, and, before we can support their
aspirations and struggles for a just and fair objective.
6 How are we going to accomplish
such a broadening of the sphere of concern and our social horizons, especially,
if we come to the conclusion, that the normal and natural development of
adolescents into adults makes them heirs to local cultural traditions and
prejudices? As we have seen, this means, invariably, that a large part of
mankind is considered to be "strange", hostile or "evil",
and, such a division between friends and enemies is a dominant factor in the
emergence of acts of violence.
7 We have discussed before, that,
indeed, our "biological heritage", or, rather, this package of
biologically given and genetically encoded behavioural instructions has
prepared us fairly well for a harmonious existence within a small social
grouping, but, we are, invariably, drawn into a situation of savage conflict,
as soon as we come into a close, competitive contact with each other.
8 We have discussed, before, the
paradox, that man can sacrifice his life for his buddy in a war, while busily
engaged in the "lofty" ideal of eliminating his enemies. The killing
and the sacrifice; the acts of all-out combat and brutal force, exist side by
side with the ability to care for a friend; to be deeply anguished by his
sufferings, and to mourn his death intensely. The attitudes of trust and
compassion are never completely absent, even, if man is at war, unless we are
dealing with abnormal, psychopathic behaviour. On the other hand, man is never
without his enemies, or, at least, he is never without a large number of people
he hates or fears.
9 We seem to need the stimulus of
combat and victory in order to thrive; at least, this is the impression we get,
if we look at human history in a broad perspective, because, even, if we
profess to love our neighbours and try to enlarge the sphere of compassion to
mankind as a whole, we still need to find an outlet for our aggressive
instincts, and, we still experience a need to spend our energies in a strenuous
battle against the ever-pesent enemy of Evil. Look at the strongly combative
over-tones of the major monotheistic religions, and see, how we always want to
do battle against one thing or another. How can we mitigate man's readiness to
do battle? Or, is it unnecessary to concern ourselves about the bridling of
man's combative instincts, because, soon, the whole of mankind will have its
combative hands full with the chronic, and, perhaps, never-ending battle
against pollution and environmental deterioration?
10 Man's most serious enemy was,
for a long time in the evolution of its personality structure, another human
being. Man has been locked into a competitive strife with other human beings
for such a long time during the final "finishing touches" of man's
personality make-up, that, fighting another human being has become a strongly
instinctive pattern of behaviour. However, soon, this era may pass, and, man's
most persistent and dangerous enemy will then be the man-made contaminants and
toxins that have found their way into the terrestial environment, as a result
of unbridled industrial growth, the short-sighted practice of dumping
haphazardly a variety of dangerous waste-products, or a sudden accidental or
deliberate nuclear explosion, or, perhaps, an act of chemical warfare.
11 Indeed, social cohesion seems to
be promoted, most readily, by delineating the common enemy as the over-riding
common interest of a socially integrated grouping, and, probably, the rapid
growth of our most common enemy, pollution, may forge the global unity with a
speed and an urgency no educational process would be able to bring-about. But,
what a price to pay for Peace on Earth, and, what a dismal cause for a lasting
harmony amongst the peoples of mankind. What an impoverishment in the quality
of life!
12 Let us see, whether we can
advance the cause of mutual cooperation, interest in each other's affairs,
respect for each other's varying cultural backgrounds and common existential
needs, without the drastic necessity of pooling our energies and resources into
a desperate, communal fight against toxins and poisons that threaten to
exterminate us all. A study to see, whether or not we can become more
cooperative and respectful of each other, is, at the same time, a study to see,
whether or not we can enlarge the sphere of mutual concern and trust.
.......
Chapter 9
Content
A boundless trust in a limited world.
Laying the foundations for a widening of social and cultural horizons.
The willingness to communicate and trust has to be nurtured carefully.
A significant effort and intelligent coaching is needed to bridge the barriers
of suspicion and mistrust.
A harmonious society is only possible, if a large majority feels that it is
treated justly by its leaders and fellow citizens.
We can not eradicate the instinctive tendencies of our personality.
When attitudes of trust and cooperation are strengthened.
Maintaining scrupulously the conditions of justice and essential equality.
Are we already living in a global society without knowing it?
The need to make the practical reality of global inter-dependence more viable.
The virtues of a frugal and globally justified life-style.
Re-discovering the values of discipline and self-discipline.
Only, if we manage to fuse into a global society that is lean and flexible,
just and transparent, firm and self-disciplined, only, then, will we be able to
carry-out the measured and flexible responses needed to preserve viability for
the species of mankind.
1 As an infant and child, our
trust is "boundless", but, of course, our "world" is
limited to the immediate family. By the time we reach the level of the
secondary school, co-inciding, approximately, with the onset of adolescence,
our world has enlarged somewhat, but, it is still, primarily, made-up of our
relatives and friends, the family we come from, as well as the social contacts
of our parents and relatives. By this time, we have become much more selective
in giving our trust and loyalty. We have experienced the fact, that some
individuals can not be trusted, because they will abuse this trust and exploit
us, and, if we are completely honest with ourselves, we will have to
acknowledge, that we feel, occasionally, the temptation to abuse the trust
others have given us. We may exploit and, we may be exploited, and, these
fluctuating relationships become an integral part of the sense-impressions we
receive and classify.
2 From our parents, as well as
the social environment, we learn our language and manner of speech, our
concepts, ideas, beliefs and disbeliefs, and, we take-over their prejudices and
pre-conceptions without much thought. The knowledge about people who fall
outside our sphere of contact and concern, is scanty and superficial. Here,
especially, we are likely to accept superficial, and, often, totally erroneous
concepts and judgements without knowing, of course, that they are wrong.
Eventually, our sphere of trustful relationships has more or less formed, and,
generally, we have learned to look upon each new situation and contact with a
measure of skepticism and mistrust, especially, if it involves people from the
"outside".
3 Yet, during our period in high-school, we will experience, perhaps, the most intensive contacts with people that are somewhat outside the local cultural sphere. We are thinking, here, about a well-integrated urban or sub-urban school-system, where a large variety of cultural and ethnic groupings live closely together. However, even, if the society, represented at a particular high-school, is fairly homogeneous, the sphere of contacts for most adolescents will still be larger than their home and immediate social enviroment. Here, lies a major chance to broaden the social and cultural horizon, because, rather than providing, merely, a curriculum of knowledge and information, which each student can assimilate while sitting oblivious besides each other, education could be an experiment in communicating the impressions and experiences of our existence, while being exposed to a lecture or a presentation in one subject or another.
4 Certainly, it is important to
learn the contents of an educational program, but, it is even more important to
discover, that, strange people, strange kids coming from families or social
groupings we know very little about, seem to have much more in common with us
than we thought. The basis for such a "widening" and
confidence-inspiring experience has to be laid carefully, because merely to
promote contacts by assuring a physical togetherness, may not spark any contact
at all; only an accentuation of suspicions and prejudices.
5 The ability to communicate,
and, in particular, the willingness to communicate, and the awareness of the
importance to do so, has to be cultivated and nurtured carefully, because it
rarely occurs spontaneously, and, if we want to promote contacts on a truly
wide scale, and not just between those who have a natural affinity to do so, we
have to spend a lot of effort and intelligent coaching, in order to bridge
these barriers of suspicion and mistrust. Besides, let us not under-estimate
the patient efforts needed to communicate with people who are strangers to us,
in spite of a mutual willingness to listen to each other.
6 Let us also guard against an
overly optimistic expectation, that the development of the ability to
communicate will solve all our problems, and will spontaneously lead to a
community of people with a boundless enthousiasm and reservoir of good-will,
ready to lead the nations of the world into a peaceful harmony of global
justice. However, the ability to communicate is a start, and, while we have a
lot to learn about understanding each other, we may safely state, that, without
such an effort, the possibilities to come to a global harmony and integration
of the many peoples and populations of the earth, are just not there.
7 In our efforts to make our
youngsters and adolescents less susipicious and prejudicial, we should avoid
the temptation to try to form a group of "uniform minds" who all
think and react alike. The goal of all education, as well as true viability and
stability in a social environment, is based on the ability of a sufficient
number of people to support, willingly and knowingly, the institutions and
functions of their society. True, a tyrant or a dictator can suppress,
temporarily, a people and subdue them with force into an apparently obedient
and compliant unit, but, justice is always lost in the process, and the forces
of fear and rebellion multiply. The leadership has to resort to ever more
oppressive measures and violations of basic human rights, in order to maintain
its power with a reign of terror.
8 A harmonious society is only
possible, if a large majority of people feel that they are being treated justly
by their leaders and their fellow citizens, and, that it is worthwhile to
belong to, and to contribute to their social environment. We can only have an
informed and educated electorate, if we encourage debate and scrutiny; if we
are willing to discuss, openly and honestly, all sorts of questions; if we, as
leaders, are not afraid to be questioned and scrutinised, or, even, criticised
and reprimanded, and, to be thrown-out of elected office, if we lose popular
support.
9 We can not hope to conquer the
temptations of egocentric exploitation, or the abuse of a position of trust and
privilege, by denouncing all such tendencies as a "bourgeois evil",
or, as reactionary attitudes, but, we should learn to acknowledge, that, each
one of us is always liable to revert to egocentric attitudes and anti-social
activities. We have to know, and understand, what factors and circumstances
will bring-out these tendencies in our personality, and, we have to know, what
sort of conditions and circumstances of social justice, essential equality and
honest relationships have to be present, in order to make it possible for most
of us to "trust society", and, to "trust the system".
10 By trusting the system, we
trust, that our rights will be respected, and, that we are not exploited in one
way or another, but, we can only maintain a sense of trust in the society at
large, (which is so difficult for each of us to oversee in its entirety), if we
can trust the overall social leadership, as well as all the other people who
occupy positions of responsibility. We have to trust, that these people will
act quickly and decisively, whenever they see that a situation of injustice
needs a correction.
11 My attitudes of trust are
strengthened, whenever I experience that my superiors, or fellow citizens,
refrain from harming my rights or exploiting my position, and, my attitudes of
trust are even stronger, if I experience the fact, that the leadership of my
society is firm in correcting a situation of injustice, wherever it may
develop, and, that it will not hesitate to tackle, even, a powerful force,
including myself, if someone or some grouping has succumbed to the temptation
of behaving unjustly or anti-socially.
12 Indeed, we do not have to curb
our instincts of combativeness completely, because there will be ample
opportunities to tackle aggressively the many pollution problems which will
confront us as time goes by. In addition, we will always have to adjust or
correct situations of injustice, then, here, then, there, because it is irrealistic
to expect, that, even, at the pinnacle of global social success, the society
will be so pure, so free of injustice and crime, so full of angelic attitudes
and motivations, that there is no need for improvements, or corrections of
unjust situations.
13 Nor is it realistic to expect,
that, living in an essentially just and harmonious society, means, a life free
from tensions, difficult decisions or the problems of mistakes and regrettable
set-backs. We should not expect to live in an atmosphere of blissful happiness,
experiencing a Socialist Haven on earth. Far from it, because there will always
be problems and tensions; not only, social problems and tensions that require
attention and remedial action for the sake of restoring justice, but, there
will always be some friction and some suspicions between people. There will
always be a tendency towards exploitation and a development of unjustified
pockets of privileged existence, as well as a tendency to secrecy and
conspirational activities.
14 We should not expect, that we
all will believe the same, to act the same, or, even, to have the same ideals.
Even, at the time when, in retrospect, a society will be judged to have reached
its zenith of success and cohesion, even, then, some people will have voiced severe
doubts about this same society, and, these people may have thought society to
be at its nadir, rather than at its pinnacle of success.
15 "Perhaps", you may say
to me,"we are, probably, already in a global society without really
knowing it, and, perhaps, we have already reached this pinnacle". Indeed,
we have rapidly become more integrated as nations, in particular, when we look
at the economic ties and inter-dependencies that have formed over the last
number of decades, but, in our attitudes; in the suspicious behaviour of our
leaderships vis a vis each other's intentions and motivations, and, in
particular, when we look at the enormous disparities in social justice and
living standards that still exist between the various nations on earth, we realise,
that we still have a long way to go, before we can be somewhat confident, that
these tentative steps towards an economic integration will be followed by an
equalisation of political systems, living standards, human rights and social
justice.
16 How far we have to go, can be seen, if we look at the long list of nations, where the leaderships occupy their position of power by military might. How many nations and leaderships are able to discuss freely their problems, and, in how many nations are people allowed to think aloud and question the wisdom or competence of their leaderships? Too many dictatorial leaderships only know, how to counter-act criticisms with force; with exile or executions. It seems hardly a viable method of government, if the people have to suffer under one sort of dictatorship or another, and, we can be sure, that it will be impossible to rule the entire globe by the methods of dictatorship.
17 Have we already reached a
pinnacle of social integration on a global scale? If, from now one, the course
of events is only down-hill, or, if we have the misfortune to experience a
nuclear war, or some other devastating military adventure, it may well be, that
the problems of staying alive will become so acute, that a frantic and undisciplined
scramble takes place to reach and occupy the few territories on earth, where
life may be lived for a few more precarious moments. However, let us hope, that
the future is not that bleak, and, let us hope, that the rapidly rising
tensions between people and their environment will lead to adequate attempts to
cope with these increasing problems of environmental deterioration and social
injustice.
18 We may be sure, that a truly
effective change into the direction of a more frugal and globally just life-style,
is only going to happen, if large numbers of privileged people are going to
develop the insight, and the confidence, that is necessary to initiate, more or
less voluntarily, a change towards a life-style of frugality. Only, if we
manage to discipline ourselves and curb the powers of those, who are trying to
manipulate public opinion and taste for their own egocentric benefits, only,
then, will it be possible to shake ourselves loose from this pernicious
pre-occupation with affluence and all the problems affluent entrapment brings.
19 We will have to re-discover the
values of discipline and in particular, self-discipline, where we make an
honest distinction between the minimum requirements we need to live a healthy
but frugal life-style, and, the many luxuries that are nice to have, and a
pleasure to consume, but, which may prevent us from spreading an equitable
living standard and an informed attitude of responsibility all around the
globe.
20 Anyone, who thinks, that a
majority of people will always remain gullible fools who can be exploited at
will, perhaps, under the guise of providing "employment", is a
criminal at heart, and, such a person should be dealt with as such, because the
time is rapidly approaching, that global stability and viability will force
upon us a standard of living that is austere and frugal, especially, when
compared to our soft existence and undisciplined notions, which are so
prevalent in our contemporary, affluent societies. Only, if we manage to fuse
into a global society that is lean and flexible, just and transparent, firm and
self-disciplined, only, then, will we be able to carry-out the measured and
flexible responses that are needed to preserve viability for the species of
mankind.
.......
Summary
1. The adolescent personality; a separate entity?
A metamorphosis.
A matter of definition.
A common bond of youthful exuberance.
Various ways of looking at the realities of adolescent existence.
An inexorable process of divergence between adolescents.
A look at the purpose of acquiring intellectual skills.
Physical growth and sexual awakening.
A turbulent time.
There is no coherent and generally agreed-upon imagey about the human
personality.
Difficulties for a common-sense discussion about the adolescent personality.
A bold attempt.
An emphasis on the common features of adolescence; their origins in childhood,
and the evolutionary background of our mammalian heritage.
2. Every living organism represents a channel for the dissipation of
an energy-gradient.
High-energy electron-bonds, formed by the capture of solar energy.
A synopsis of the evolution of the living organisation.
The need to spend energy is a characteristic shared by all life-forms.
A constant expenditure of "maintenance energy".
"Elan vital"; a measure of surplus energy.
A remarkable surplus energy at the onset of healthy adolescence.
The need for guidance, and the likelyhood of experiencing frustrations.
A willingness to take risks.
Data selection, according to the "filter" of our mood or outlook.
Socially determined deviations from a well-accepted "norm".
Anger and frustrations, based on sharp disparities in living conditions.
Young people are ready to commit their youthful energies to an ideal.
An increased emphasis on the realities of social conditions.
Learning to "fit-in".
Developing a skill to make a living.
The specialised "niche" in the social environment.
Building self-confidence.
The need to develop all faculties harmoniously.
Every individual can develop a few skills "above average".
Personality development, and an unavoidable divergence in skills, talents and
social status.
Learning to analyse the many reasons behind diverging personality developments.
The influence of class-divisions upon the outlook of the adolescent
personality.
Mobility through the social classes represents a sign of social well-being.
Social mobility preserves the factor of "social status" as a
reflection of individual merit.
Problems associated with "over-privileged" youngsters.
The phenomenon of "late maturers".
Youngsters with learning disabilities.
Physically or mentally handicapped people will always need special schooling,
as well as a carefully protected niche in society.
3. A remarkable parallel between the mechanisms of natural selection,
and the forces that guide the development of a personality.
Adaptations and specialisations in function.
A loss of genetic flexibility, resulting from specialised adaptations.
An infant presents itself to the world with a large variety of potentials.
Some potentials develop, others wither-away.
Normal infants have a complete range of potentials, but, at somewhat differing
levels of endowment.
Remarkable similarities and differences between youngsters.
The inter-play between the genetic blue-print and environmental factors in
physical and mental developments.
A comparison between physical and psychological mechanisms of unfolding.
Defining the essence of a "talent".
The disastrous consequences of parental "neglect".
When there is an undue stimulation of the defensive pole of the personality.
The undesirable results of "being spoiled".
Stimulating the attitudes of egocentricity and indifference.
Normal parents and ordinary circumstances provide the most natural and
healthiest balance between positive and negative stimuli.
There has to be a limit on the amount of attention given or received.
When a society has lost the ability to rely upon natural instincts and normal
circumstances.
A highly neurotic attitude that is likely to fall into both traps at once.
No wonder, affluent population groupings show, often, a dismal record in the
quality of their off-spring.
4. Molding a personality through the mechanisms of "reward"
and "correction".
The need for discipline and self-discipline.
Inborn trends and environmental factors form the primary mechanisms of
influence for the unfolding personality.
A complex mosaic of influences.
The relativity of being a "stranger".
Discrepancies in judgement and perception between members from different social
strata.
Practices that sustain an exploitative upper class.
The need for a congruence in reality perceptions in order to communicate
fruitfully.
A subconscious effort to "streamline" reality perceptions.
Living with a high level of anger and resentment.
The accumulation of wealth rests, increasingly, on the gullability and
exploitation of other people.
A baffling range of attitudes, made clear by careful analysis.
A variety of basic personality patterns.
The judgement of normality has to be made within the context of a specific
social structure.
The draw-backs of a "laissez-faire" attitude.
Living and working in an atmosphere of diseased behaviour-patterns, abnormal
relationships, and unhealthy living conditions.
A watch-dog mentality in a socially conscious environment.
It is impossible to impose the Socialist virtues by force; people have to be
ready for them.
The increasing demands of social responsibility.
A happy balance between freedom for personal differentiation, and safeguards
for a contract of essential equality.
5. Opportunities for study, when there are identical twins.
Learning to differentiate inborn from acquired characteristics.
The qualities of leadership.
Learning to dominate, when necessary, and to tolerate dominance, when it is
appropriate to do so.
A long hierarchical ladder of relationships.
The sliding axes of behaviour.
Enlarging the sphere of individual and collective concerns.
The reasons for extending to each other a package of rights and obligations.
Ethical concerns have a tendency to stretch only to the limits of the social
environment we identify with.
Flashes of insight mark the beginnings of reflective thought.
Neglected children learn to survive by their own wits.
Why weak and indecisive parents keep supporting their children in affluent
societies.
The lure of excercising a measure of parental control.
Adolescence should be characterised by a gradual but consistent withdrawal of
material and psychological support.
Developing a marketable skill.
A remarkable change in social status during adolescence.
Problems with acquiring an extended sphere of reality perceptions.
Why a sharp division of the social environment into friends and enemies is not
realistic.
Short-comings in the development of a personality.
Most of us find an acceptable place in the social hierarchy.
Filtering a series of contradictory facts and observations from the pool of
social phenomena.
Looking with anxiety at our leaders, because they have the power to do a great
deal of harm.
The world of international diplomacy and military posturing seems to be
divorced from the concerns and realities of ordinary people.
The need to have "quality control" over our leaderships.
Questioning the arms-race.
The dangers of vacillating too long.
6. The evolution of the adolescent personality.
The world of motivations.
The many aspects of manipulative skills.
Being subjected to a large series of chance-happenings.
Becoming a source of influence and guidance for young people.
All communications have a subtle emotional under-current.
The disadvantages of popularising too much.
Commercialism; a communication that is not concerned with "a truth",
but with satisfying a need.
Preserving a measure of idealism amongst teachers and young people.
When the cultural code becomes a confusing jungle of contradictory trends and
guidelines.
Passing the banner of cultural leadership to more deserving social
environments.
The universal lure of affluent luxury and the freedom to indulge.
Effective teaching is not easy in a confused and vacillating society.
Diagnosing the many tensions and frustrations within a social environment.
Education should be centered around the ability to observe honestly and
articulate clearly.
Minimising apparent differences in aptitude.
Resisting the temptation to let the more talented pupils dominate the
class-room.
7. Eliminating the elements of unfamiliarity and mis-understanding.
Conflicts, due to minor irritants and a lack of privacy.
We want and need contacts.
We are so remarkably similar in our needs and aspirations.
Appreciating the wide variety and range of awarenesses, thoughts and feelings.
A great respect for individual human life.
Sharing the same "body-plan", including the outlines of our
personality.
Excercises in thought and communication.
Understanding and insight will not prevent every situation of conflict.
Why should we give-up a position of privilege, when we can fight-off a
challenge with relative ease?
Why we need an explicit social contract of essential equality.
Analysing, how, and why, inequalities develop and persist.
A central role for the attitude of trust.
A review of the attitude of trust.
The meaning of "a smile".
A review of early childhood developments.
Egocentric attitudes can be manifested defensively or aggressively.
Normal youngsters experience, from an early age, that they are not the only
focus of adult attention.
The need for a "physical correction" on the rear-end.
A child has to learn, how to deal with competitive pressures.
Damage to the development of a growing personality by ambivalent or
over-protective attitudes.
8. The variable factors of parental protection and social stability.
Absorbing the prejudices and traditional views of the social environment.
How to enlarge the cultural basis of the well-integrated members of a social
unit or sub-grouping.
Minimising the differences between "we and they"; friends and
strangers"; good and evil.
We always seem to hanker for the experiences of combat and victory.
Mankind will soon have its combative hands full with a never-ending battle
against pollution and environmental deterioration.
A shifting threat.
Social cohesion was promoted, in the past, by focussing the attention upon a
"common enemy".
Attitudes of cooperation and respect are based on an enlargement of the sphere
of mutual trust and concern.
9. A boundless trust in a limited world.
Laying the foundations for a widening of social and cultural horizons.
The willingness to communicate and trust has to be nurtured carefully.
A significant effort and intelligent coaching is needed to bridge the barriers
of suspicion and mistrust.
A harmonious society is only possible, if a large majority feels that it is
treated justly by its leaders and fellow citizens.
We can not eradicate the instinctive tendencies of our personality.
When attitudes of trust and cooperation are strengthened.
Maintaining scrupulously the conditions of justice and essential equality.
Are we already living in a global society without knowing it?
The need to make the practical reality of global inter-dependence more viable.
The virtues of a frugal and globally justified life-style.
Re-discovering the values of discipline and self-discipline.
Only, if we manage to fuse into a global society that is lean and flexible,
just and transparent, firm and self-disciplined, only, then, will we be able to
carry-out the measured and flexible responses needed to preserve viability for
the species of mankind.
.......