Click here for PDF format of this essay
ABOUT GROWING OLD AND TAKING CARE
A Study in Thought
sa094
by
Marius Heuff
Chapter 1
Content
The only alternative to growing old, is to die young.
We worry about the future, without addressing the problem, how to age
gracefully.
We tend to forget, that our requirements and ambitions are changing
continuously.
Can we die in peace?
Thinking about life, and the gift of time.
A combative method to solve the problem of death.
Death is, once again, what it appears to be.
The concepts of natural evolution may give us a "bad taste" about the
nature of living existence.
The "evolutionary" view of life takes-away the promise of eternal
life, but it also removes the fear for eternal damnation.
The processes of death are a necessary and inevitable corollary to the
processes of life.
We can cope with death, adequately, in a framework of reflective understanding.
A gradually diminishing flow of vital energies.
A life-form is a temporary actualisation of a possibility to exist.
Anonymous contributions and contributors.
Being grateful to those, who have made a conscious effort to reduce the impact
of their existence upon the environment.
Living a life-style of as much independence and self-sufficiency as possible.
The last contribution we can make.
1 Let us agree about one thing;
to grow old is a privilege, because the only alternative to growing old, is to
die young. Certainly, to grow old may be a painful experience for which we have
failed to prepare ourselves properly, and, in some isolated incidences, the
burden of infirmity is so crippling, that people prefer to die voluntarily,
before nature takes their life at the end of a long and hopeless illness.
However, most of us cling to life as long as we can, and, we learn to cope with
the problems of old-age, as they happen to confront us.
2 I think that it is worthwhile
to talk about old-age, because we are so inclined to waste our time, together
with most other commodities that are at our disposal. We waste time by worrying
about the future, and not relishing the feeling of being alive at this
particular moment. We worry about the future without approaching the problem of
ageing rationally, and we let time slip-by. However, the most curious aspect of
our worries, is the fact, that we rarely acknowledge to be getting older. We
worry, whether or not we will have enough money if we retire; whether we will
have to give-up our ambitious travel plans, which we dream about when we are
still young and hemmed-in by financial and family responsibilities, but, we
forget, that we are growing older all the time, and, that our requirements,
wishes and ambitions are changing continuously.
3 I have been thinking, here,
primarily about those people, who have a fairly clear idea what they want to
do, and, that it takes planning to get somewhere. These people know, that no
ambitious goal or achievement is possible, without a great deal of careful
thought and a determined will to get there. Yet, if we look at people, who live
more or less from day to day, and, who are unable to bring much self-discipline
to their plans and behaviour, we see a largely useless and, often, detrimental
life-style, which results, finally, in the sad judgement, that nothing has been
accomplished; that one has responded, slovenly, to the whims of passions and
instincts, and, that one has done, on balance, more harm than good to the
social and natural environments.
4 However, it is difficult to
judge someone else's life, and, let us concentrate, first, on our own. Let us
set, as one of our goals, the hope and expectation that we can die in peace, if
we have been granted the privilege to die a natural death at a ripe old-age.
Even so, it is difficult to overcome the nagging suspicion, that we may still
not be satisfied with the way we have lived. We may have to die with the
feeling, or judgement, that we could have done better, and, that we have made
serious mistakes.
5 The more alert we are at the time of our death, the more likely it is, that we feel a twinge of regret that the end has come, but, then, we may also have learned to see, that these feelings of regret about the impending end of our life, are nothing more than a residual spark of vitality, protesting against its imminent dissolution.
6 The goal of dying in peace and
being resigned to the fact, that life is coming to an end, is, therefore, not
so much an "absolute" goal in itself, because we have little control
over the time and circumstances of our death, (unless we take our own life).
The real purpose is to think about life, as well as the gift of time. We have
to think about the question, how we are going to spend this time, and, it may
be wise to speculate about, or anticipate, the thoughts, feelings and emotions
that may be going through our minds when we are about to die. These are all
helpful aids in organising our life and building-up realistic and harmonious
objectives, which will give us, at least, a good chance of living a life, we,
and others, will not have to consider as a waste and failure.
7 We see, then, that, even, the
art of dying in peace, or, the art of living a useful and harmonious life,
depends a great deal upon the way we interpret our realities, and, how we see
the essence and existence of human life. The religious reality interpretation
is the most explicit, and, often, the most combative way to solve the problem
of death, because death is, then, "overcome"; like an enemy in
battle. It is, indeed, a remarkable denial and conversion of the primary
"facts of death", that this process, which is so inevitable and
irreversible, is totally "denied" in many religious perceptions of
reality, including Christianity. Death is, then, not seen, anymore, as the end
of life, but, only, as an important phase of transition, where life is
transformed, either, into an existence of bliss, united with the Creator, or,
as an existence of eternal condemnation, as just punishment for a life of sin.
8 With the advent of the sciences
and a much more precise grip over the nature of the living organisation, we
also gained a more realistic approach to the problem of death. Death is, once
again, what it appears to be; the cessation of the processes of life, followed
by a process of entropic dissolution, which is the result of the varying
energy-levels occupied by a large number of labile, biochemical substances.
9 For a long time, the
scientific, physiological interpretation of reality left us with a gloomy and
unsatisfactory imagery about the nature of death. Gone was the glory of dying
for one's Faith, and the images of hope and victory in an eternal existence
disappeared, too, as it became clear, that all forms of conscious awareness
were linked to the existence of a living, intact organism. The concepts of
natural evolution gave us a "bad taste" about life as well, because,
initially, these concepts showed us, only, the ruthless mechanisms of the
"law of the jungle", where love and tenderness seemed to be out of
place, and became a curious aberration that was not really viable in the fierce
competitive struggle for existence; where victory and life seemed to be merely
a matter of strength and endurance.
10 Now, we have a more complete
picture of natural evolution. Certainly, competitive struggle, together with
the survival of the fittest and most adaptable organisms, accounts for most of
the genetic molding of a species, and, we understand, now, why such a molding
process is necessary. However, the tensions and problems of competitive
existence are solved, not only, by a ruthless struggle for survival, but, also,
by the mechanisms of "socialisation" or social integration.
11 The "evolutionary"
view of life takes-away the promise of eternal life and a possible unification
with our Creator, but, it also removes the fear for an eternal damnation in
Hell. This last factor, however, was always considered to be a major obstacle
to the viability of a scientific-philosophic interpretation of existence,
because it did not seem possible to organise society successfully, without a
number of sanctions and taboos, which required the authority of a divine
commandment.
12 The mechanisms of social
integration as an alternative and complementary method to solve the problems
and tensions of competitive strife, have given us a much more solid basis to
construct a viable framework for the larger human societies, and, at the same
time, these insights have provided us with a solid foundation for a system of
natural ethical guidelines. The possibilities of life, given by the symbiotic
harmonies of numerous biochemical substances and socially integrated organisms,
also explain the inevitability of death. We are able to appreciate, now, more
clearly than ever before, that the processes of death are a necesssary and
inevitable corollary of the processes of life.
13 Without this fluidity of the
living organisation, where a constant search for viability is under way by
combining, dissolving and recombining, we would never have seen the evolution
of such a large variety of living organisms, and, we would, certainly, never
have witnessed the evolution of the faculty of conscious, reflective,
verbalisable awareness. The abilities of the living organisation, as well as
the existence of all life-forms, including the human being, were only possible,
after a long evolutionary search for existence possibilities, and, this means,
that each individual organism must have a limited life-span.
14 We can not conquer death,
anymore, in a blaze of combative victory, but, we can cope with death,
adequately, in a framework of reflective understanding, and, the latter
approach, to solve the emotional tensions associated with the inevitability of
death in a reflective insight, is far less destructive for other human beings,
compared to the solution of obtaining ultimate victory for a fervent religious
Faith.
15 The solution of competitive
pressures and tensions has to shift from a predominantly combative one to a
symbiotic and "harmonising" mode of co-existence, where
inter-dependence on the basis of essential equality, (under the supervision of
a strict but fair behavioural code), is, ultimately, the most viable, and,
perhaps, even, the only viable way for continued human existence. In a world,
where the stresses of combative strife and incomprehensible injustice are
sharply reduced, we do not need, any longer, the death-defying heroism of a
religious creed. On the contrary, such a creed would be a matter of serious
concern because of the inevitable rise of polarising attitudes that are
associated with a fervent and absolute belief. Such a polarising belief
prevents an attitude of harmony, as well as a willingness to exist in state of
large-scale inter-dependence.
16 We understand life, now, in a
broader, evolutionary view, and, this interpretation of the living organisation
also colours our outlook on death and old-age. In stead of looking upon old-age
as the nearing of the moment, when eternal life is going to begin, we see
old-age, now, as a slow, steady and gradually diminishing sparkle of life, just
as a dying star, past its prime, is on a slow, steady and long-lasting decline
that gradually fades into a state of total darkness.
17 What, then, is the essence of
the living organisation? In what sort of time-periods, or phases, can we divide
the existence of life? What is the period of maturity and senescence; what is
death, and, can we prepare for it; what can we do with our time. Can we give a
valid meaning to our life, which goes beyond the meaning of a purely
physiological search for possibilities of existence? In the biological meaning
of life, we see, that a life-form is nothing more than the temporary
actualisation of a possibility of existence. Do we have to have an ultimate or
absolute meaning for our existence, or, can we be satisfied with a meaning that
is "man-made" and socially oriented in nature?
18 Can we find ultimate happiness
in the knowledge, that we have, at least, minimised the detrimental effects of
our existence upon the environment, as well as for other people? Obviously, few
can pride themselves to have made a significant social contribution, and, even,
then, every living generation has to make this judgement anew. Perhaps, we are
lucky, and, perhaps, our contribution has gone somewhat beyond the boundaries
of our immediate social environment, but, we know, how quickly people forget.
We know, to what extent we made use of the anonymous contributions of millions
of people who have lived and worked before us, and, we know, how little we
cared about their names or personalities.
19 We used, nearly all
contributions from other people in a completely anonymous manner, and, even,
those contributors we knew by name, were only acknowledged, if these people had
made or done something out of the ordinary; something, that really caught our
imagination. We still care little about the names of people, who have made our
way of life possible, and, even, the master-pieces of great artists may leave
us cold. Then, we do not care one iota about those, who devoted their life to
creating a thing of beauty.
20 We know, that future generations
will only "know" us, if we happen to stand-out for one reason or
another, but, they can only feel a glimmer of gratitude, if we have made their
existence more hopeful and enjoyable. This is the reason, why future
generations will be more aware of the value of those people, who have made a
conscious effort during their life-time to reduce the impact of their existence
upon the environment. Soon, it will be a recognised virtue to direct our
attitudes towards a goal, where we have only consumed what we needed; where we
have cleaned-up behind ourselves, and, where we have caused little damage to
the environment and the people around us.
21 ust as we appreciate the neat
guest who is considerate, unobtrusive, helpful and modest, so is it about time,
that we consider ourselves to be temporary guests on earth. Let us consume,
carefully, and, let us not waste anything. Let us not waste any commodities or
energy, nor, should we be wasting our time and life with useless and often
harmful objectives and ambitions.
22 Perhaps, the greatest
contribution we can make to ourselves, as well as to the people around us and
the future generations, is the cultivation of an attitude of wisdom and understanding,
where we live, frugally and unobtrusively, a life of as much independence and
self-sufficiency as we can; where we spend our time thinking and learning about
ourselves and others; where we learn about life, as well as the inexorable
passage of time; where we recognise the wants and needs of others, and,
especially, the vital energies of the younger generations; where we teach
silently, by example and a precise remark at the appropriate time; not by long
lectures, which bore the young, because they do not really understand. The last
contribution we can make, is to disappear quietly and without resentment, as we
die peacefully and without undue fanfare.
23 These attitudes of wisdom and
tolerance will penetrate and facilitate the relationships between people like a
social lubricant, and, let us not forget, that, those young people, who seem so
refractory to the wisdoms and lessons of old-age, will represent the older
generation in a few short decades. Then, these same impatient people will be grasping
for the same old wisdoms to cope with their old-age, and, they will feel the
same frustrations and resistance, when trying to teach these same insights to
their own children and grand-children.
.......
Chapter 2
Content
The hall-mark of maturity is the ability to take care.
The instinct of "holding-on" to what we have.
Becoming less productive, without realising it.
Various ladders of achievement.
The dream from rags to riches has become an irrealistic expectation in our
modern, conglomerate societies.
The parameters of personal achievement, bureaucratic advancement, and financial
success.
Living a rather "submersed" life-style in our own particular world.
Our social position at the end of maturity.
The stress of living-up to expectations.
A time for sober reflections.
Many of us remain anxious and frightened children all our lives.
We all have to earn a living.
We have to give an honest day's work for our wages.
Why social justice brings the inevitable corollary of the need to make a contribution
to society.
The need to anticipate the stresses we are likely to encounter.
A large variety of circumstances.
The ability to survive, be content, and stay alert.
The freedom and ability to reduce the stress-load to a level we are comfortable
with.
1 The hall-mark of maturity is
the ability to take care; to take care of oneself and one's dependents, as well
as the environment from which we receive our sustenance. As we grow older, our
responsibilities diminish somewhat, because our children are growing-up and are
becoming independent. Eventually, we also lose our position in society, and, it
is often difficult to acknowledge and accept, that we are not needed any
longer. Our children do not need us anymore in the strict sense of the word,
and, if we fail to see the normality of this situation and give-in to the
instinctive desire to maintain a hold over our children or position in society,
we become "possessive". We may try to direct our children's
behaviour, long after it has become unnecessary to do so, and, we may be
tempted to keep them artificially dependent on us, for as long as we can, by
doing things for them; giving them money, or promising them a portion of our
assets, etc.
2 We may adopt somewhat similar
attitudes at our place of work, unless we are glad to get rid of our job. Most
of us develop a comfortable routine during the latter years of our maturity and
the slow slide into a state of decline. This means, that we are becoming more
rigid and defensive, watching younger competitors vye for our job and social
position, and, a significant part of our later years is spent defending this
job or position. However, in doing so, we run the risk of becoming even less
productive and useful, and, by the time our mandatory retirement comes around,
everyone around us utters a sigh of relief.
3 It is logical, that we try to
hold-on to our position at work, and, that we try to maintain a measure of
influence over our children, but, only very few people are lucky and talented
enough to keep climbing the ladder of their profession throughout their career.
Most of us stagnate, to some extent, as we grow older, because we are unable to
adjust, fully, to the disappointments and failures we had to face, and, our
personality becomes somewhat stifled by hidden pockets of anger and resentment.
This makes us less flexible and less willing to learn. It makes us less able to
follow directives carefully. We become less attractive for our superiors, and,
consequently, we are "shunted away" from the ladder of promotion onto
a sideline, where we can not do much harm during the remaining years of our
working life.
4 This is a short description of
the "bureaucratic model", where the level of our power and influence
is measured as a position on a hierarchical ladder of bureaucratic functions.
We can also be absorbed by a "career", where our position of power
and influence is measured by the prestige and acclaim we receive for our
productivity. This productivity may be in the form of an artistic achievement,
or it can be scientific and technological in nature.
5 Perhaps, the most common ladder
we are trying to climb, is the gathering of assets, or the goal of financial
security. Yet, in our modern, complex societies, it becomes increasingly
difficult to begin the climb towards a financial empire, unless one has a
"head start", in the form of family-ties and connections with the
world of "big business" and "high finance". Even, in a
relatively "fluid", Capitalist society, where a hard-working
individual could amass a fortune during a single life-time, starting from
scratch, the dream is becoming a legend. The dream from rags to riches has
become an idle dream, rather than a realistic expectation.
6 In the parameters of personal
achievement, bureaucratic advancement, and financial success, we see three
important elements that determine the position of an individual in nearly every
social environment, in spite of the fact, that these parameters may be mixed in
ever varying ratios. The road towards bureaucratic power may become
inter-twined with political power, in particular, in one-Party States, but, in
a pluralistic, democratic society, political power is often the result of a
combination of publicity, financial assets, and the ability to project an
appealing image. Certainly, academic achievements, experience in holding public
office, a genuine concern for people, as well as a knowledge of politics and
society, are all contributing factors to the success of a political candidate,
who has to get a sufficiently large support from the electorate, in order to
become and remain successful.
7 Most of us climb the ladder of
power, influence and success less ostentatiously, be it in the maze of a civil
service, the hierarchy of a large company, or, in the financial success of a
small business-venture; or, perhaps, as a professional expert in one field or
another. Some of us may become highly visible during our career as a popular
artist, but, most skilled people in the sciences, the professions, or the arts,
live a rather "submersed" life within their own particular world.
8 Certainly, the world of our
career is often so large, that we can "lose" ourselves completely in
it, and, we feel, then, somewhat uncomfortable, whenenever we meet people who
fall outside the circle of our social horizon. Yet, these worlds are large
enough to absorb all our ambitions and goals, and, they provide, then, the
total input to a specific, specialised personality.
9 Ultimately, our position at the
end of maturity depends on a variety of factors. In part, (and, perhaps, it
represents the most important part), our position is, indeed, a reflection of
our skills and the consistency with which we have worked towards a goal, and,
our position in the social environment reflects the skills with which we have
made use of opportunities as they came along.
10 However, there are also other
factors that are largely beyond our control, or, at least, beyond the sphere of
our skills and productivity. Did we happen to be in the right place at the
right time, which gave us an opportunity to evolve together with a pocket of
rapid development? Did we meet the right kind of people and receive a great
deal of help from our superiors? Did we develop the social skills to make us
feel comfortable with a position in the center of attention? Did we have the
health and energy to work hard for many years in a chosen career?
11 Whatever factors played a role,
we find ourselves, at the end of our period of maturity, in the late forties
or, perhaps, early fifties, in a position, where the constant demands of a
highly visible and responsible position are going to take their toll in stress.
These demands also take their toll in money, time and effort, which has been
spent in order to live-up to the expectations that were created by a life in
the lime-light. Perhaps, the only exception here, is the bureaucratic form of
power, because there, the responsibilities, or, at least, most of the work can
be delegated to younger "work horses", while the older bureaucrat can
reduce his work load, and, yet, retain the ultimate powers of decision-making.
Most bureaucratic systems of government favour such a set-up.
12 However, most of us, ordinary
people, never get so far on the ladder of social achievement, that we occupy a
position in the lime-light, or in the board-room of a prestigious company, as a
powerful bureaucrat or politician, or, as a University professor. Most of us
measure our success or failure a little differently. We reflect, soberly, at
the end of our maturity, whether or not we have been able to bring-up our
children to become decent citizens; whether or not they have been able to
finish high-school and secure a trade; whether or not they have work and can
look after themselves and their family.
13 If we try to measure our
financial success, we are thinking in terms that are quite a bit more modest
than any dreams concerned with amassing a fortune; do we have work; have we
been able to pay-off the mortgage; have we been able to pay-off our car and
other debts? Do we have a pension that will see us through our old-age? Do we
have friends, and are we accepted by the people we like to associate with? Have
we been able to hide our failures and short-comings?
14 Many of us remain anxious and
frightened children all our lives, always afraid, and, always dependent upon
others. Our personalities are never fully developed, and, if we remain in a
large city, we may face a poor quality of life as we grow older. Yet, if we try
to live in the country-site, after we have reached maturity, without relatives
to go to and without a place of our own, without some financial security and
experience, then, we see, that the road towards a frugal country-life is not
easy, and, we realise, that we should have started earlier in life; when we still
had plenty of energy to learn and adapt to a new and self-sufficient
life-style.
15 Throughout life, we are
subjected to various demands, and, old-age is no exception. During childhood
and adolescence, we are given shelter and food, as well as varying degrees of
freedom to do what we want, but, we have to listen to our parents and teachers,
and, we have to learn and behave according to the instructions we receive. As
we grow older, more and more demands are made upon us. We are expected to
prepare ourselves for a role in society, but, we do not always get to do what
we want. Most of us find ourselves, eventually, drifting into one direction or
another, and, we will have to accept, to some extent, the situation we find
ourselves in.
16 A simple basic truth of our
existence is reflected by the fact, that, we are, eventually, expected to
"earn a living", which may mean different things in a complex and
large social environment. If we have developed a few talents that are useful to
society, we are usually able to make this living fairly easy, because most
skilled jobs, (and we are not thinking, here, about exceptionally demanding
artistic, athletic or scientific skills), are easier to accomplish, once
learned, than heavy physical work of an unskilled nature.
17 If we neglect, through ignorance
and lack of guidance, through emotional difficulties or plain stupidity, to
develop, at least, some of our talents while going through adolescence, it will
be difficult to find a job, later-on. Unfortunately, too many youngsters and
adults seem to forget the simple truth, that a job, means, that one has to
fulfill a function or do something of value for someone else. Even, when
employed by a large, impersonal government, we are, in the final analysis,
working for the community we live in, and, if we do not give anything in return
for the wages we earn, we are defrauding society, and, eventually, we will lose
our job.
18 Social justice means, to provide
a great deal of security to each member of the social environment, but, a
condition of social security, together with the monies and energies it
represents, still has to be earned and provided by the hard-working,
contributory and honest members of society, before the social environment can
dispense these securities as a matter of birth-right amongst all its members.
This is the reason, why social justice and security bring the inevitable
corollary of having to make a contribution to the well-being of the social
environment, whenever the health and skills of an individual, together with the
opportunities of the moment, make such a contribution possible.
19 Therefore, even, in a social
system that protects us against poverty and helps us in the misfortune of a
serious illness, we see, that the principle of having to make a contribution is
alive and well. It is true, that a wise and compassionate society will provide
most of the security and shelter that become increasingly needed with advancing
age, but, in the absence of such a benevolent and wise social system, we are faced
with the responsibility to understand and anticipate, at least, to some extent,
the stresses we are going to be subjected to, as we live our lives through a
few decades of existence of our social environment.
20 I mean this; our own individual
life goes quickly through the stages of childhood and adolescence, through
maturity into old-age, while our social environment only evolves slowly during
this same period of time. We may happen to live in a tentative and poorly
organised society, and, we are then largely thrown-back upon our own resources.
We may be lucky and live during the maturity stage of a well-developed and
socially concerned society. Then, we will grow-up with a plethora of
opportunities for development and personal fulfilment, but, still, we will have
to face old-age, and, we will have to understand some of the fundamental facts
about the living organisation, if we want to understand the circumstances we
find ourselves in, and, the way we inter-act with our social environment.
21 We may happen to live during a
period of rapid social decline and increasing chaos, and, the quickly changing
social circumstances will cause a great deal of stress, because we are
confused. The old guidelines are disappearing rapidly, and, we suddenly find
ourselves abandoned and without the shelters and guidance-patterns, which our
society still possessed a few decades ago. Here, again, survival depends upon
our ability to grasp what is happening, as well as upon our ability to foresee,
at least, some of the trends and problems, the pressures, as well as the
opportunities, which make themselves felt during periods of rapid social
change, including the transformations of decline.
22 Regardless, where we find ourselves
in society, as a leader, a responsible citizen and a professional, a skilled
artist or scientist, or, as an average law-abiding citizen with modest
qualities and virtues, our abilities to survive and be reasonably happy and
alert depend upon our willingness to learn and observe. We have to rely on our
ability to evaluate our own strengths and weaknesses in a changing kaleidoscope
of force-fields, and, we have to be able to anticipate our own declining
ability to tolerate stress and adapt to changes, as we grow older.
23 Rather than anxiously testing, time and again, whether or not we can still function as well as we could when we were younger, we are much better of, if we learn to acknowledge, that our faculties are going to decline, and, that we will be much happier during the later years of decline and old-age, if we have provided the opportunity to reduce, at will, the stress-load and the demands society can make upon us. If we can reduce the stress-load to a level we feel comfortable with, and, if we can keep reducing this stress-load as infirmity and old-age are creeping-up on us, we have understood, at least, the principles upon which a healthy and sound old-age is based.
.......
Chapter 3
Content
A brief review of the organisation of life.
The requirements of the living organisation.
The cell, and the city; comparisons.
Cellular mechanisms of "ageing".
Mechanisms of uni-cellular and multi-cellular reproduction.
A symbiotic unit of many billions of cells, requiring efficient channels for
the supply of energy and the removal of waste-products.
The multi-cellular organisation.
The science and art of medical diagnosis and therapy.
A good grasp is possible, without an intricate knowledge of details.
An inter-twining of ageing and disease processes.
Conditions that are too severe to be tolerated by living tissues.
Changes in the organisation of life, taking place "from within".
A variety of abnormal mechanisms.
Some ageing processes are not clear-cut pathological in nature.
A gradual decline of the ability to tolerate stress.
Understanding what is happening to us.
Excercising our mental and physical faculties gently, and with care.
When we accelerate the processes of wear and tear
1 If we understand the processes
of life, we also understand, why an organism ages, and, eventually, dies. We
have traced, on previous occasions, how the organisation of life developed from
a protoplasmic primordium, consisting of symbiotically functioning biochemical
reactions. After a billion years or so of evolution in an unimaginably vast
natural experiment, the independently metabolising and reproducing cell arose.
The key to the coherence of this cellular unit of biochemical protoplasm, is
the genetic code, which steers and regulates the biochemical functions,
including the metabolic functions of everyday life, as well as those of
reproduction.
2 This genetic key reflects the
many generations of evolutionary experimentation with the living organisation,
and, the slow "molding", or adaptation, of the genetic code is the
reason, why life is still possible under a large variety of circumstances. The
many evolutionary end-results of this never-ending search for possibilities of
existence, are represented by the numerous species' still living and existing
today. Since the genetic code is carried, and transferred, from one generation
to the next, it disappears without a trace, after a species has become extinct
and all cells have died and disintegrated. Then, there will be no chance for
this species to ever arise again.
3 The large, multi-cellular
organisms seem to be far removed from the vulnerable uni-cellular organisms
that arose in the primordial seas, but, we know, now, that, in essence, each
and every large, multi-cellular organism is made-up of billions of individual
cells, each containing a blob of labile and vulnerable protoplasm. Every cell
of a multi-cellular organism needs a constant supply of energy in order to
maintain its existence. This constant metabolism of the cell requires, not
only, a constant supply of a suitable energy, but, many noxious or toxic
waste-products have to be removed.
4 Just as a large city requires a
constant influx of food, water, electricity and fuel, as well as the disposal
of all sorts of waste-products, so is the cell easily harmed and damaged, if
there is a delay in the delivery of food and energy, or, if waste products are
allowed to accumulate. Just as we see, that, industries and production plants
tend to wear-out and start to produce somewhat defective products after the
equipment has become worn, so is the machinery of the cell subject to a process
of wear and tear.
5 The combined effects of
disturbances in the supplies of energy and food-stuffs or building-blocks, the
incomplete removal of unwanted and dangerous products, together with the
general wear and tear of the numerous production processes that are taking
place in the living cell, constitute, together, a process called
"ageing".
6 In the uni-cellular organism,
the processes of division, or mitotic reproduction, lead to a nearly complete
renewal of the cellular machinery and protoplasmic constituents, and, this
negates the process of ageing. However, the multi-cellular organism can not
reproduce with the mechanisms of a mitotic division, and, even most organ-systems
are made-up of cells that are so highly specialised, that they have lost the
ability to reproduce.
7 The multi-cellular organism has
to be built "from scratch", meaning, that each organism has to go
through a stage of embryonic development, where a fertilised egg-cell unleashes
a sequence of developments that transform a single cell, (with a full
complement of genetic instructions), to a multi-cellular organism, with the
many specialised organ-systems such a multi-cellular organism requires in order
to live and function, normally, in the habitat into which it has evolved. This
means, however, that the processes of ageing can not be compensated for by
cellular division, and, there is another mechanism of vulnerability as well,
compared to the ageing processes of the single cell.
8 The multi-cellular organism is
a symbiotic unit of many billions of cells, which is organised into a number of
relatively large organs and functional systems that are completely dependent
upon each other. This means, that the supply of energies and building-blocks,
as well as the removal of toxic and noxious waste-products is taken-over by the
circulatory system, assisted by a strong pump, the heart, as well as a variety
of organs that take care of the removal of unwanted products from the blood.
(the kidney, liver, spleen, as well as organs that put the necessary
building-blocks, oxygen and energy into the blood; the digestive system and the
lungs.)
9 In addition, there are
protective systems, such as the skin, the lymphatic and the immune systems, a
large number of regulatory mechanisms, such as hormones, and, there are systems
that allow the organism to inter-act with its environment and obtain food or
escape from a predator; the central nervous system, the general and special
sense-organs, as well as the musculo-skeletal systems. In short, a highly
developed and strongly inter-dependent organism like our own body, is so
tightly inter-woven, that a serious injury or malfunction of an important organ
is likely to be followed by the death of the entire organism.
10 We see, how serious the
consequences are, when we lose a finger, or, when the blood-supply to a finger
or toe is interrupted, and, we know, that injuries or circulatory problems
affecting the heart and the brain, the kidneys, liver or intestines, are
quickly followed by a severe deterioration in the functions of all the other
organs throughout the entire body, leading to death, unless the natural
defense-mechanisms of the body are able to halt the escalation of damaging
consequences. Because of the strict inter-dependence of the cells in a
multi-cellular organism, the failure of one essential system leads, eventually,
to the death of all cell-groups, just as the lack of one essential element in
the environment will lead, sooner or later, to the death of the entire
organism; e.g., a lack of oxygen or water, etc.
11 We are all familiar with the
fact, that, the essence of the science and art of medicine, is to understand,
first of all, what is happening, when someone is sick, or has been involved in
an accident, and, secondly, based upon this mental imagery of understanding
about what is going-on in the body and mind of a stricken individual, medical
knowledge has the task to devise a course of action, or "therapy",
that assists the healing processes of the body and halts the pathological
processes that are taking place.
12 A good understanding of these
processes is possible, even, without an intricate knowledge of many details,
which can be left to the fields of the various specialties; not only, in the
field of medicine, but, in the many fields of science upon which medical
diagnosis and therapy have been based. The "lay person", or, the
individual who is not specifically schooled in any of these sciences, can still
obtain a good grasp of the essential biological features of the living
organism, if we would design a secondary school curriculum that teaches the
overall lines of the processes of life, together with the functions and
structures of the human organism.
13 As we grow older, we see,
inevitably, a variety of disease processes and alterations in functions and
structures come to the fore. These changes constitute together the process of
ageing. It is difficult for us, at this point in our understanding of these
processes, to make a clear distinction between a disease and a process of
ageing, and, perhaps, such a distinction will turn-out to be somewat artificial
and unnecessary. At the present time, we understand under the concept of
disease, a process that is, in essence, alien to the "normal" variety
of metabolic activities that are going-on. This "alien element" may
be something from the outside; a microbial or viral invasion, a toxic chemical,
absorbed through the digestive tract, inhaled, or otherwise absorbed; it may be
a thermal, chemical or mechanical accident, where, suddenly, the environmental
conditions have become too severe to be tolerated by living tissues.
14 There are also numerous disease processes that come "from within"; e.g., many of the cells maintain reproductive potentials, even, if, during the normal course of their existence, these reproductive capabilities are kept in check. We still know little about the numerous regulatory mechanisms that must exist to maintain the many billions of cells and the many organ-systems of the multi-cellular organism into a functional unit. If some of these regulatory mechanisms fail, or, if the sensitivity of the cells to respond to these regulatory signals has been altered by some sort of biochemical "injury" or influence, we may see all sorts of abnormalities of behaviour come to the fore.
15 Cells may start to multiply
without rhyme or reason, distorting local structures, or, if these cells are
seeding-out throughout the body, such an uncontroled process of proliferation
will damage many vital organ-systems, leading, eventually, to death. Or, cells
may suddenly "attack" other body-cells, if the immune mechanisms fail
to function properly. Cells that produce all sorts of regulatory hormones, may
fail, leading to a variety of diseases, or, a variety of disease processes may
come to the fore that are based upon faulty or defective genetic instructions.
16 If genetic defects are severe,
it is unlikely, that the organism will survive long after birth. Severe genetic
defects lead, often, to intra-uterine death and an early abortion. However,
subtle defects may not be apparent, untill some time after birth, and, these
genetic defects are responsible for a number of complex diseases; from mental
retardation to all sorts of enzymatic defects, leading to a variety of
abnormalities in metabolic behaviour, such as diabetes and a variety of lesser
known illnesses.
17 Nevertheless, it seems, that a
number of changes take place during ageing, which, at the present time of our
understanding of physiological mechanisms, do not seem to represent a clear-cut
disease process. For example, as we grow older, our hair gets grey, or, we lose
a lot of the hair on our head. Our bones become more brittle and break easier;
our joints become more stiff, we lose flexibility, and
"stretch-ability", of our tissues. We have less energy and slow-down
somewhat. We can tolerate discomfort less easily than we could before, our skin
may show some yellowish deposits or skin-tags, etc. We become a litte more
forgetful. We become more set into a comfortable routine, our opinions and
ideas become more inflexible, and we can express our opinions more clearly. In
short, we become more rigid and inflexible, in body and mind, and, we tolerate
stress less well, mentally, as well as physically.
18 There are other changes. The fat
distribution changes as we grow older, and, we all know about the tendency to
put-on weight. Men tend to develop a pot-belly, and changes in the contours of
arms and legs. We can also see changes in the cells, where pigments and other
waste-products tend to accumulate, and, we may state, that, at all levels of
observation, from the intra-cellular protoplasm to the overall appearance of
body and mind, a variety of important changes take place as time goes by, even,
in the absence of specific disease processes. Yet, almost everyone who lives
and dies at a "ripe old-age", will show a variety of disease
processes as well, if his or her body is extensively scrutinised, after death,
in the form of an "autopsy", or post-mortem examination.
19 We have to understand, at least,
the outlines of the processes of life and those of ageing, because, then, we
understand, what is happening to us, as well as to everyone else, who is
getting older. Certainly, the rate at which a living organism ages, varies
remarkably, and, we see this variability, also, amongst the members of mankind.
If we do not understand life or the processes of ageing, we may engage in a
long, but, essentially futile fight against the fact that we are getting older,
and, we waste a lot of time and energy in a foolish attempt to prove to
ourselves, and others, that we are an exception to the rule, and, that we are
escaping the inexorable progress of time.
20 Rather than fighting the fact,
that we are getting older, and, rather than trying to prove, incessantly, that
we have lost nothing of our vigour, a far more healthy and physiological
adaptation to the processes of ageing, is a gradual lowering of our exposure to
stress. This does not mean, that we should not remain active and excercise,
but, the purpose should be just that; to excercise our faculties and physical
capabilities, and not, to prove, anxiously, that we can still do as much as we
could twenty years ago. By excercising gently, and with care, we keep our body
and mind mobile, but we make sure, that the level of stress remains well within
the limits of what is easily tolerated.
21 If we give-in to the temptation to
prove, time and again, that we are still as vital and energetic as we were
twenty years ago, the level of stress we impose on ourselves, is chronically
above what we should be experiencing, and, in stead of a healthy mobility of
our physical and mental capabilities, we are only accelerating the processes of
wear and tear.
.......
Chapter 4
Content
Why we have to acknowledge the unavoidable processes of ageing.
The trap of voluntary financial slavery.
We are all inclined to "live it up" to the hilt.
We forget, that our energies are going to decline.
The road of "diversions", to make us forget the stress of our
contemporary existence.
An ever more efficient web of enticements.
Why is it so difficult to adopt a life-style that does not consume all our
energies or earnings?
The harsh world of free-enterprise.
Sliding, imperceptibly, from a search for old-age security, to power-hungry
empire-building.
Fore-sight is a fragile and elusive quality, especially, for those, who never
excercised their faculties of initiative and endurance.
The consequences of a "collective insurance" against adversity.
The ambivalence of a state of intense inter-dependence.
Leadership requirements.
The Socialist Society.
An interesting parallel with the multi-cellular organism.
It is still rare to see the quality of "obligatory social
inter-dependence" in human societies.
Are we still talking about the processes of injury, ageing or stress?
1 The significance of
acknowledgeing the unavoidable processes of ageing rises far beyond the chronic
anxiety and strenuous efforts to prove that one has not lost any physical
capabilities in the past twenty years or so. If we fail to acknowledge the need
for a gradual reduction in the level of stress, we will be trapped in an
increasingly unpleasant situation. The most common entrapment is financial,
because we have, foolishly, taken upon ourselves financial obligations that
stretch over a prolonged period of time, without realising, that the fulfilment
of these commitments is going to get more difficult and stressful, as we get
older.
2 Not so long ago, the practice
of slavery was abolished, but, with the rise of affluent consumerism and the
constant lure of advertising, many people get themselves into a trap of
"voluntary slavery" by accepting a prolonged financial debt-load.
Yet, we rarely realise to what extent we are compromising our freedoms, and the
quality of our existence, by carrying a burden of financial indebtedness. In
particular, the practice of buying a house with the help of a mortgage is so
widespread, especially, by the middle classes of professionals and
wage-earners, that it has been acepted as "the norm". As long as
living standards and financial incomes were rising, and, as long as a manageable
level of interest-rates and inflationary pressures was maintained, people could
budget for the monthly expense of the mortgage, but, as soon as the threat of
unemployment arose, or interest-rates climbed steeply, the financial burdens
became intolerable and posed a real threat of personal bankruptcy; with the
loss of all assets.
3 The point we want to make,
here, is the fact, that we are all inclined to "live it up" to the
hilt, but, this means, that we are quickly caught in a situation, where
maintaining the status-quo requires all the energies we can muster, and, if we
forget, that these energies are going to decline as we get older, or, that they
may be suddenly disrupted by an illness or an accident, we are inviting
"big trouble". In our modern, affluent societies, we have come to
regard a life-style of maximum energy consumption, (our own, as well as the
energy resources of the environment), as "normal", but, prudent
citizens cover themselves with a series of insurances. This may give them some
protection and some peace of mind, but, again, such precautions raise the
financial burdens associated with an affluent life-style.
4 There is another major
objection against the affluent way of life. Chronic pressures and anxieties
constitute, not only, a constant factor of stress, but, they actually enhance
the ageing processes and tempt us into the use of alcohol, as well as other
"diversions". These may temporarily relieve our anxieties, but, they
also weaken us more and more, resulting in an extra stress-burden, after the
effects of our soothing habits and escapades have worn-off. In addition, a
chronic level of stress, together with the unhealthy and transient measures to
sooth the awareness of this chronic level of stress, dulls the mind. We do not
have the time, nor the right frame of mind, to relax and think clearly. We are
caught and trapped into a web that is largely of our own making, but, we were
constantly enticed to do so by the commercial pressures that are all around us.
5 Ironically, the constant
pressures to remain financially solvent make us work strenuously at our job,
but, if our job is to sell something, or to lure other people into spending
their monies, we see, that this chronic anxiety to make money, contributes to a
mutual momentum of "economic activities", which results, in turn, in
an ever more complex and wide-ranging web of enticements. This web is so
difficult, if not impossible to resist, because we are "educated",
or, rather, indoctrinated, into the belief, that we need this way of life; that
we owe it to ourselves, and, that our level of success in life is measured by
it. Here, we see affluent consumerism at its worst.
6 Why is it so difficult to adopt
a life-style that does not consume all our "energies", and would
leave us with a prudent reserve? Why is it so difficult to anticipate illnesses
and accidents, or, the inevitable decline of our energies as we get older? Why
is it so difficult to build-up a basis of financial and physiological security
upon which we can draw when we get older?
7 Ironically, the harsh world of
free-enterprise, whith its ruthless competition for financial success, made
people well aware of the fact, that they had to look after themselves in case
of illness or old-age. The drive to build a fortune, or an empire, became an
integral part of the philosophy of free-enterprise. This drive was partly
motivated by the desire for security, but it slid, imperceptibly, into a drive
for power, as most, if not all "empire builders" amass a far greater
fortune than is necessary to secure a worry-free old-age.
8 However, as social environments
became more socially conscious, and tried to mitigate the most glaring
inequalities between the rich and the poor, a web of social provisions and
services arose, which would take care, at least, in part, of our needs,
whenever we got old or sick. Every attempt to bring the goals of justice and
equality nearer was hampered by a corresponding rise in the attitudes of
laxity, short-sightedness, and a complete reliance upon the social provisions
of a benevolent society. The desire to look after the requirements of old-age
or sickness seems, indeed, to be a fragile flower, especially, in those, who
never excercised their faculties of initiative and endurance.
9 You may look somewhat surprised
at these sentences, because, if you know my thoughts, you will remember, that I
have always condemned the ruthless practices of free-enterprise, just because
it leads, inevitably, to strong class-divisions, where society is, eventually,
dominated and ruled by a small, rich and powerful elite, while a great majority
of people lives in poverty and serfdom, literally dependent for their daily
bread on the meagre wages they receive from their over-lords. And yet, as soon
as a benevolent government steps-in and gives the poor a great deal of
security, while creating a social environment where our needs are taken
care-of, from the cradle to the grave, we see, gradually, but inexorably, the
rise of an attitude of carelessness and apathy, where people live like spoiled
children; unaware of the fact, that the benefits that are being provided by
society, have to be earned by someone.
10 The crux of the matter is, of
course, that, in any socially integrated entity, the collective insurance
against a lack of the basic needs, has to be associated with a collective
contract of obligations to contribute whenever possible. Only, if we have a
viable social contract of rights and obligations, can we, indeed, afford the
luxury, not to worry about those basic needs, but, we will have to accept the
responsibilities, as well as the obligations that come with such a social
contract of essential equality.
11 A society is nothing more than a
group of people living in a status of symbiotic harmony, and, if we see, that
society provides for us from the cradle to the grave, we see, that, countless
people in our social environment, are working and contributing to provide these
services and functions for us. The beneficial effects of such a state of
intense inter-dependence in a highly evolved social system, are clear; if the
system works well, and, if nearly everyone contributes his or her fair share,
we see a degree of well-being, trust, enthousiasm and openness that can not be
paralleled in a society, where the instincts of competitive strife are given a
much free-er reign. Yet, at the same time, we see, that such a highly evolved
social unit requires an efficient, honest and capable leadership and
bureaucracy, just as a multi-cellular organism needs a good coordinating
network of neural and hormonal connections, before it can function efficiently
as a living unit.
12 As soon as the leadership makes
serious mistakes, or, as soon as the bureaucracy becomes inefficient and
slightly corrupt, this network of trustful relationships starts to fall-apart.
People become disillusioned with the system, and the high level of
inter-dependence becomes, quickly, a burden and a trap, rather than a trustful
blanket of security. The highly evolved Socialist State is, therefore, more
vulnerable to quick decay and social unrest compared to the less coherent and
more freely enterprising societies, but, on the other hand, such a
free-enterprise society, with its inevitable class-divisions and social
tensions, is not capable to rise to the same level of communal effort and
emotional cohesion as a highly integrated, successful and inspired Socialist
Society.
13 If a Socialist Society is felt
to be truly fair and honest by most of its members, it will be invincible, as
the citizens will be able to work together and sacrifice for their society, to
an extent, that is unheard of in a more egocentric, class-ridden, Capitalist
society. However, if a majority, or, even, a significant segment of the
population in a Socialist Society is thoroughly disillusioned with its
government, this society will experience a level of tension and turmoil, which
is more de-stabilising than the turmoil in a socially less organised or
integrated society. The reasons are simple; because the people in a Socialist
Society are far more dependent upon the social system, compared to the people
in a free-enterprise society. The feelings of gratitude when things are right,
or, the feelings of frustration when things go wrong, are so much stronger in a
well-organised, highly inter-dependent Socialist society, compared to similar
fluctuations in the free-enterprise, or "laissez-faire" societies.
14 Here, again, we see an
interesting parallel with the multi-cellular organism. The more tentatively
organised free-enterprise society, which gives the citizens a great deal of
freedom in the way they make a living and survive, resembles one of those
early, tentative multi-cellular colonies, such as the slime-mold, where the
cells can live, either, in a loosely organised social unit, or, as independent
cells. A highly organised Socialist Society resembles a much higher stage of
social evolution, where the fate of each individual cell is more stringently
bound to the fate of the community as a whole. Certainly, the parallel has many
imperfections, and none of the Socialist Societies, even, those that are doing
extremely well, resemble the level of coherence that is displayed in the unity
of a multi-cellular organism.
15 Yet, in isolated pockets of
socially integrated existence, even, in the more loosely organised
free-enterprise societies, we see, that the viability of the unit as a whole is
going to determine the viability of each individual member in this unit. It is
inconceivable, that the astronauts of a space-mission could survive, if the
social unit of their space-ship would break-down. This does not mean, however,
that a whole space-mission would be doomed to failure, if a member would die. A
multi-cellular body can lose many cells without dying itself, but, there comes
a point, when injuries, loss of life and other processes, such as a lack of
communication or flexibility, may jeopardise the viability of the unit as a
whole. If a space-mission loses a critical faculty or capability because of the
death of number of its crew, the function of the space-ship as a whole may be
incapacitated to the point, that it is incapable of carrying-out the required
manoeuvres, and, as a result, it may be unable to return to earth or reach a
safe haven. This would lead, ultimately, to the death of everyone on board.
16 Are we still talking about the processes of injury, ageing or stress? These processes represent a combination of all three factors. Just as we have seen, that it is difficult to distinguish in the physiological happenings within our body between the processes of disease, injury, ageing and stress, so can we see a similar inter-twining of these phenomena, whenever we look at the mechanisms of stress-adaptation in a complex social environment.
.......
Chapter 5
Content
Is a social entity, indeed, a living organism?
The qualities of organisation and regulation.
Varying degrees of inter-dependence and cohesion.
The inter-dependence of "national units".
Human nature makes it impossible to force a state of social cohesion entirely
by "raw power", but, neither can it be done by persuasion alone.
The functions of the genetic and cultural codes.
The central nervous system of a large-scale social environment has to be
"created" by a conscious, collective effort.
Ageing and disease processes in society.
Can a social environment "take care" of itself, and age in a state of
health and wisdom?
A flowing and un-interrupted line of developments.
Getting worn and stifled by imperfections.
A tentative parallel with the social unit of multi-cellular existence.
Inter-dependence in a framework of essential equality.
Prudent fore-sights.
When we tighten the noose of financial enslavement for the rest of our lives.
Looking forward to the time when mankind grows older and overcomes the
turbulent upheavals of its early youth.
1 Is society, indeed, a living
organism? What are the criteria of a living organisation, and, does a society
qualify? We have seen, that the living unit of a cell consists of a large
number of labile biochemical reactions that have to be controled and
replenished in order to maintain their existence and organisational
relationships. It is this combination of an organisational structure, with
guidance-mechanisms and the presence of labile, reactable substances, which
gives the unit as a whole the capability to react to a variety of mild stimuli;
to move, or, to alter its chemical reactions; to reproduce, to take-in energy,
to grow, or to slow-down its chemical reactions and stagnate, accumulating
harmful waste-products and falling-apart, eventually, in a process called
"death".
2 We have also seen, that the
multi-cellular unit is, in essence, a similar structure, where the mechanisms
of organisation and regulation have transformed a large number of individual cells
into a flexible, inter-dependent unit, which can also grow and multiply, move
and react to a large variety of stimuli. Such a large, multi-cellular organism
is also subjected to the processes of ageing, which begin with a loss of
flexibilty, a reduction in the ability to endure stress, and, these processes
culminate into a process of death and decay, whenever the society of cells can
not be held-together any longer. The death of the multi-cellular unit as a
whole, leads, also, to the death and decay of all the cells that constitute the
multi-cellular organism.
3 Society is a similar
organisation, where a large number of multi-cellular individuals form an
organisational unit that regulates the behaviour of each individual, just as
the body of the multi-cellular individual regulates the behaviour of each cell.
Certainly, the level of inter-dependence and cohesion between individuals in a
social environment, is much less apparent and clear-cut, compared to the level
of inter-dependence of the cells in a multi-cellular organism, but, the
mechanisms at work are essentially the same. The antagonistic and competitive
behaviour-patterns of cells are transformed into a high level of
inter-dependence and specialisation, which mutes these competitive drives and replaces
them with a state, where the well-being and viability of each cell and
cell-group is dependent upon the viability of all the groups that make-up the
unit of the multi-cellular body. A similar process takes place in society, but,
to a lesser extent, and, we have discussed the fact, that the level of
inter-dependence varies a great deal, whenever we look at a variety of social
organisations.
4 Some of the small, highly
specialised social groupings acquire a level of internal inter-dependence and
mutual dependence that mirrors the inter-dependence of the cell-groups in our
body, as we saw in the example of the space-craft and its crew. However, if we
talk about society, we tend to think about a political unit, represented by a
national entity. Even, then, we run into difficulties, if we try to see a
nation as an independently "metabolising" social unit, because one
look at international trade and other contacts and relationships, shows us,
that, there is a strong tendency towards the development of inter-dependencies.
However, the ambitions of national sovereignty, as well as the competitive
atmosphere between large nations and groups of nations which are beginning to
form a competitive "block", are hampering the trends towards
inter-dependence on a global scale.
5 Yet, you may wonder, whether or
not it is really fair to consider the society a "living entity". Is
the level of organisation sufficient to say, that a social grouping behaves as
a unit? Does it respond like a living organism to a variety of stimuli? Are we
justified to say, that it grows and consumes energy; that it may be aggressive,
competitive and domineering; that it may get into a fight? All these
characteristics are undoubtedly present, and seem to support the argument that
a society of human beings qualifies as a living organisation, but, the
organisation is, often, so tentative, and, the regulatory functions are so
rudimentary, that we do not see a clear-cut "head", nor a central
nervous system. We do not see clear-cut organ-formations, nor, do we see this
characteristic of physical coherence and structuring between the individual
members of society, which characterises the organisation of the individual
cells within a multi-cellular body.
6 We have discussed, on previous
occasions, what the reasons are for these discrepancies, and, we have discussed
the fact, that the individual human being has a far greater repertoir, or
range, of behavioural responses than a single cell, and, we have seen, that
human behaviour has a measure of flexibility with the unique capability of a
"conscious will", which makes it necessary to streamline the
"will" and the motivational drives of people into a spirit of
cooperation, before regulatory functions in society can be carried-out successfully.
The nature of human existence makes it impossible to force a social cohesion
entirely by raw power, but, neither can it be done by persuasion alone.
7 Besides, there is another
crucial difference between the human society and an organisation of socially
integrated cells. The multi-cellular organisation is entirely under the control
of a genetic code, which has been developed over a very long period of time in
the laboratory of natural selection and evolutionary change, and, the results
are securely locked into a genetic code, which guides the behaviour of the
cell, as well as the multi-cellular unit. This guidance occurs with an
"iron hand", dictated by the invariable laws of chemical reactions
and energy relationships.
8 However, the human society has
few, if any, genetically determined behavioural regulators. Certainly, early
man evolved in a small-scale social setting, and, fortunately, many of man's
behavioural characteristics are, at least, potentially, motivated towards
cooperation. However, none of the mechanisms, institutions and bureaucratic
functions of the larger society are "genetically given", and, man has
to create the brain and the central nervous system of the large-scale society
with his own conscious mind.
9 In spite of the many
differences we can see between the organisation and function of the large
society, on the one hand, and the functions of our own body as a society of
billions of cells, on the other, we can still regard the large-scale society as
a living entity. The social organism is not as clearly defined as the
multi-cellular unit. Its members have a measure of freedom in mobility and
behaviour that is unparalleled in the multi-cellular unit, but, many of its
functions are similar, in spite of the fact, that these functions are executed
more primitively. Yet, let us ask, then, whether or not we can see the same
sort of ageing processes taking place in the larger societies of mankind, as we
see taking place in the cell or the multi-cellular organism. Can society be
"getting old", or getting sick? Can it die? How do the processes of
birth and death compare with those of the individual members? Is it useful to
compare the society and the living members in this way? Can we gain a better
grip over the happenings in society, if we consider it as a living organism?
10 It seems worthwhile to try to
answer these questions, but, they are, in essence, a repetition of arguments
and view-points we have considered before. Let us, therefore, go quickly
through these questions, in order to concentrate on the processes of ageing,
dying and decay. Let us see, whether or not a society can "take care"
of itself, after it has reached a certain age, or stage of development, and,
let us consider the question, whether or not a "society as a whole"
can age in a state of health and wisdom. What conditions are necessary, before
an individual or a society can age in health, wisdom and harmony?
11 Perhaps, the greatest advantage
associated with a perception of reality that lets us see the evolution of
society as a living entity, is the perspective it opens-up. Now, we can see, in
a flowing and un-interrupted line of development, how life evolved from a
conglomerate of biochemical reactions into the entity of a living cell, and,
how it developed from a conglomerate of cells into the unit of a multi-cellular
organism, including the human being, and, from a group of independently
existing human beings to the tentative unit of a social organisation. Such a
perspective upon the evolution of the living organisation gives us a scope of
vision we have never had before, and, the processes of living and dying, of
becoming and ageing, are inter-woven into a persuasive view, with a remarkable
degree of conceptual coherence and logical extra-polations.
12 Just as the biochemical
conglomerate, eventually, gets worn and stifled by imperfections and the
accumulation of waste-products, as well as the cumulative effects of small
injuries and minor aberrations, so is the multi-cellular organism subjected to
a similar deterioration in the perfomance of its constituent components, as
well as its organisational mechanisms. Similarly, the tentative social unit of
human beings is, often, so fragile, that its fleeting moments of function and a
rapidly accumulating series of short-comings, seem to blend together during a
brief moment of existence, and, we have a difficult time recognising the
phenomenon of the living organisation during its brief existence.
13 Indeed, the parallel is so
tentative, that many people will find the idea strange, and, yet, our own
existence, our needs and behaviour-patterns, are so well explained in such a
broad evolutionary perspective, that this view has to gain ground, even, if it
will probably gain ground only slowly. Not only, will we be able to recognise our
common biological heritage, but, we will also see, ever more clearly, that, in
nature, the solution of an all-out fight is only one of several methods with
which the tensions of a competitive strife can be solved.
14 In the phenomena of harmony and
symbiosis, (as seen in the harmony between biochemical substances in the
cellular protoplasm, as well as between the cells in a multi-cellular
organism), we become aware of an equally important and successful method to
solve the problems of competitive strife; nl. inter-dependence, in a framework
of essential equality. We have to add the condition of essential equality,
here, because we know, that, without it, a symbiotic harmony slides, quickly,
into a state of parasitism, or, perhaps, even, outright predation.
15 As an individual grows older in
society, he or she learns to see, ever more clearly, that the vital energies
are slowly diminishing, even, if such a process is not hastened by accident or
disease. We also learn, that life will become much more pleasant, in spite of
our ageing, if we have the freedom to adapt our way of life, and, if we can
reduce the stress-load according to our particular needs. If we are fortunate,
and, if we have been successful in planning a wise and far-sighted course for
our declining years, we may, even, be able to reduce the stress-load quicker
than we actually need on physiological grounds, and, this has the net effect of
a gain in the amount of "surplus" elan-vital we have at our disposal.
16 If we reduce the stress of making a living or functioning in society more quickly than the deterioration of our stress-tolerance dictates, we will have a life that is becoming easier, rather than more difficult, as time goes by. This means, that we may be able to do things according to what we would like to do, rather than according to the obligations we have; at least, this will be the case, as long as our dreams and ambitions are realistic and do not consume an unnecessary amount of energy or money.
17 For example; if we keep dreaming
about traveling widely as we grow older, or, if we keep dreaming about being
able to devote ourselves to one strenuous sport or another, we may not be
reducing our stress-load at all, even, if we are successful in making it
financially possible. If we succumb to the temptation to spend a little
nest-egg "before we are too old to enjoy ourselves", we only succeed
in tightening the noose of financial enslavement for the remainder of our life.
18 No, the secret of a healthy and
relaxed old-age is to assess, realistically, what we can do. Some of us are
remarkably strong and healthy, until a ripe old-age, and, for those, it would
be a pleasure, rather than a stress, to engage in strenuous activities. In
particular, if such strenuous activities are done in moderation, free from the
anxiety to "prove oneself", and, as long as these activities do not
represent a serious drain on our financial resources, such activities may well
contribute to a long and healthy life. Others, like myself, have a more placid
nature, and, we are less inclined to indulge in rugged physical activities. I
can find satisfaction in a life-style that is so quiet and uneventful, that
most people would find it outright boring. Yet, the efforts my wife and I have
made to reduce our dependence upon a cash-income, have brought with them a
variety of chores and regular routines around which my contemplative work has
been arranged.
19 Of course, not everyone would
find happiness in the writing of essays, and, not everyone could keep him- or
herself busy with some sort of craft or art, but, most of us could find
happiness in a self-sufficient or near self-sufficient life-style that gives us
a healthy versatility in the care we have to take of ourselves and a modest
property. We have gained a level of freedom that is utterly enjoyable. We do
not have to rush to work every morning. We do not have to face bumper to bumper
traffic, or the chronic pressures and frustrations of a work-environment. We do
not have to lead a life-style we do not believe in, with many, unnecessary,
expensive social obligations, including a highly taxed sub-urban property. No,
we can live more or less the frugal life-style, which, I believe, will become
much more widespread in the future; partly by choice, and, partly by necessity,
as the society of mankind grows older and overcomes the turbulent upheavals of
its early youth.
.......
Chapter 6
Content
What are the signs of an ageing society?
A conglomerate of numerous smaller social organisations.
The simpler model of a "special-interest" organisation.
A dubious legal claim to "sovereignty".
Nations are not equal.
The solution of a gradual fading of national boundaries.
Average citizens may be more inclined to listen to the arguments of the social
rather than the military solution.
Dreaming about the utopian prospects for a peaceful mankind.
We have to know what constitutes a condition of social and individual health.
A review of the conditions of childhood and adolescence.
Qualities of a wise and benevolent society.
The feeling, that it is good to belong to society.
Measuring the opinions and attitudes of people.
A dramatic rise in the level of social awareness.
The difference between being wise and spine-less.
The folly and futility of a global conflict.
Becoming more patient, in spite of the fact, that time is running-out.
We see, more clearly, the nature and purpose of society.
The care we have to give to our social environment.
Getting people to care about justice for everyone; on a global scale.
1 What are the signs of an ageing
society? When is a society healthy, and, when is it dying? When is it in the
process of being born? All these questions are difficult to answer. It depends
upon our definitions, when we consider a society to be dying or falling-apart,
and, it is even more difficult to say, when a society is being born. The actual
birth of a social nucleus is, often, shrouded in mystery, and, it is a matter
of hind-sight or retro-spective judgement, whenever we try to pin-point the
founding stages of a particular social organisation. It is, often, an excercise
in retrospective judgement, if we try to elucidate which factors in its
organisation or constitution made a particular social unit a success.
Sometimes, this success was so remarkable, that we still pay attention to such
a society, even long after its demise.
2 We make these questions
somewhat easier for ourselves, if we keep in mind the fact, that the larger
social entity is, in reality, a conglomerate of numerous smaller organisations.
A large society is a conglomerate, that is often held together by the powers of
a dominant segment within this larger social environment, after it has imposed
its political will on the conglomerate. Then, we may be justifed to consider
the birth of this overall, conglomerate society to co-incide with the period of
conquest and domination by the "master society", but, ethnic
groupings, as well as other social organisations, may precede the overall
conglomerate society by many decades, or, even, many generations.
3 The smaller social grouping, in
particular, the small, special-interest groupings of the larger social
environments, may have been called into existence as the result of a clear-cut
"founding act", and, we see, then, also a clear-cut "charter",
or Constitution, which regulates the behaviour of its members. Because we are
dealing with a special-interest, we see, that, only a fraction of the
existential concerns are regulated by the Constitution of such a
special-interest grouping, and, we should not be surprised to learn, that the
problems such a small special-interest grouping has to face, are quite
different from a social organisation that has to regulate all the aspects of
socially integrated human existence. The latter is the hall-mark of a political
unit.
4 If we talk about
"society", we usually refer to the larger political or ethnic
groupings, forming, together, a social environment, as the members share a
life-style, a culture, a language, as well as a government with a set of common
behavioural rules and guidelines. Such a society has a long and complex
history, as various groupings clash and fight for dominance or independence.
Some are victorious and become dominant, or, they may exterminate a majority of
those who have been conquered. Others lose, and are amalgamated into a new
culture, or a new society, and, the round of conflicts and conquests begins
again, as soon as a measure of vigorous vitality has been established.
5 This is the reason, why the contemporary
political boundaries of all nations, States and federations are the result of
their particular fortunes and misfortunes in the past. What is, therefore, a
"legal claim" to sovereignty, is based, in essence, upon the
accidents of history, and, no nation can claim, that it has never conquered or
dominated people who occupied these territories before.
6 The haphazard growth of
nations; their inequalities in population, size and viability; the haphazard
circumstances that led to existing boundaries, as well as the equally haphazard
cultural and ethnic make-up of a "country", (a political entity as
defined by the concept of a sovereign nation-state), makes a mockery of the
claim, that national sovereignty is sacro-sanct, or, that each nation should
have an equal voice on the basis of democratic equality. Both claims are based
on untenable assumptions, but, the establishment of the United Nations is a
step forwards in the development of an attitude that favours the methods of
negotiation and compromise.
7 Yet, if we think about it,
clearly, we see, that the only solution to halt the conflicts between ethnic
groupings and national entities, is a gradual fading of these arbitrary
national boundaries, as well as an abolition of the concept and practice of
national sovereignty. However, before we can convince a majority of the people
in a specific social environment, that any clam to national sovereignty and
security is an out-moded and unworkable idol, we have to do a lot of hard work,
in order to show the people, and their leaderships, that security and viability
can not be found in an attitude of jealously guarded national sovereignty and
independence. We have to show them, that such attitudes will inevitably lead to
ever-escalating efforts to maintain military superiority over competitors and
challengers.
8 Perhaps, those of us, who are
not involved in the leadership structure of a military and ruling elite, will
find it easier to accept, that it is a fallacy to try to safeguard a social
environment with military might, and, average citizens may be more inclined to
listen to the arguments of a social rather than a military solution. In the
social solution, we actively strife towards an enlargement of the boundaries of
the social environment, until, we all, including our foes and competitors,
become part of an overall, socially integrated structure. Then, we may be able
to co-exist in a tentative, and, perhaps, always somewhat tense organisation,
but, at least, we will have gotten rid of those fiercely competitive national
leaderships, which tend to poison the atmosphere with their propaganda and
halftruths. We will have one all-encompassing leadership and set of
Constitutional Guidelines, which is continuously trying to bring a measure of
justice and equality to a society with global dimensions.
9 Before we can dream about such
utopian aspirations for a peaceful mankind, we need to understand more about
ourselves. We need to know, what constitutes a condition of health for our
personal existence, as well as the society we live in. Any organism, including
our own, is in good health, if it has, first of all, an opportunity to be born
and develop under favourable conditions, and, this means, that it must have
been nourished adequately by the maternal blood-stream, and, it means, that the
mother did not do anything, by accident or intention, to harm the physiological
development of the embryo and the birth of the child.
10 As a child, we should receive a
stimulating but difficult to define mixture of protection and encouragement;
with clear-cut indications about the limits of tolerable behaviour, as well as
a rich exposure to the psychological inter-actions between the members of the
family, and, later, with the members of the social environment.
11 During childhood and
adolescence, all youngsters should have a roughly equal chance to develop some
of their talents and inclinations. Every youngster should have a chance to be
educated, fed and clothed properly, and, to be treated justly, so that the
adolescent and the young adult will have the best possible chance to find a
suitable and harmonious place in society. During adult life, we should all
enjoy equal rights and treatment under the law, and a wise society will
continue to guide the behaviour of its citizens in such a way, that the most
appropriate and contributory life-style is chosen. A wise and benevolent
society will make sure, that people are somewhat protected against the
consequences of grave misfortunes, such as a serious illness or accident, unscrupulous
and exploitative practices, as well as an excessive loss of property through no
fault of their own.
12 Such safeguards and regulations
contribute to a feeling, shared by a large majority of citizens, that it is
good to belong to society; that there is a reasonable protection and reward for
all the hard work that is being put into one's job. These safeguards and
regulations will contribute to the feeling, that there is justice and equality
under the law, and, that the authorities can be trusted. Such a feeling of
appreciation for the society in which one lives, will generate an
extra-ordinary outpouring of good-will towards one's fellow members in society,
as well as an abundant willingness to bring sacrifices for the good of society.
13 The health of a society can be
measured in the opinions and attitudes of the majority, but, I grant you, that
it is often difficult to get an honest or precisely articulated opinion from
the people. Still, too often, the level of education is so low, and, the people
are so easily intimidated by a domineering and authoritarian regime, that they
do not even dare to admit to themselves, how frightened they are. Then, they
will be unable to communicate their true feelings. Only a few people may have a
good idea, what the society could and should be, but, the majority shows an
attitude of apathy and resignation, together with a cautious shrug of the
shoulder.
14 However, once people have a
better idea, what society should mean to them, and, what rights they can expect
from a wise and benevolent social environment, we see a dramatic rise in the
level of social awareness. Then, we may see a persistent, if painful, attempt
by millions of people, all over the world, to bring their respective societies
or social environments, to a generally accepted standard of "good
health"; of adequate justice; of well-being for all; where everyone
receives a measure of protection and opportunity in exchange for a faithful
contribution according to talent and opportunities.
15 Perhaps, the rising level of
general physical and mental health, which is accompanied by a gradually rising
standard of living and life expectancy, will help us to bring-about this slow
but persistent pressure towards a greater degree of social justice and health. Older
people learn, eventually, the lessons of wisdom. They learn the futility of
violent confrontations, and, they can see, more clearly than young people, how
similar our existential requirements are; how similar we are, in particular, to
those we dislike the most.
16 Older people, eventually,
"mellow", but, this does not mean the acceptance of a spineless
compromise, or an inability to fight for what is considered to be just and
right. I think, that older people have, at least, a chance to formulate the
principles of justice in a way that reflects a global orientation of human
needs. Certainly, as long as we are alive, our instincts will prod us,
rightfully, to look after ourselves, but, as older people, we become less
obsessed with the fulfilment of our particular goals. We can take life more as
it comes, and, we learn to enjoy and savour life, day by day, as we realise,
ever more clearly, that time is limited, and may be running-out, soon.
17 This awareness of old-age; this
awareness of the fact, that the greater part of one's life is behind, and, that
many dreams and wishes will remain unfilfilled; the striking similarities
between the generations as we see them emerge in a continuous stream of births,
all these awarenesses and experiences show us the common denominators of human
existence, and, they show us, ever more clearly, the folly and futility of a
global conflict with its un-imaginable suffering and destruction.
18 Older people learn to be more
patient, and, they learn, that the world can not be reformed in a day, perhaps,
not, even, in a life-time, and, they learn to live with the frustration, that
all their efforts seem to have little or no effect. Yet, at the same time, this
attitude of patience, the willingness to tend to all sort of problems, even,
small problems, as they confront us, from day to day, allows us to develop this
all-important ability; to take care.
19 As we go through life, we learn,
slowly, how to take care. We come into the world as a helpless infant, but,
quickly, we learn, how to get help and attention, provided, of course, that
care is available from the immediate social environment. Gradually, we learn to
do more for ourselves, until we become parents as young adults.
20 Then, we have to take care of
our youngsters, our home, the problems at work, and of relating to other
people. Finally, as we get older and retire somewhat from the most demanding
aspects of our profession or social position, we learn to take care of things
we had other people do for us, before. We learn to take care of our declining
health, the small ailments, and the minor handicaps. We also learn, again, to
care for the people close to us, whom we often neglected, to some extent, when
we were busily occupied at the height of our career. We learn to see, more
clearly, the nature and the purpose of society, and, because we have made more
time free for ourselves, we begin to look at society with a somewhat different
perspective.
21 We see, that society is a living
organism after all, and, we understand, that society needs our care and
attention, just as much as people in our environment need care and attention.
We may not have to give care and attention the way we care for our dependents,
however, and we certainly should not adopt patronising attitudes towards
society. (We are inclined to be patronising towards other people, especially,
if we consider ourselves a staunch pillar of the Church, or, an important
member of the local social elite.)
22 The care we have to give to
society, is the care to see, that justice is done and maintained. We have to
make sure, that we do not condone or contribute to anything that is contrary to
the princples of justice and equality under the law. If we learn to take care,
and to be honest, we find, that we have the courage to speak-up, and, we have a
better ability to articulate our opinions. This is the best way to take care of
society, because we realise, ever more clearly, that the health and stability
of a social environment is accurately reflected by this all important
"sense of justice". If a large majority of the people thinks, that
they are getting a fair deal, we may assume, that the society is in a
reasonable state of health.
23 More and more people have to be
concerned with the general sense of justice in their social environment,
including the rights and the sense of justice of those people, who live
far-away, in a different country. If we can get people to care about this sense
of justice on a global scale, and, to promote the application of fair laws and
guidelines, everywhere, without discrimination, and, if we genuinely want all
peoples to share in this sense of well-being and justice, then, we may
conclude, that our care has not been in vain, and, that society is in a fairly
good state of health.
.......
Chapter 7
Content
The importance of the ability to care.
The corner-stone of social health.
A role for the older generations.
The need for careful thought.
Attitudes of good-will and charity are not sufficient.
Essential equality is a right; not a gift dispensed by the privileged.
Being careful with the environment.
A few generations hence, our ideological struggles will seem irrelevant.
We are becoming quickly more inter-dependent; apparently, more rapidly than we
can comfortably cope with.
We all have to get involved in thinking about the destiny of human existence.
Our leaders want peace, but do they know how to establish or preserve it?
To care is to speak-up, whenever we have an opportunity to do so.
Let us study, reflect and think, before we speak or act.
We have to measure our energies carefully.
The most urgent priority is to reduce the risk of a nuclear war.
Who knows, how close a nuclear war is?
Making sure, that the threat of nuclear weapons has disappeared forever.
The factor of increased social transparence.
The collective will can reign supreme.
Treaties and promises are not enough.
The price of neglect.
Scrutinising, carefully, all promises made by political candidates.
Social health will increasingly depend on the quality of collective fore-sight.
1 To care for something or
someone; to take care of oneself, one's property, one's problems and
obligations, and, to be careful and thoughtful about everything we do or say,
is, probably, the most constructive and contributory attitude we can adopt.
Future generations may well consider this attitude the corner-stone of social
health. I believe, that the older generations are going to lead the way in
this, and, the fact, that, rising standards of health and well-being are
increasing the age of the population, will have an unexpected bonus. As the
proportion of older people rises, the voice of moderation and caution, wisdom
and care, should also become stronger.
2 Certainly, a mere willingness
to take care, to "do good", or, to show a friendly attitude towards
others, is not sufficient to solve our problems. We need a lot of hard work in
the form of careful thought and debate in order to understand, more precisely,
the nature of human existence. We can not solve the problems of living together
by adopting, merely, an attitude of good-will and charity on the basis of
religious beliefs and commandments. The problems associated with living
together at close quarters, and sharing a variety of dwindling resources, have
to be understood and solved on the basis of commonly acceptable principles of
justice. The poor and the depraved are quite right, if they rebel against an
attitude of charity. The help they receive in order to help themselves reach a
decent standard of living, is their's as a right, and, this assistance should
not depend upon the charitable impulse or magnanimity of a privileged
individual or group.
3 Let us take care of ourselves,
so that we can take care of those, who depend upon us. Let us take care of our
property and our environment, so that we do not waste and destroy. Let us be
especially careful with our environment, so that the generations after us do
not inherit a gigantic garbage dump. If we are not careful, they may well
inherit a dangerously polluted earth, as well as a mismanaged and scandalously
exploited remnant of natural resources. Let us be careful and think a little,
so that the generations after us will not curse and condemn us posthumously, as
blind fools.
4 Let us not forget, that a few
generations hence, people will consider the struggles of our times, be it
ideological in nature, or a struggle for power and dominance, as irrelevant and
wasteful foolishness. Let us think about this, as we are supporting our leaders
in their arms build-up, their belligerent rethoric, and their deceptive appeals
to sovereignty. Let us think about this, as they indoctrinate us about the
sanctity of our culture or the villainous designs of our enemies.
5 After the major part of the world
has been destroyed in a nuclear exchange, all these arguments of the past will
seem to be futile and irrelevant, ignorant and stupid. The survivors will look
back, with nostalgia, at the history of man, before the nuclear holocaust, and,
they will only have their memories to fall back on, when trying to visualise a
world as it once existed, before man destroyed it.
6 Yes, I am pessimistic about the
present trends of human behaviour. True, our belligerence, today, is not any
worse, or different, than the belligerence of man throughout recorded history.
But, the consequences of our belligerence are becoming unacceptable and
intolerable. Not so long ago, we could afford the attitude, that a conflict
between others did not concern us, and, we could mind our own business, while
the combatants slugged it out, while we hoped, secretly, to be able to profit
from the fact that they were seriously weakening each other.
7 Now, we are all involved, just
as the lives of everyone aboard a space-craft, an air-plane, or a small boat,
are at stake, whenever a serious conflict breaks-out between a few people, or,
if the mental health of a member breaks-down. We are becoming increasingly
inter-dependent, perhaps, not, as yet, in an economic sense, and, certainly, we
have not managed to become politically inter-dependent on a global scale,
because the world seems to be fragmenting into a few, large, political
"tectonic plates". However, in our acts of warfare, we have become
totally inter-dependent. Even warfare on a small scale with so-called
"conventional weapons" is now so destructive, that cities and rural
areas can be completely devastated. We can not imagine, what it would be like,
whenever a nuclear war takes place.
8 It is becoming more evident all
the time, that, we, ordinary people, have to get involved, and, we all have to
think about what is happening. We have to try to stop this mad race towards an
armed conflagration. However, let us not come to hasty and erroneous
conclusions, which may weaken our cause. Let us not glibly assume, that the
leaders of the super-powers are steering deliberately a course towards nuclear
war. They are honest, if they state, that they do not want a war anymore than
we do. They honestly believe, that the only way to prevent a war, is to be so
strong, and, to have so many weapons, that military might acts as a deterrent
to any sort of military adventure by our enemies.
9 Here, they are wrong, because
they do not take into account, that, the policy of military might as a
deterrent leads, also, to a spiraling arms-race, which can not be curbed,
because the mutual trust that is necessary to come to a workable treaty, is
undermined by the doctrine of building-up a credible military deterrent. They
are also wrong in assuming, that such a build-up of arms will not lead to an
unintentional conflagration that may easily get out of hand.
10 While we do not deny that our
contemporary leaders want to preserve peace, or, at least, a status-quo, we
disagree with their methods, and, we are convinced, that their present
policies, on both sides of the ideological divide, will, inevitably, lead to a
nuclear catastrophe. We see, clearly, that the primary, instinctive
behaviour-patterns, which are so clearly displayed by our national leaders, are
leading us into a morass from which there is no escape. Let us not deny the
validity or truthfulness of the primary, instinctive reaction to seek security
in military might, but, let us patiently show, again and again, the
evolutionary "dead-end" into which these attitudes lead us. Let us
try to convince our leaders, as well as the established segments of every
social environment, that there are alternatives to the search for an absolute
security, and, that it is possible to reach an acceptable level of existential
security in the form of a social contract, rather than a never-ending
arms-race.
11 I believe, that the arms-race,
in particular, the nuclear arms-race, together with the unbridled attitudes of
super-power rivalry, are the major and most acute problems we face, regardless,
where we live; regardless what creed or political system we believe in, or,
what sort of leadership we support. What will be the good of all our scientific
and technological progress, if we lose everything in a nuclear holocaust? If we
want to have a chance to design a just society that is organised on a global
scale, we will have to contain the threat of nuclear war. Can we do it, or,
does a serious nuclear accident, or a limited nuclear exchange have to happen,
before the pressures of public opinion will be strong enough to curb the
belligerent and suspicious instincts of our leaders and their military
establishments?
12 To care is to speak-up, whenever
we think we are right, and, whenever we know, that something is wrong. To care,
is to have the guts to risk controversy and embroilment, but, to care, also
means, to think and reflect, and, to refrain from jumping, thoughtlessly, on
some sort of a "band-wagon". To care, is to be careful with what we
say or do. Let us study, reflect and think, before we do or say anything, but
once we are convinced, that we can say or do it right, let us, then, have the
courage to say or do it, as it should be done.
13 Yet, we have to measure our energies carefully. As we grow older, we know, that time is running-out, and our energies are limited. We have to choose, carefully, what we want to get involved with, otherwise, we are wasting our time, and, we are diluting our efforts over too many projects. Then, none of these projects will be carried-out or completed with any sort of finesse. Let us be careful to choose well, and, let us get our priorities right.
14 The most urgent priority is to
reduce the risk of a nuclear war; or, is it erroneous to think, that such a war
is close at hand? Is it erroneous to assume, that the likelyhood of a nuclear
exchange grows as the number of missiles and war-heads grows? Who knows? We
have no way of measuring, how close a nuclear war really is, especially, since
it becomes more likely, that a nuclear war will happen inadvertently. If a
nuclear missile is fired by mistake and destroys a major city, it will be very
difficult to convince the party whose city has been destroyed, that it was
"an accident". Will there be time for consultations and explanations,
and, will these explanations be believed, or, will they be interpreted as a
desperate ploy to avoid retaliation?
15 We will never know the answers
to such agonising questions, and, our only recourse is to do, whatever we can
to make such hypothetical questions irrelevant. Let us pressure our leaders and
establishments into adopting a policy of complete nuclear disarmament, so that
they can satisfy their belligerent instincts with a war of words, or, at least,
the somewhat less devastating consequences of "conventional arms".
How are we ever going to be sure, that all nuclear weapons have been destroyed,
or that the capability to quickly re-assemble nuclear war-heads, together with
their delivery-systems, has been effectively eliminated?
16 The only possibility, I see, to
make sure, that the threat of a nuclear conflict is, indeed, gone, for good, is
a world-wide network of concerned and inquisitive citizens, who are going to
scrutinise all hidden corners of society, all military establishments and
structures, including all political, scientifc and military activities. We can
only ensure the total ban of such weapons, if we all work together, for many
years, and, perhaps, for many generations. We have to work incessantly for the
establishment of an increasingly transparent social environment. There should
be a complete openness in society, in particular, of the powerful and hidden
corners of political and military establishments.
17 Let us not forget, that the
political as well as the military leaders are there to serve the interests and
the will of the public, and, if we, the people, want them to disclose
everything, and, if we want them to dismantle all their nuclear weapons, we
have a perfect right to demand their compliance with our collective will.
18 Treaties and promises are not
enough, because these can be broken, and we can be deceived. Only, if a large
majority of people, all over the world, is in favour of total nuclear
disarmament, only then, do we have a chance to achieve this goal. But, we also
have to realise, that we have to create, first of all, leaderships that are
accountable to the will of the majority, and, we have to create the powers of
control and investigation, in order to make careful policing of a total ban on
nuclear arms, a realistic possibility.
19 We have to take care. We have to
take care of ourselves, as well as the people who depend on us. We have to take
care of the environment so that we do not waste and destroy. We have to take
care of our society, our leaderships and their institutions. Unless we care
about good quality leadership, as well as a fair and open society, we are not
going to get a benevolent social environment, nor, an honest and impartial
leadership. If we neglect ourselves, we will age fast, and we will be susceptible
to diseases and accidents. If we neglect our property, our home and our
environment, we will soon be living in a slum, and, if we neglect our children
and our family, they will grow-up to be resentful strangers.
20 Everything needs care, and, our society
needs care, too. We do not have to infringe upon the independence or the
privacy of our neighbour, but we can take care, that the relationships remain
cordial and respectful. We may interfere as little as possible in each other's
affairs, and, yet, we should be able to keep a sharp eye open for practices
that go against the common good. We need to take care about our relationships
with other people, and, in particular, we need to take care of our public
institutions, as well as the people who offer themselves for public office.
21 If we see people offering
themselves for an official function or a leadership position, we have the
right, and the duty, to scrutinise, carefully, their behaviour, their plans and
thoughts. Let us look for people, who understand the importance of fairness and
equality under the law, and, let us be weary of those, who promise us
everything under the sun in order to get our vote. It is tempting to believe an
individual, who promises us something special, but, we owe it to ourselves to
think such a promise through. Why are we singled-out for privileged treatment?
What is the catch? Who is going to pay for this? What has been promised to
others? Is there any chance, that these promises can be kept? Will someone else
be discriminated against? Is it fair, that we receive special treatment? What
would we think, if someone else would be singled-out for a special favour? Is
it just rethoric to buy our vote, and, has everyone else also been promised
some sort of a special deal? Who is going to pay for all these favours?
22 We have to think clearly, and, we have to take care not to be lured by facile promises. As we learn to scrutinise election promises more closely, and, as we learn to ask all sorts of pertinent questions, our aspiring political leaders will learn to be more careful and honest about what they say and do. The more we, ordinary citizens, understand, what it means to have a just society, where the leadership is responsible and accountable to the people, the better our leaders will perform, and, the better our leadership institutions will be able to function on the basis of equality under the law, and justice for all.
.......
Chapter 8
Content
It is not easy to look well after ourselves.
Diseases and accidents do not happen "out of the blue".
Learning to read the warning signs.
When we begin to "take chances".
The criminal attitude of hoping to make "a quick profit", because it
always implies an unscrupulous attitude towards other people.
Relying on experts.
Professionals have made a life-time career of becoming an expert in one little
aspect of this gigantic complex of "taking care".
The need to keep an overall perspective in view.
The rise to power of the narrow specialist is a serious problem.
Will the "generalist" be able to make a come-back?
The art of making valid generalised statements is not appreciated at the
present time.
A baffling spectacle of squabbling experts.
A few examples of contradictory and confusing opinions.
The logic of advocating a return to religious standards of moral behaviour.
To take politically care of a large society is not easy.
There is no need to be intimidated by expert opinion.
We have to set, collectively, our major social objectives.
Ulimately, it is our decision to let our physician go ahead with a proposed
plan for investigation and treatment.
The ability to talk intelligently with an expert or professional.
Fixing a problem by replacing a "block of functions".
All expertise is, in essence, a tool to be used, intelligently, by the ordinary
consumer.
We also have to learn to listen to, and accept, the advise of honest experts
who are trying tell us something that is not pleasant to hear.
1 I know, this is all much easier
said than done, and, I realise, that, even, such a seemingly simple task as
looking after ourselves and our belongings, is not as easy as it may appear.
The reason is, of course, that we have to know something about ourselves, as
well as the many tools and devices we have around us, before we can hope to
accomplish any sort of care and maintenance, even, if we have the energy, and
intention, to do some work ourselves, rather than rely upon the experts to do
it for us.
2 Even, the task of looking after
ourselves slides, already, so easily into a medical problem, for which we may
need expert help, but, here, too, we see, how important it is, to have, at
least, a basic knowledge about the functions of our body and mind. If we have
some idea about these mechanisms, we will find it much easier to understand, what
the physicians tell us, and, we will be in a much better position to know, what
we can do ourselves to prevent, or, at least, minimise the chances of getting
into a serious problem.
3 Certainly, most diseases and
accidents appear to happen "out of the blue", without warning, and,
apparently, without any chance to prevent them. Yet, if we look closer and
analyse, sharply and honestly, the history of our experiences leading up to an
accident, or the outbreak of a disease process, we see, that warning signs were
almost invariably, there. We, either ignored them deliberately, or, we failed
to recognise their significance.
4 Disease processes have, almost
always, a fairly long history of increasing signs and symptoms, and, most diseases
are easier to cure or correct, if they are diagnosed in their early stages. The
same applies to a serious accident. If we honestly evaluate the history of our
experiences, we see, that we have been ignoring little mistakes, or, apparently
minor incidences of careless behaviour. If we really want to avoid serious
accidents, we almost certainly can, but, we have to acquire the knowledge, and
the insight, to recognise how the chances of a serious accident are slowly
building-up.
5 In retrospect, we can, almost
always, re-construct a series of happenings and events, which should have
alerted us that the possibility of a serious accident was increasing. Often, we
ignore these signs, because we are afraid to be called an alarmist, or, we
leave the decision to react, to someone else; or, we know, that we do not have
the means to deal effectively with the underlying problem because of flaws in
the equipment or short-comings in the rules and regulations. Then, we literally
"take our chances".
6 It is one thing to take chances
with our own health, safety or life, but, increasingly, in particular, in large
industrial projects, the lives and health of numerous people, as well as the
well-being of the environment, are at stake, and, if we continue to be careless,
to take our chances in the hope of making a quick profit, we only contribute to
pollution and the deterioration of our terrestial eco-systems.
7 To take care, properly,
requires a great deal of wide-ranging knowledge and insight, and, it is not
surprising, that we tend to rely on "experts" to take care of the
many problems we have. We need medical and dental experts to look after our
body; we have priests and ministers, psychologists and psychiatrists to help us
with mental problems; we need legal experts to help us in our disputes, and, we
need a large and complex body of experts to govern our society, collect taxes,
provide public services; to grow our food, mine resources, and monitor the
eco-systems of the terrestial environment.
8 These activities are all
manifestations of the chores of taking care. We have to make sure, that we are
healthy in body and mind, as well as in our social arrangements and
inter-actions. Many of these tasks have to be done by professionals, who have
made a life-time career of becoming an expert in one little aspect of this
gigantic overall complex of "taking care". Yet, we, ordinary
citizens, non-specialised people and experts alike, we all need to develop and
maintain some sort of over-view, where we can see the logic and rationale, how
all these specialised functions relate to each other. If we lose this overall
perspective, we lose also the ability to judge, whether or not the thrust of a
particular expert concern or advise is healthy and wise, as well as beneficial to
the social and natural environments.
9 If a physician would only look
at a miniscule detail of the overall body, he loses sight of the fact, that the
body has to function as a unit, before an individual feels healthy and happy.
The same applies to our society. If we emphasise, only, the particular concerns
which happen to be our field of expertise, we may have our priorities all
wrong, and, we may start to squabble and fight with other experts, who,
naturally, consider their particular field to have "top priority".
10 The rise to power of the narrow
specialist is one of the most serious problems the complex societies of our
times are facing. The fields of science and technology have been fragmented,
literally, into thousands of fields of expertise, and, each field has become a
world on its own, completely absorbing those, who have devoted their life to
mastering their particular field. Unfortunately, the "generalist",
the overall philosopher, who is interested in the field of existence as a whole,
has been pushed into the background, because, regardless of the topic he wants
to discuss, he will be muzzled by the experts in any particular field, who can
quote statistics and extensive references, and, who are aware of the finer
details. The art of making valid generalised statements is, indeed, not
appreciated at the present time.
11 As a result of this loss of a
useful over-view, or, perhaps, because of the fact, that the art of creating a
useful and authoritative over-view has not kept pace with the rapidly
increasing complexity of the modern world, we see an extra-ordinary degree of
confusion about all the major questions and policy decisions that face us.
Ordinary citizens are becoming increasingly baffled by the spectacle of
squabbling experts, struggling for dominance and priority. This is the reason,
why our modern societies show strident and contradictory view-points on each
and every problem, concern or topic of interest.
12 Some groups clamour for a rapid
development of the economy in order to "create jobs", they hope,
together with a loosening of the money-supply. Others argue, just as
convincingly, that the problem of un-employment has to be solved by the
creation of a truly competitive industry and a stable climate for capital
investment. Some of the groups in society will vocally demand a rapid expansion
of the mining of resources, including the extraction of petro-chemicals from
hazardous sea-bed operations, while others point, tirelessly, to the dangers of
pollution and damage to wild-life and sea-life in case of a major oil-spill.
13 Some people advocate,
strenuously, that society be "protected" by a costly and dangerous
wall of nuclear missiles and anti-ballistic missile defense systems, while
others point to the lunacy of even contemplating the use of nuclear weapons. In
essence, we are always witnessing a battle between narrow experts, who can
quote, impressively, a large number of references and statistical facts.
14 There are people in society, who
claim, loudly, that they should have the right to decide, what to do with their
own body, including the right to terminate a pregnancy, while others point-out
with just as much conviction, that the baby in the womb is a different person,
and does not belong to the body of the mother, even, if it is still nourishing
on the maternal blood-stream. Again, this debate is a result of the fact, that
we do not have a clear idea about the essence of life, or the nature of
reproductive mechanisms.
15 We hear people advocating a
return to strict religious beliefs and moral standards, and, they would like to
see the imposition of a theocratic leadership on society, while others remain
faithful to the principles of freedom of religion and beliefs, as long as the
basic human rights of each and every citizen are respected.
16 Look, how confusing and
incompatible the pressures are for our political leaders. They are pushed and
cajoled into diametrically opposed opinions and attitudes, and, we should not
be surprised to see, that it is extremely difficult, and, sometimes, impossible
to govern the complex, affluent societies with a semblance of efficiency. Most
of the time, our political leaders seem to drift, helplessly, with the vagaries
of political opinion, and, from the day they have been elected to office, they
wonder, how to keep this fickle and shifty electorate on their side. The voters
lack the necessary broadness of view to guide their political judgement into a
more encompassing attitude, where they concern themselves with the problems of
the society as a whole, rather than the more egocentric and instinctive
question, how to get the most out of the candidate of their choice.
17 To take care is not easy. We
have difficulties taking care of ourselves, our dependents, our property and
our social and natural environments, because everywhere, we come-up against the
problem, that our knowledge is grossly insufficient, and, that we are
over-powered or intimidated by "expert opinions". However, there is
no need to be intimidated by expert opinion. If we have a good overall view of
the realities we are dealing with, we can use expert opinion as a tool. We
should be able to control this tool, and direct it in such a way, that it does
what we want it to do.
18 If we have a good, coherent view of the world, we can identify numerous pockets in this overall framework of our reality perceptions, where our knowledge is insufficient to solve a particular problem. Then, we may call-upon the experts, and, we may direct them in the tasks of maintenance and care, which are so closely linked to the criteria of overall, social and individual viability. However, we know, or, we should know, what we want. We should know, exactly, what has to be done, in order to solve a particular problem of maintenance or construction. Then, we are able to talk intelligently with these experts, and, we can find out, precisely, whether or not they are able to provide the service we are looking for.
19 Let us not be fooled by expert
opinions. They can not tell us, what our overall goals of maintenance and care
should be. An expert is asked, only, to elucidate a specific and relevant
problem, which lies beyond our capabilities of solving, but, this problem lies
not beyond our capability of understanding. How the expert solves the problem, is,
ultimately, his responsibility, but, what he does, and, what effect his work
has upon our goals and purposes, is our responsibility.
20 When we go to a physician, we
tell him, what we think is wrong with us, and a good physician will supplement
our story with a lot of pertinent questions, which will help him make a
diagnosis. After his inquiries and investigations are completed, he comes to us
and explains, what he has found, and what he thinks is ailing us. Then, he
suggests a variety of ways to correct, whatever is wrong, and, it is our
responsibility to understand, at least, in outline, what he is telling us, and,
what he proposes to do about it. Ultmately, it is our decision, whether or not
we let him go ahead with treatment or further investigations, and, if we think,
that he is wrong, or, if he proposes a form of treatment we do not trust, then,
we have the pefect right to discuss our doubts with him, and, to ask for a
second opinion, if our doubts are not removed by a frank discussion.
21 Similarly, if we go to a garage
because of a problem with our car, we want an accurate diagnosis; a clear plan
of action to correct the problem, and a realistic estimate what it is going to
cost us. After all, we have to decide, how much money we want to spend on
having a problem fixed. We have to make sure, that the work is done well and
efficiently, and, we see, how important it is to understand, in principle, how
a car works, what can go wrong, what has to be done to fix it, and, why it has
to cost the monies we are asked to pay.
22 All our tools or objects of use
may have problems or malfunctions, which we can not correct ourselves, or, we
do not understand, in sufficient detail, the nature of these problems in order
to correct the situation ourselves. Few of us know enough about electronics to
understand our radio or television sets, and, now, we are beginning to use even
more complex electronic tools, such as computers and laser-disc players, which
go far beyond our ability to know in detail. Unfortunately, selling or buying
such equipment is the easiest part, and, few technicians are available who are
competent enough to understand and repair these instruments expertly. This is
one of the reasons, why these instruments are built-up in "blocks" of
components, and, the task of servicing is facilitated, because the problem is
shifted from knowing the precise mechanism of what has gone wrong, to a rough
location of the problem. The problem is, then, "fixed", by replacing
the "block" which contains the "fault", whatever this fault
may be.
23 All expertise is, in essence, a
tool, which we, ordinary citizens and professionals alike, have to learn to
use. We know, how to operate a telephone, a radio, or a television set, and, we
handle with confidence all sorts of complicated equipment and machinery,
without knowing much about the internal details of structure and function. Yet,
we tell these instruments what to do. We command our automobile and steer it
wherever we want to go, without knowing much about the way it functions.
24 We should adopt the same
confident attitudes towards our numerous experts. We should tell them, that we
want clean industries that do not pollute or constitute a hazard. We should
tell our leaders, that we want a society that is run efficiently and fairly,
and, we should tell our politicians, that we want them to spend the public
monies frugally, because, after all, we will have to pay the costs.
25 We want our military experts to
design the tools, we think, we need, but, if we want them destroyed, then, our
military experts and their political leaders will have to listen to the will of
the people, because, after all, we should be able to determine, collectively,
the direction we want our society to go into, but, we will, also, have to learn
to listen to, and accept the honest advise of our experts, even, if it does not
correspond with what we want or expect to hear.
.......
Summary
1. The only alternative to growing old, is to die young.
We worry about the future, without addressing the problem, how to age
gracefully.
We tend to forget, that our requirements and ambitions are changing
continuously.
Can we die in peace?
Thinking about life, and the gift of time.
A combative method to solve the problem of death.
Death is, once again, what it appears to be.
The concepts of natural evolution may give us a "bad taste" about the
nature of living existence.
The "evolutionary" view of life takes-away the promise of eternal
life, but it also removes the fear for eternal damnation.
The processes of death are a necessary and inevitable corollary to the
processes of life.
We can cope with death, adequately, in a framework of reflective understanding.
A gradually diminishing flow of vital energies.
A life-form is a temporary actualisation of a possibility to exist.
Anonymous contributions and contributors.
Being grateful to those, who have made a conscious effort to reduce the impact
of their existence upon the environment.
Living a life-style of as much independence and self-sufficiency as possible.
The last contribution we can make.
2. The hall-mark of maturity is the ability to take care.
The instinct of "holding-on" to what we have.
Becoming less productive, without realising it.
Various ladders of achievement.
The dream from rags to riches has become an irrealistic expectation in our
modern, conglomerate societies.
The parameters of personal achievement, bureaucratic advancement, and financial
success.
Living a rather "submersed" life-style in our own particular world.
Our social position at the end of maturity.
The stress of living-up to expectations.
A time for sober reflections.
Many of us remain anxious and frightened children all our lives.
We all have to earn a living.
We have to give an honest day's work for our wages.
Why social justice brings the inevitable corollary of the need to make a
contribution to society.
The need to anticipate the stresses we are likely to encounter.
A large variety of circumstances.
The ability to survive, be content, and stay alert.
The freedom and ability to reduce the stress-load to a level we are comfortable
with.
3. A brief review of the organisation of life.
The requirements of the living organisation.
The cell, and the city; comparisons.
Cellular mechanisms of "ageing".
Mechanisms of uni-cellular and multi-cellular reproduction.
A symbiotic unit of many billions of cells, requiring efficient channels for
the supply of energy and the removal of waste-products.
The multi-cellular organisation.
The science and art of medical diagnosis and therapy.
A good grasp is possible, without an intricate knowledge of details.
An inter-twining of ageing and disease processes.
Conditions that are too severe to be tolerated by living tissues.
Changes in the organisation of life, taking place "from within".
A variety of abnormal mechanisms.
Some ageing processes are not clear-cut pathological in nature.
A gradual decline of the ability to tolerate stress.
Understanding what is happening to us.
Excercising our mental and physical faculties gently, and with care.
When we accelerate the processes of wear and tear.
4. Why we have to acknowledge the unavoidable processes of ageing.
The trap of voluntary financial slavery.
We are all inclined to "live it up" to the hilt.
We forget, that our energies are going to decline.
The road of "diversions", to make us forget the stress of our
contemporary existence.
An ever more efficient web of enticements.
Why is it so difficult to adopt a life-style that does not consume all our
energies or earnings?
The harsh world of free-enterprise.
Sliding, imperceptibly, from a search for old-age security, to power-hungry
empire-building.
Fore-sight is a fragile and elusive quality, especially, for those, who never
excercised their faculties of initiative and endurance.
The consequences of a "collective insurance" against adversity.
The ambivalence of a state of intense inter-dependence.
Leadership requirements.
The Socialist Society.
An interesting parallel with the multi-cellular organism.
It is still rare to see the quality of "obligatory social
inter-dependence" in human societies.
Are we still talking about the processes of injury, ageing or stress?
5. Is a social entity, indeed, a living organism?
The qualities of organisation and regulation.
Varying degrees of inter-dependence and cohesion.
The inter-dependence of "national units".
Human nature makes it impossible to force a state of social cohesion entirely
by "raw power", but, neither can it be done by persuasion alone.
The functions of the genetic and cultural codes.
The central nervous system of a large-scale social environment has to be
"created" by a conscious, collective effort.
Ageing and disease processes in society.
Can a social environment "take care" of itself, and age in a state of
health and wisdom?
A flowing and un-interrupted line of developments.
Getting worn and stifled by imperfections.
A tentative parallel with the social unit of multi-cellular existence.
Inter-dependence in a framework of essential equality.
Prudent fore-sights.
When we tighten the noose of financial enslavement for the rest of our lives.
Looking forward to the time when mankind grows older and overcomes the
turbulent upheavals of its early youth.
6. What are the signs of an ageing society?
A conglomerate of numerous smaller social organisations.
The simpler model of a "special-interest" organisation.
A dubious legal claim to "sovereignty".
Nations are not equal.
The solution of a gradual fading of national boundaries.
Average citizens may be more inclined to listen to the arguments of the social
rather than the military solution.
Dreaming about the utopian prospects for a peaceful mankind.
We have to know what constitutes a condition of social and individual health.
A review of the conditions of childhood and adolescence.
Qualities of a wise and benevolent society.
The feeling, that it is good to belong to society.
Measuring the opinions and attitudes of people.
A dramatic rise in the level of social awareness.
The difference between being wise and spine-less.
The folly and futility of a global conflict.
Becoming more patient, in spite of the fact, that time is running-out.
We see, more clearly, the nature and purpose of society.
The care we have to give to our social environment.
Getting people to care about justice for everyone; on a global scale.
7. The importance of the ability to care.
The corner-stone of social health.
A role for the older generations.
The need for careful thought.
Attitudes of good-will and charity are not sufficient.
Essential equality is a right; not a gift dispensed by the privileged.
Being careful with the environment.
A few generations hence, our ideological struggles will seem irrelevant.
We are becoming quickly more inter-dependent; apparently, more rapidly than we
can comfortably cope with.
We all have to get involved in thinking about the destiny of human existence.
Our leaders want peace, but do they know how to establish or preserve it?
To care is to speak-up, whenever we have an opportunity to do so.
Let us study, reflect and think, before we speak or act.
We have to measure our energies carefully.
The most urgent priority is to reduce the risk of a nuclear war.
Who knows, how close a nuclear war is?
Making sure, that the threat of nuclear weapons has disappeared forever.
The factor of increased social transparence.
The collective will can reign supreme.
Treaties and promises are not enough.
The price of neglect.
Scrutinising, carefully, all promises made by political candidates.
Social health will increasingly depend on the quality of collective fore-sight.
8. It is not easy to look well after ourselves.
Diseases and accidents do not happen "out of the blue".
Learning to read the warning signs.
When we begin to "take chances".
The criminal attitude of hoping to make "a quick profit", because it
always implies an unscrupulous attitude towards other people.
Relying on experts.
Professionals have made a life-time career of becoming an expert in one little
aspect of this gigantic complex of "taking care".
The need to keep an overall perspective in view.
The rise to power of the narrow specialist is a serious problem.
Will the "generalist" be able to make a come-back?
The art of making valid generalised statements is not appreciated at the
present time.
A baffling spectacle of squabbling experts.
A few examples of contradictory and confusing opinions.
The logic of advocating a return to religious standards of moral behaviour.
To take politically care of a large society is not easy.
There is no need to be intimidated by expert opinion.
We have to set, collectively, our major social objectives.
Ulimately, it is our decision to let our physician go ahead with a proposed
plan for investigation and treatment.
The ability to talk intelligently with an expert or professional.
Fixing a problem by replacing a "block of functions".
All expertise is, in essence, a tool to be used, intelligently, by the ordinary
consumer.
We also have to learn to listen to, and accept, the advise of honest experts
who are trying tell us something that is not pleasant to hear.
.......